I disagree with this take.
Just because a card looks like a 10 doesn’t mean it’s a 10. There’s a reason professional grading exists. You’re not just paying someone to slap a number on a card. You’re paying for authentication, consistency, and a grade the market recognizes.
Anyone can claim their raw card is gem mint, but that doesn’t mean collectors should pay gem mint prices based on someone’s personal opinion.
And let’s address the whole “setting the floor for next year” argument. If vendors are intentionally inflating prices to establish a new market floor, that’s an attempt at market manipulation, not collecting. The market should determine a card’s value through actual supply and demand, not sellers artificially pushing prices higher.
Technology might make grading more accessible, but accessibility doesn’t automatically equal credibility.
At the end of the day, a raw 10 is still a raw card. If you want graded prices, get it graded.
Otherwise, you’re asking buyers to take all the risk while you collect the premium