@CantonMan711@virelle_x No I didnt and grok proved it. You had to misrepresent my statements to grok in your question in order to get it to agree & the first screen shot proves that. At this point its not even the hunger tapping me out, its the intellectual dishonesty and disingenuousness. Goodnight.
@CantonMan711@grok@virelle_x The thing is I never actually said that or even implied it. I accepted that the 10 year-olds in question (i.e. that were women) were the pregnant ones. You just misrepresented my statements to grok in an effort to get it to return a favorable result.
@CantonMan711@virelle_x 3/ but I digress. I am hungry and you're logic isn't really staying consistent so I am going to take my leave and respectfully bid you a goodnight. Take care and God bless.
@CantonMan711@virelle_x 2/ Which brings me back to the fact that if its a purely biological thing then there has to be a concrete biological requirement to womanhood. If so, what is it? So far you've done more to prove my point that its not purely biological than I have.
@CantonMan711@virelle_x 1/ The 10 year-old example was because 10 year-old females are typically considered girls NOT women, and I was curious if the pregnancy was what you would consider the determining factor in them being a woman.
@CantonMan711@virelle_x So again, using your own words if beginning her menstruation process is a girl BECOMING a woman, when is she considered a woman (since the word becoming is indicative of being in the midst of an incomplete process). And biologically its females, not women.
@CantonMan711@virelle_x Then its not a concrete biological requirement. Which is the point. Gender is not a 1:1 biological construct and has various sociological aspects to it.
@CantonMan711@virelle_x We're not talking about imperatives, we talking about requirements. What are the BIOLOGICAL requirements of a girl to become a woman. Keeping in mind that the word 'requirement' means NEEEDED and/or NECESSARY.
@CantonMan711@virelle_x If biologically a boy becomes a man when he is able to father a child then LOGICALLY if he is never able to father a child he never becomes a man. PERIODT. Otherwise there has to be some other way or criteria by which he can become a man.
@CantonMan711@virelle_x You cannot say that being able to have children is a defining requirement to be considered a woman and then say that you dont need to be able to have children to be a woman. And site 'biological flaw" and the excuse.
@CantonMan711@virelle_x NO, THEY ARE BIOLOGICALLY FEMALE. A pregnant 10 year-old is generally NOT considered a woman. They are considered a child, and I challenge you to find one jurisdiction where that is not the case.
@CantonMan711@virelle_x If age was irrelevant we shouldnt have girls and that's the point. Girls and women are completely different in terms of what they represent. And age IS one of the generally accepted factors in determining the difference.
@CantonMan711@virelle_x 2/ The point is that we as a society already acknowledge that gender is subjective which is why we have girls and women, and why the line of demarcation that separates the two is subject to so many different interpretations. Now female, that's a lot more concrete a terminology.
@CantonMan711@virelle_x 4/ If its somehow tied to both then whats the magic combination of age and reproductive capability and how is that standard objective enough to not make the determination of gender (i.e. girl/woman) subjective (i.e. NOT singularly biological) and open to interpretation.