@divineTrev@Gamebreak0r Yeah I’ll give it a read. Just to clarify before going into it, I specifically said OP and not all TCGs. For OP my current opinion is that it would work but happy to get more informed
@divineTrev@Gamebreak0r It’s not the win-con for everyone but read the room. Lots of games recently were going to time and a fair amount of accusations were thrown of players doing it on purpose. Makes for a very toxic and less skill-expressive environment. Chess clocks fix this particular issue
@divineTrev@Gamebreak0r Right but chess tournaments happen at scale with clocks without a problem. I am not suggesting removing the need for refs I am saying we eliminate one of the variables altogether so they can focus on other issues
@divineTrev@Gamebreak0r Where was it tried? I’d rather my refs be handling actual rule/sequence disputes than people being paranoid and accusing either side of slow playing. Clocks eliminate that. Also as a TO isn’t it easier to plan/count on a rounds ending when you have both sides with a clock?
@divineTrev@Gamebreak0r This is with how things currently are, doesn’t mean it can’t be improved. Rules should make it so that the type of deck you run doesn’t have an advantage (as much as possible) in a given format
@divineTrev@Gamebreak0r I would say try it. I’ve ran a few closed locals at my place with a chess clock. Worked great for One Piece. I agree it’s harder/different with games that have action chains
@divineTrev@Gamebreak0r If that’s true then there’s a flaw in game/amount of time per round. By your logic players are currently incentivized to do the opposite. Decks that can stall and win off time/life. At least with the former, there’s a finite, fair, objective outcome.
It gives a finite time to both sides. Won’t alter deck building any more/less than the current rules because your argument is a moot point where some people will build decks to optimize for rules. Sure. In One Piece it works because any action requires an acknowledgment/reaction by the opponent. It’s the same 35-40mins but fairly allocated. White/black and chess have the same moves but black plays completely different from white because it doesn’t have 1st move momentum and is at a slight disadvantage. Games, as much as possible, should be fair and objective. Having it on players to call on a judge when they suspect the other player is slow playing doesn’t solve it because by the time you think the other playing is playing for time you’re in a compromised spot where they have the advantage.