@westle3go@mrtiniv@Lilrock4444 I think what people miss is that the exposition on stuff like this is usually saved for last. We’ve gotten a few tidbits through the final sagas and it’ll all come together soon. Beginning with the inevitable attack on crossguild by the navy
@westle3go@mrtiniv@Lilrock4444 I think the biggest thing is, that they treat “sword skills” as a fancy certificate you get for completing sword courses or something when it should be something that offers you a combat advantage against other swordsmen
@westle3go@mrtiniv@Lilrock4444 When someone says shanks is better in haki but mihawk is better than shanks in sword skil, the least they can do is paint the picture and explain what is sword skill and how is it separate from haki application on a sword for combat
@westle3go@mrtiniv@Lilrock4444 My thing is, everyone thinks shanks is strong but people want him to be stronger than the strongest swordsman despite the illogic lol
I don’t even think there’s anything wrong with shanks being stronger if it made sense and didn’t outright violate mihawk’s standing in the story
@westle3go@mrtiniv@Lilrock4444 I’ve seen some people suggest it requires maki as well. Imu’s explanation that it resides in all things makes me think that irs accessible just like haki but might be harder to utilize
@westle3go@mrtiniv@Lilrock4444 I like that you’re heavy on logical consistency in the writing as well though, the issue i see with shanks fans specifically is that they can’t explain half the things they believe and how that preserves the narrative lol
@westle3go@mrtiniv@Lilrock4444 I think his personality has been made pretty clear as far as not wanting to engage in those sort of things when he had the emperor title on his lap. Especially with the complete power of the WG being something that I don’t think even 4 emperor crews at full power could overcome
@westle3go@mrtiniv@Lilrock4444 All that in mind though, I’m too heavy into BB being final villain now with the circumstances of elbaph. Imu had the aura and presence but the build up bb has been there from the beginning he just happens to look pathetic at times
@westle3go@mrtiniv@Lilrock4444 I would need it addressed in the manga so that there isn’t an unnecessary logical inconsistency in the writing. Whether it be that his first world form or something turns him into something else entirely or that its straight up stated that he’s the strongest swordsman
@westle3go@mrtiniv@Lilrock4444 I just gotta disagree there. I think it wouldn’t make any sense for him to stop dueling him if he still had the ability to push him to his limits. I think the loss of an arm and inability to forge a stronger blade are too things that are to significant to toss to the side
@westle3go@mrtiniv@Lilrock4444 Same way people get upset at the idea of mihawk being over legends like rocks and roger. There are way more than enough fighting styles for oda to use to keep them from getting compared to mihawk. But he doesn’t do that and leaves all these angles to argue for mihawk’s superority
@westle3go@mrtiniv@Lilrock4444 Yeah and Initially I figured you could just explain that by using the “hidden from the world” excuse for imu, but the more I think about it from a writing standpoint why would it be necessary for Oda to do that when its simple enough to just separate the fighting styles
@westle3go@mrtiniv@Lilrock4444 Cause I struggle to see where that fight would be placed if not the very end. In any case the shanks v mihawk thing is just endless cope protect him from falling under mihawk. They’re here everyday begging to make shanks an “exception” for no reason other than liking him more lol
@westle3go@mrtiniv@Lilrock4444 No because you could argue for imu being a final villain. Shanks is nowhere close to that. In any case that argument has been shaky lately which is why I think things are leaning towards mihawk being superior as a combatant with BB taking the top spot before the final fight
@westle3go@mrtiniv@Lilrock4444 The way oda has been presenting imu this arc has been sus for a couple of reasons. The main one being how he’s had him show this many forms this soon
@westle3go@mrtiniv@Lilrock4444 Not how it works. The argument against shanks is ironclad. Shanks niggas been trying to leach off imu like they have anything to do with eachother . What i realized is there’s no reason for oda to limit mihawk as long as imu isn’t the final villain