@_SteveRyan@LilahRPGtt Maybe do a bit of reading and look at the actual figures instead of blindly swallowing whatever political promises she’s blabbing about. There’s a difference between hearing someone explain a policy and understanding whether the numbers actually stack up.
Giveaways of what exactly? Someone who can put a sentence together, structure an argument and pick apart someone else’s points? That’s called being able to communicate and think critically. Hardly exclusive to AI. You’re clutching at straws here. Sounds more like you can’t fathom someone on Twitter who actually paid attention in English at school. But maybe I should start using AI to make it easier for you to keep up lmao.
And as for the rest of it, you’re throwing a few different things together and acting like they all prove the same point. Murdoch owning a large part of the media, journalists speaking out about editorial freedom, the ABC giving Hanson airtime and Hanson making herself look bad are all separate things. One doesn’t automatically prove the other.
I’m not saying Hanson is above criticism, and I’m not dismissing what those journalists have come out and said. But that doesn’t mean you can just lump everything together and expect it to back up your entire argument. You’re entitled to dislike Hanson, that’s fine. But actually addressing what I’m saying would be a better start than throwing insults around and making assumptions about people.
And there it is again. You keep insisting I’m defending Hanson. I’m not even a One Nation supporter and have never defended her Port Arthur comments.
You seem incapable of separating criticism of your argument from support for the person you’re criticising.
I’m asking you to back up what you’re saying. That doesn’t mean I’ll necessarily disagree with you. It means I expect you to stand behind your claims with evidence and be prepared to defend them. Surely that’s a reasonable expectation in a discussion.
I haven’t asked you to respect Hanson, excuse her conduct or overlook anything she’s said. I’ve asked you to address what I’ve actually argued instead of putting words in my mouth.
And this is part of the problem with politics today. People see something online, accept it at face value and then treat anyone who questions it as though they’re defending the person being criticised. There’s a difference between being informed and simply repeating what you’ve been told.
Calling me brainwashed doesn’t resolve that problem. It just gives you another label to throw around instead of engaging with the point.
You keep congratulating yourself for producing a list of controversies, but you still haven’t grasped the point.
I never claimed Hanson has a spotless record. I questioned why you think listing unrelated controversies involving her and other party members somehow answers the actual discussion.
There’s a difference between establishing that someone has a controversial history and demonstrating that their position on a particular issue is wrong.
You haven’t done the latter. You’ve just repeated the former and declared victory.
Calling that a deflection doesn’t magically make it one. It just saves you from having to address the distinction.
That’s a lot of confidence for someone whose entire argument amounts to “go away”. You haven’t challenged a single claim, addressed a single policy or offered an alternative. Just insults, eye-rolls and predictions about the future. If you can’t argue the substance, at least have the honesty to admit it. Political debate isn’t about whether you like the person speaking. It’s about whether you can answer what they’re saying.
You managed to call someone barely coherent while producing an argument that can’t get past your own political prejudices.
Let’s unpack this. You invoke Murdoch, throw in Zionism, make a sweeping claim about media ownership, then declare Hanson a piece of shit as though that somehow establishes whether the reporting about her is accurate.
Do you actually understand the difference between media ownership, editorial independence and journalistic accuracy? Because they’re three separate questions, and you’ve made no serious attempt to address any of them.
Murdoch’s political views don’t establish that every journalist working for his outlets follows his position. The ABC giving One Nation airtime doesn’t establish that its reporting is impartial either. And your personal contempt for Hanson certainly doesn’t establish that every criticism of her is justified.
You’re demanding intellectual rigour from someone else while offering nothing but guilt by association, sweeping generalisations and schoolyard insults.
The original discussion concerned two media organisations being excluded. Yet somehow you’ve managed to turn it into a rant about Murdoch, Zionism and how much you hate Pauline Hanson.
That’s not an argument. That’s a collection of political grievances looking for a conclusion.
If you have evidence that the reporting was accurate, produce it. If you have evidence that it was misleading, produce that too.
For someone so preoccupied with everyone else's intelligence, it's remarkable how little you've demonstrated of your own. All that condescension, and not one argument worth taking seriously.
That’s a lot of words to avoid addressing the actual issue.
The original discussion was about two media organisations being banned. Instead of defending their journalism, you’ve resorted to dumping every controversy, accusation and questionable association you could find involving Hanson and people in her party.
Do you actually have an argument about the reporting, or is this just an exercise in seeing how many Google results you can copy and paste?
Let’s get something straight. The ABC and The Guardian aren’t above scrutiny simply because they’re media organisations. Journalists don’t get a lifetime exemption from criticism, and their reporting doesn’t become automatically accurate because they claim to be holding politicians accountable.
At the same time, Hanson doesn’t get to treat legitimate scrutiny as an inconvenience and exclude journalists without facing questions about transparency.
That’s the actual debate. Media accountability, journalistic standards and political transparency.
Your list doesn’t establish whether either organisation reported accurately, whether their coverage was fair or whether the ban was justified. It just establishes that you have a collection of things you dislike about Hanson.
If you’ve got evidence that addresses the original issue, present it. Otherwise, you’re not dismantling anyone’s argument. You’re changing the subject and hoping the length of your copy-paste job will do the heavy lifting.
Try arguing the issue instead of attacking the person.
These are things worth looking into properly before jumping on the bandwagon. You’d be surprised how much has been thrown at her that either turns out to be wrong, taken out of context or has an explanation people conveniently leave out.
I’m not even a One Nation supporter, but I can look at an issue without automatically dismissing someone because I don’t agree with everything they stand for.
Immigration needs to be balanced with our ability to actually house the people coming into this country. We can’t keep bringing people in faster than we can build the homes and infrastructure needed to support them. That puts more pressure on housing, services and the people already living here.
That doesn’t mean immigration needs to stop altogether, or that policies can’t change over time. It’s about addressing the problems we’ve got now and getting things back into balance.
@LukeCha65346511@TheKennyDevine@PaulineHansonOz Just ignore what the others are saying, can’t argue or debate with people that are “never wrong”. One using google for their replies already sums it up lmfao😭.
Building infrastructure is part of a government’s job, but it doesn’t mean Victoria’s problems have been solved. Crime is still a serious concern, and despite some recent improvements, recorded offences remain considerably higher than they were a few years ago. Then there’s the $6.55 million machete amnesty program, which collected thousands of weapons, including other knives. But collecting knives in bins isn’t the same as tackling the causes of violent crime. How about we start looking at the actual outcomes, value for taxpayers and whether the government is keeping Victoria safe? The Lego insult is a nice distraction, but it doesn’t answer any of that.
I agree government needs to play a bigger role, but getting private companies out of the housing market altogether isn’t the answer either. There’s a difference between regulating large investment firms buying up existing homes and removing private investment from housing altogether. You still need private builders, contractors and investment to get homes built. It’s about getting the balance right, managing population growth and making sure supply actually keeps up with demand.
This is why immigration needs to be properly regulated too. Governments need to have realistic targets, enforce visa conditions and deal with people who overstay their visas. You can’t have a sustainable immigration system without proper planning and enforcement. It’s a harsh reality, but ignoring those responsibilities doesn’t help anyone.
And to be fair, Trump has actually recognised that housing affordability needs to be addressed through policy, not just by telling people to build more houses. His administration has taken steps to reduce regulatory barriers and make construction easier. That’s the sort of practical action I’m talking about. You need policies that actually address the problem, not just slogans about building more homes.
You can dislike Trump for whatever reasons you want, but that doesn’t mean you have to dismiss every policy his administration puts forward. If a policy helps increase housing supply and improve affordability, that benefits everyone, including legal immigrants who contribute to the country. That’s the point I’m making.
I’m not disputing that immigrants contribute to the economy. Of course they do. But that doesn’t mean the extra demand on housing and infrastructure magically disappears.
And this whole “just build more houses” argument sounds great until you actually think about what’s involved. You can’t just flick a switch and have thousands of houses appear overnight. There’s planning approvals, land availability, construction costs, materials, labour, infrastructure and years of work involved. Who exactly is supposed to make all that happen, and how quickly?
That’s my point. Governments need to consider how many people they’re bringing in alongside how many homes they’re actually capable of delivering. You can’t keep increasing demand and then act like building enough housing to catch up is some simple overnight fix.
I’m Australian. We’re watching these pressures play out here, so forgive me if I’m not convinced by the idea that it’ll all sort itself out by simply building more houses.
I’m not arguing that immigrants don’t contribute. I’m asking why acknowledging the pressures that come with population growth is apparently such a controversial thing. Those two things can be true at the same time.