So I made a card game...
It's kinda like Balatro meets Roulette (but not really) and it's crazy fun if you ask me. Drop a wishlist at the link below.
Demo coming very soon!
Finally heard the news about The Bazaar entering a maintenance mode of sorts. That's a tough one. I still think it's a great game players can get countless hours from, even if it doesn't get new content updates. Asynchronous multiplayer makes that possible, as long as they keep the servers online as promised.
Reynad took a really really really big swing with this one. There are certainly things we decided to do very differently in our creator-to-dev path, as we wanted to make games at a much smaller scale and budget. We also didn't always agree with his approach to communicating with players, but there's no doubt he made an absolutely incredible game at the end of the day.
That's a triumph that took a ton of courage and work and creativity and execution.
A crazy amount of players fell in love with the game and that's a huge win any way you look at it.
I'm comparing all time peaks. This isn't looking at 10 years old games' data from today. Its peak is higher than the peaks of some of the most beloved indie games of all time.
It's also now almost twice as high as last night. Surpassing legends like FTL, or more recently since that seems important to you, Blue Prince, the 2025 indie game of the year for many.
I feel like I need to clarify yet again, I am not excited about this. I don't think it's good.
I am basically telling you the end is here while pointing at a glowing orange mushroom cloud, and you are like, looks like a rain cloud to me.
AI has already won the war in game development.
This developer was quite open about his use of generative AI during development with various reddit posts and so on, openly discloses on Steam, and has had an absolute smash hit here. At the end of the day, a vast majority of players only care about the end result, not how the sausage is made. Most won't even notice if the game doesn't "look like AI." The AI games made with care will do just fine.
My dev partner Ben and I have discussed this a lot. I've always described myself as "pro human" more than "anti AI" and we've really prided ourselves on developing human skills, him coding by hand, and now me making pixel art by hand. I think we just enjoy the creation a lot. We've also commissioned artists to support more humans.
But of course we also use AI tools too. They're not "making the game" for us, but it's unavoidable in this age. I'm on Twitter, that's AI. I've googled stuff, that's AI. You'd damn near need an air-gapped machine and hand-write your entire engine and release the game independently of any platforms. That'd be badass, by the way! We're always trying to figure out the right line to draw where we feel good about what we've made.
So where do you draw the line? I think most devs have their own definition of the line they feel good about, and being open about that is the way to go. Buyers will either see that and align, or simply not care.
AI may have won, but I think taking pride in being "hand-made" will be a bit like artisan goods at a Farmer's Market, where some people will happily pay extra or value the craft, as opposed to buying a mass-market item at retail. Hopefully there's still value in saying, hey look, I made this thing!
My first solo developed game Slotbound just crossed $356K in gross revenue and 50,000 copies sold in its first 48 hours on Steam!
We also hit 9,377 peak concurrent players.
Still feels unreal. Thank you so much to everyone who gave my game a chance! ❤️
#indiedev#gamedev #Slotbound
That is because a huge majority of AI games are garbage. Their scores aren't worse because they are *labeled* as AI, they are worse because they're bad AI games.
But from this game, we can see that buyers don't actually care about the AI label itself at all.
We hoped that was a moat. It is clearly not.
You've perhaps read this as a gloat. I'm presenting it as a defeat. I wish my hand-made art was more valued by buyers, which is why my conclusion focused on framing it as an artisan effort against a mass-market effort.
Maybe too much Queen's Domain has just made me want to kite everything forever, haha.
His gap-closer is pretty insufficient against the crossbow, by the way. I just was missing like 60% of my on-target shots, so it was taking forever.
And again, I didn't have the energy this morning to lock-in for melee or get out a controller (assuming it works with controller).
@RiotIksar I had no problems with the dragon version, it was human form I felt like it should be hitting, but seemed like it was only connecting ~50% of the time, just kinda passing through.
But anyway, yeah it's cool! Writing at the beginning was awesome.
How are you reading this as me announcing a win? I'm announcing that those of us doing by hand have lost.
But also, this ISN'T someone trying to convince people. It's self-evident. He didn't actually say anything about his game being AI in his post. He didn't have to. He just talked about results, because they spoke for themselves.
Yep. I had to cheat to "Travel" my way to the Veldor death cutscene haha. I didn't have the energy to lock-in this morning to do it right.
Veldor phase 2 was giving me too much shit with flame stunlocks in melee, and then the dragonbow hitboxes were a bit hit or miss.
I think he might be cheeseable with one of those stone blocks in the middle of the field a bit.
Vibes were on point! I audibly chuckled at "red, then."
As a dev, I would prefer a note, even if you're declining, so I can open up that code for someone else.
That said, as a YouTuber, I try to respond, but sometimes it's just too many emails and I can't keep up, so I fail to respond to many.
So I hope people understand if you don't. I would certainly understand and hold no I'll will.
@VoidmawGames I know the feeling all too well! Even being a YouTuber for 10 years didn't train me for the exposure of bearing your soul when you debut a game.
@GarrettPetersen Didn't know which game was yours, so I was totally unbiased.
Yours is indeed the one that jumped out.
Looks so sick. I am an Aesprite amateur but learning everyday. Would be so pumped to make that.
I respect your passion. I think it's a noble goal.
Also thank you for actually engaging, really appreciate it.
I definitely wrote an attention grabbing opening line, and may have buried the lede a bit too much. I was wrestling a toddler while writing it out.
I will make a YouTube video tomorrow with more refined thoughts.
I will try to respond one more time, even though you don't seem interested in actually reading the words I write.
This post is me being sad that most players don't seem to value AI as a distinction, or at least don't notice. I'm saying that war is lost. It's clear they will buy AI games anyway.
Many devs hoped AI disclosure was a moat that separated their games. It doesn't seem so.
My conclusion is that I hope hand-making our game still earns it some perceived bonus value, like a hand crafted good at a farmer's market instead of a mass produced item at a store.
I'm trying to help shift the discourse here into something that might help support more human-forward game devs. Because I don't think the anti AI discourse has worked sadly.
If you guys attack people like me, who are doing the thing you want, making art by hand, and hiring artists, you're just cannibalizing your own goals.
@chrosaga We can all rest now that the legendary owaowa has shared their opinion.
But also, did you even read this? What do you think the conclusion was here my guy?
Do you think this is a pro AI post?
Media literacy, etc.
@VoidmawGames No, don't worry. I always get pissed off when I see something that's extra great. I know if I get mad that the game has "the stuff." This is the pixel art and juice I want to be when I grow up.
Also unrelated both my grandpas and my dad are named Eugene so that's fun.
My dude, it is one of the most 100 played games on Steam right now: https://t.co/MfimN8A5RK
It's all-time concurrent player peak is higher than indie icons like Dead Cells or Into the Breach.
Maybe you have some AAA thresholds for "smash hit" I don't know, but for one-person indie games, this is damn near as big as it gets. It is certainly the most lucrative openly AI-forward game we've seen yet.
Don't me mad at me for reporting the numbers. I'm over here hand-making pixel art for my game. I'm just the messenger.