@PatBrown954 Bauer had 3 positive WAR seasons since 2018 career WAR of 2.0. .4 .6 and 3.3 in 2026. Career since 2018 2B 100 HR 84 avg 223. JD 4 positive WAR seasons. 2021 &22 -.6 & -.4 playing 33G &53G resprlectively. Career WAR 15.7 2B 155 HR 70 RBI 295 & 254 career avg. JD is better.
@FoulTerritoryTV If Sox are not targeting Peralta or Skubal, Houck Oviedo Kutter, especially Houck give Sox s shot at Crochet Tolle Suarez Houck Bennett Bello. 6 man should be used with all these starters in place
@JackLautaret@ChatSports This is the smarter trade but I rather send Durbin and hope Mead puts up 25 to 30 HR. I like Durbin, great D at 3B but his bat profiles as a 2B. If I thought Adley Abreu could get Seth Gray Curtis Barco DeCaro, I make the move signing Jeffers.
@ChrisCotillo@FenwayRundown@Sean_McAdam Houck looked like a great 2 if not an ACE prior to injuries. He shoukd get every chance to win a spot and potentially create a big 4
@ChrisCotillo@FenwayRundown@Sean_McAdam I love for this question to be answered. If Duran posted a good, incredible very good and a poor year, doesn't history and facts project JD will out preform Bauer 8 poor 1 elite year, Mead a mess until 87 very good games. Why are these 2 being counted over a JD's evidence?
@pesky_podcast I wrote the same post. Facts, not speculation of one poor year, JD outperforms Mead Bauer Abreu Durbin Adley. I rather trade high on Abreu and Wilson to get the superstar needed. Wilson Abreu to Pitt for Bubba Seth Gray Curtis Barco +1. Sox trade Bennett Bello Romy Masa $ for π
@ChrisCotillo Abreu isa beloved in RF. His stats scream streaky. 2 great months of wRC+ 140 &168 mixed w 4 wRC+ <100. JD had 2 good and 1 elite yr prior to a bad year. Evidence would dictate it is more likely JD outperforms Mead, Bauer Adley Abreu Rafaela in 27. Why again is JD the odd man?
@empeefive@ChrisCotillo Bauer has been terrible. I don't care if he was good in 2026. 8 prior years, horrendous. A 1.7M risk vs 58M trade Abreu and Durbin, Abreu had 2 months of a 168 & 148 wRC+ w 4 months well below 100. Durbin definition of avg. Mead risk. Duran cuteness stares 26 outlier.
@jimsoxfan A 1.7M gamble than Casas stays healthy better than a 58M gsmble Bauer will debunk 8 bad seasons and continue his 2026 campaign. Regression is more likely for Bauer while Casas Duran Houck great Comeback POY candidates. These half measures and overpaid trades killed momentum
@FoulTerritoryTV@timbhealey I agree. Houck Kutter Oviedo Holobetz Wehunt w Valera Monegro by September is plenty. My concern is an Anthony Adley Wilson Bauer Mead Abreu Rafaela Durbin Story (Arias) any better than Anthony Duran Rafaela Adley Wilson Story Mead Arias Casas DH w Abreu Durbin Bennett trade
@tylermilliken_@ByAndrewParker Adley AS AS IL IL IL Wilson 35, Bauer 8 bad seasons added for 58M. Early sent for Mead who was dumped 2x before a good half. Yet Duran 15 WAR and 3 very good seasons w one bad, trade him and his 11M. Casas 1.7 40 HR potential dump him yet count on more expensive bad players??
@jimsoxfan@bradfo JD Rafaela Anthony Wilson Bauer Adley Mead Durbin Arias. Casas Yoshi Story Gasper bench. Abreu Romy Canpbell maybe Masa Casas + $$ mid ST Trade to Pittsburgh for Bubba or Seth Gray C Barco DeCaro Curiel. Durbin Abreu Masa Casas w Mead 3B Arias 2B Story 2B. Duran Houck CB POY
@jimsoxfan This is a silly move. He deserves a chance. 3 months is not a real chance. Outfield log jam, 1B Logjam and too many questions marks in Bauer, Miller Abreu, (2 incredible months w 4 below avg months at the plate) Durbin great D lack of power at a corner infield spot. Mead.
@timbhealey This would be silly. Trade him to A's or Pittsburgh. A's get Campbell Ziehl Oviedo for Servino Nett and a lottery type prospecr. A's have plenty of space to allow KC to succeed. I think KC would put up similar numbers to Bauer Mead and Durbin.
@tylermilliken_ McGonigle Tolle Early PCA Camerio Aranda Skenes Merrill weatgerholt Woods Skenes since 2024. I think Rafaela Abreu all improved year over year. Anthony?? If healthy what will we get. Lastly, Boston has not given players much time. Campbell great April then 2 yrs in AAA.
@tylermilliken_@Section10Pod Explain, JD has a much better history than Bauer. Still, everyone wants JD gone and Bauer in Boston over his career year in 2026. Seems silly. Same argument with Mead. Dumped by TB and CWS then turned into Early over 87 good fames. Adley has been ok yet injury ridden since 23
@tylermilliken_ 1. The target was a RH bat with pull side lift power. Bauer is a role player with one good season under his belt. Durbin is a league avg player whoke Mead cost Boston Early over 87 career games. Yet, Duran, one bad season and everyone wants to dump him for lesser talent.