@barriere_dr@Dr_Pouk@JLMelenchon@LCI Parce que il a besoin de pauvres pour survivre, supprimer la pauvreté et la précarité et il perd son boulot,il n'est pas idiot le Trotskyste
@Cathy_dubourg33 La question qui se pose ce n'est pas avait vous été de droite car le non est évident, mais est ce que la LFI vous paye ou vous êtes juste une naïve ?
Once you understand the degrowth scam, you'll understand everything else.
Including why Greta Thunberg went from climate to Palestine.
She launched the school climate strike at 15. In 2025, she sailed with a Gaza flotilla. This month, a clip went viral of her bursting out laughing when told Fridays for Future was still marching in Berlin. "They still do that?"
People call her a puppet. I think it's more revealing than that. She's a true believer who simply followed the ideology to its logical end.
Because the cause was never the point. The climate was a vehicle. Palestine is the next one. The target never changes: capitalism, and the free societies that built it.
To understand why, go back to the original problem.
Marxism needed a revolutionary subject: the worker. Poor, exploited, ready to tear everything down.
Except capitalism did the one thing Marx never saw coming. It made the worker rich. Wages, a car, a house, holidays, kids in college. The proletarian became an owner. And owners don't start revolutions. They defend what they've built.
The radical left was left with a theory and no people.
Marcuse said it in black and white in 1964, at the end of One-Dimensional Man. The working class has been absorbed by the system. Revolutionary hope now lies with the outcasts and outsiders, "the exploited and persecuted of other races and other colors." The revolutionary subject changes. The project stays the same.
Forty-seven years later, the theory became an electoral plan. In May 2011, Terra Nova, a think tank close to the French Socialist Party, published "Left: Which Electoral Majority for 2012?" The diagnosis: the working class is defecting to the National Front. The recommendation: build a new coalition, "the France of tomorrow." Graduates, young people, women, minorities, the banlieues.
I'm not making this up. It's written down, published, available as a PDF.
France's far-left leader Jean-Luc Mélenchon pretended to be outraged by it. Then he executed it better than anyone.
The man who once said he rejected the word "Islamophobia" marched on November 10, 2019, in a march against Islamophobia co-organized by the CCIF. An organization the French government dissolved a year later, calling it an Islamist outfit working against the Republic. In 2022, according to Ifop for La Croix, 69% of Muslim voters backed Mélenchon in the first round.
I don't blame the voters. People vote for whoever speaks to them. I blame the strategist who understood that a homogeneous community vote pays better than a universal message, and who sacrificed French secularism to get it.
And this alliance was no accident. In 1994, British Trotskyist Chris Harman laid it out in The Prophet and the Proletariat, with a line that became famous: sometimes with the Islamists, never with the state.
We know how it ends. In 1979, in Iran, the left marched alongside Khomeini against the Shah. Foucault gushed about "political spirituality." Four years later, the communist Tudeh party was banned and its leaders arrested. In 1988, thousands of political prisoners, many of them leftists, were executed.
The left thought it was using Islamism. Islamism was using the left.
Now, immigration. Why does this left defend it without ever setting a limit?
No need to imagine a secret plan. Just look at the incentives.
An electorate built on grievance needs the grievance to last. If integration works, if immigrants' children become entrepreneurs, homeowners, managers, middle class, they do exactly what the workers did before them: they leave the "victim" box. And they stop voting for the people who live off that box.
Assimilation is to the immigrant what growth was to the worker. The way out.
That's why this left distrusts assimilation, calls it "colonial," and fights every attempt to control the flows, without ever asking whether integration keeps up. It doesn't need to manufacture chaos. It just needs the chaos never to be resolved.
And who pays? First, Muslims who simply want to live free. Women told what to wear. Young people who want to succeed and keep hearing the system is rigged against them. Shop owners in neighborhoods abandoned to drug trafficking. Then everyone else.
The solution is the same as last time.
What lifted the worker out of the proletariat wasn't Marx or the Party. It was growth, work, and ownership.
What will lift these neighborhoods out of dependency isn't welfare or patronage. It's schools that demand excellence, a State that enforces the law everywhere, chosen and controlled immigration, and an economy that gives everyone a reason to defend their country rather than hate it.
The radical left needs victims. A nation needs citizens.