@jasonmcgowan@CoachJayHill Thanks for all you’ve done for BYU Football, Jay. No matter what you choose, you’ll always be a Cougar and have our utmost respect. You’ve built something special here and I hope the reasons to stay outweigh the reasons to go. An incredible leader who teaches by example. GoCougs
Honestly, this is the hardest ranking for me to accept.
Miami shouldn't have played for OT twice.
ND had a weak schedule, and we knew they probably needed to start 1-1.
BYU ... lost to a spectacular team on the road and beat everyone else.
https://t.co/f9xVqf9F1t
Great work here by @RedditCFB. Comments and images are from them.
Take a look at these altered graphics by ESPN/ABC from this past weekend:
#1: Shown on the majority of broadcasts & excludes teams ranked 11th and 13th.
#2: shown during the BYU-UCF game. For this one, ESPN decided for the "W-L vs RANKED OPP" stat to only include games against teams who were ranked at the time of play instead of games vs current CFP ranked opponents. ESPN didn't convey this distinction to the audience so any casual viewer would probably think that BYU's resume wasn't Comparable to Oklahoma and Alabama.
#3: ESPN finally gets it right and shows an unbiased graphic during the Notre Dame-Stanford game which started in the 10:30 PM EST. Look at how the statistics differ between this graph and what was shown during the BYU-UCF game.
#4: BYU excluded from graph that was shown during the CFP ranking show. Now Pitt and Tennessee have both fallen out of the CFP rankings so Oklahoma, Alabama, Notre Dame and Miami all lost a ranked win compared to what was shown Saturday. Maybe that's why they went back to excluding BYU from the discussion as now BYU has a better or equal(Alabama) record against ranked opponents compared to the other bubble teams.
If you're going to penalize a 1-loss Power Conference team for a weak strength of schedule... BYU's SOS is better than Ole Miss and Notre Dame.
If you're going to penalize a team for not having the strongest power ratings (which incorporate prior year's history and recruiting rankings)... BYU's FPI is higher than Oklahoma's.
If you're going to penalize a team for a non-competitive / bad loss... Alabama lost by 14 to a team with a losing record and Miami lost to two unranked teams.
If you're going to use strength-of-record like you indicated you would, BYU's SOR is the second highest of teams 6-12.
BYU also (1) made its conference championship game and (2) if you sum up the wins of the teams it has beaten, it is THIRD in the country. It is hard to win games and BYU has beaten a lot of teams with a lot of wins.
This. Makes. No. Sense.
The @CFBPlayoff should be ashamed of itself. It has literally contorted itself into a pretzel to avoid putting BYU where it should be ranked (somewhere between 6th - 9th).
RT to get the info out there. They need to feel pressure.
@jasonmcgowan@kalanifsitake You represent us well in public, but more importantly, your influence extends beyond the field. You are teaching young men how to use football as a platform to do good, specifically for children/families facing adversity. I will always be a Kalani fan and I hope you stay at BYU!
@jasonmcgowan@kalanifsitake Balancing the inherent violence of football with a Christlike life is a rare challenge, and few even attempt to reconcile these two seemingly opposite goals. I don’t think anyone has navigated this better—or represented BYU and the Church with more dignity—than you.
BYU is the 8th best CFB team in the nation per the avg of the 64 independent ranking systems included in today’s Massey Composite
Yet the CFP committee & AP
Voters have seen fit to underrate BYU YET AGAIN!
It would be funny if it weren’t so persistent, obvious, & serious in leaving the Cougs out of the CFP field
THIS IS NOT OK!