Everyone gets feisty over comps.
I do comps college game to college game. I try to find measurable matches that pair with style of play and college tape of my comps.
If you're mad, stay mad.
While I'm not thrilled with the class, I'd hang my hat on Carnell Tate as the safest receiver. Not groundbreaking, but he has a high pedigree, great coaching, and proven performance. Hard to see him not deliver WR2 floor.
Cons:
- Not a terrific deep threat. Plenty fast to improve however.
- May be slow to transition to full NFL role without scheme help. Indiana quick RPO game.
- Needs to develop separate skills in man coverage
Draft Analysis: Omar Cooper Jr
Height: 6'0"
Weight: 199 lbs
College: Indiana
NFL Comparison: Rashee Rice
Pros:
- The epitome of a football player. Does the dirty work with detail. Tough.
- One of the best runners with the football. 4th in mossed tackles forced (27) in '25
- Good hands. Battles for the ball in 50/50 situations. Good tracking and focus.
- Will block at every level.
- Plenty athletic to play inside and outside. Transitioned to primary slot in '25.
Cons:
- Extreme lack of separation. All deep routes turn into contested situations
- Unnecessary jumping at the catch point.
- Whiffs far too often when stock blocking. Never sets his feet well, and fails to use his size appropriately.
-Weird fumble issues
Lack of broken tackles
Draft Analysis: Malachi Fields
Height: 6'4"
Weight: 218 lbs
College: Notre Dame
NFL Comparison: Bryan Edwards
Pros:
- Exceptional back shoulder receiver. Has a good feel of when to turn on the corner and plucks the ball away.
- Can be a terror for smaller corners with his size
Cons:
- Pretty capped ceiling in terms of athleticism. To be truly special will need a perfect landing spot that commits to his skills.
- Likely a slot-heavy receiver in the NFL.
- Reception chart is primarily MOF
Draft Analysis: Antonio Williams
Height: 5'11"
Weight: 187 lbs
College: Clemson
NFL Comparison: Khalil Shakir
Pros:
- A steady, efficient route runner. Can run a full route tree.
- Great release tape. Shoulder pad level is advanced. He climbs his stems well and avoids contact
- Clemson used him like the Lions use Amon-Ra. Motion, inside/outside, screens, even in line blocking digging out linebackers.
- Very good hands. Down year in '24 but looks to be an anomaly