This is racist and sinful rhetoric that seeks to harm and to divide. It is disturbing that it comes from a candidate for public office. An apology is called for. @FWdiocese@NTCatholic@TXCatholic@USCCBGovRel#Txlege
Public officials may opine about theology, as is their right.
The Successor of Peter teaches. This is his office.
If what he teaches doesn’t sound like what we want to hear, we should admit the likelihood that the problem is in what we want to hear, and not in what he teaches.
@johnddavidson Your use of the word "faithful" is doing some interesting work in this post to distinguish itself from the teaching of those ordained as successors of the apostles, even more so in appeal to "especially those outside the Catholic Church".
But it's not doing anything Catholic.
@JasonLouMiller And, if you watch the whole clip from MS NOW, I explained — as I did in the article — how to focus on the Gospel instead, as the pope calls us to.
https://t.co/0Km8YaRG8T
@GuyRancher@americamag Another anon account disparaging the Vicar of Christ with nonsense from Trumpist talking points. News at 11.
Leo is speaking as the pastor of the whole church, calling us to work for peace and reject warmongering. Let those who have ears hear.
It's understandable for Catholics to be outraged by President Trump's attack on Pope Leo Sunday evening.
But follow the pope's example rather than taking the president's bait.
Mr. Trump wants the focus on him. Pope Leo points us to the Gospel and its call to peace.
.@SSawyerSJ on Pope Leo and the American President: "Christian faith is being misused and disgraced... But the Gospel demands more from us than to be outraged on its behalf." https://t.co/nTZkDJWxa2
Pope Leo XIV responded to President Trump’s social media post saying:
“I do not look at my role as being political, a politician. I don’t want to get into a debate with him. I don’t think that the message of the Gospel is meant to be abused in the way that some people are doing.”
I doubt Pope Leo XIV will lose any sleep over this, before he begins his pilgrimage to Africa tomorrow. But the rest of us should. Because it is unhinged, uncharitable and unchristian. Is there no bottom to this moral squalor?
@Broomblossem@FeserEdward God in his providence may bring good out of evil, but that does not counsel either doing or threatening evil, nor testing God.
At this point, the most charitable thing I can say is that I will pray for you and I encourage you to examine your conscience.
Trump is threatening to ignore the most basic moral norm for the conduct of war: discriminating between military and civilian targets.
No matter how bad Iran is, no matter what leverage this threat gains him, the ends cannot justify these means.
https://t.co/Zst4JCivMl
This is absolutely correct. And a military refusal to carry out an unlawful order from POTUS could trigger an extraordinary crisis that only Congress could solve through impeachment/removal.
And this is happening as Hegseth has purged the military of some of its best leaders.
@Broomblossem And I don't see why you are still trying to get the ends to justify these evil means. It would still be evil no matter who was threatening it, but coming from the president and commander in chief, it also makes future reliance on that evil more likely. https://t.co/718jwQapqb
Exactly. He threatens things that are evil to degree 10, and then when he actually does things that are evil only to some lesser degree, the cult cries "See? Art of the deal!" ignoring the fact that the Overton window has still been moved in the direction of greater evil.
@Broomblossem If you truly can't see why it is both immoral and bad strategy to threaten to do something so evil that your defense of issuing the threat hinges on the assumption that it won't actually be done, then you are demonstrating how entertaining such evil corrupts the mind and soul.
I mostly avoid commenting on what President Trump says from day to day, while pulling no punches in my assessments, whether positive or negative, of his policy. His Iran ultimatums feel different. Making such threats is a policy. If he were to follow through on them, the consequences would be immediate, irreversible, and catastrophic on a world-historical scale.
So while some will inevitably insist he should be “taken seriously rather than literally,” or that he is executing a sophisticated “madman” strategy in a complex game of 5-D chess, or that he needs everyone’s steadfast support to maximize his leverage, now rather than later seems the time to say that the actions that he is proposing would be a disaster for our country, both strategically and morally, which makes the remarks themselves a terrible mistake.
Simply put, what’s the point of all this? If these are empty threats that we all know he will not carry out, then they are ineffective threats (the Iranians are on X too!), merely making the president and our nation look foolish. If they are not empty threats, then the president is asserting the American position that such actions are acceptable in this situation and ones we are willing to take. We are not living in some quantum thought experiment where he simultaneously is and is not serious. We cannot expect the Iranians, but only the Iranians, will believe him.
Whether the threats are empty or not, we should be willing to say: This is wrong. We should not establish a pattern of threatening escalation from a blockaded strait to elimination of a civilization. We should not launch strikes intended to devastate the lives of millions of people and take our nation to total war without indisputable justification, or before the American people have deliberated upon and assented to the path with full understanding of what total war might mean for them. Those principles are vital to our Republic, independent of whether the strategy could “work.”
But it’s also worth emphasizing that the strategy is a dead end. This war is actively weakening American power, increasing the danger to American citizens, and frustrating the president’s important efforts at addressing our many domestic challenges. It has closed a strait that was previously open, strengthened the incentive for other nations to pursue nuclear weapons, and in this most recent rhetoric made more plausible their use. Our choices for continuing the war appear to be catastrophic escalation of the air war or extensive deployment of ground troops, neither of which were planned or had support at the outset.
Stepping back from these threats and admitting such actions do not offer a path to resolving the conflict may be unpalatable, but it is by far the least unpalatable option available. Let us all hope cooler heads prevail.
In condemning deliberate attacks on civilian infrastructure, Pope Leo simply reiterates longstanding Catholic just war teaching, just as Catholics who defend Trump manifestly dissent from it. This is not remotely complicated for Catholics who put their religion ahead of politics.
@Broomblossem As we say in the editorial, "No matter how much the Iranian regime deserves to fall, … no matter how much leverage in negotiation the president may gain by these threats, those ends cannot justify these profoundly immoral means.
It's basic morals. Ends don't justify evil means.