As in previous years, TMLR will pause new submissions over the upcoming holiday period from November 30, 2026 at 11:59 PM to January 3, 2027 at 11:59 PM (AoE timezone for both). We will resume accepting new submissions on January 4, 2027. Happy Holidays!
What is TMLR doing under a 300% increase in submissions?
- Suspensions of >150 authors
- Publicly naming major violations
- Submission quotas distinguishing slop patterns
- Desk rejections 6% → 53%; focus on clarity
- AI reviews evaluating soundness
https://t.co/TCFt0TB9RU
ICYMI, here's the latest post, where Co-EiC Nihar Shah asked authors of papers to be desk rejected about their own submissions. They couldn't answer his questions!
https://t.co/QT5URf24GP
TMLR now has a shiny new blog! By popular demand, the days of Medium are over. All the old posts are already ported, please check it out (and its beautiful colour scheme). Thanks to Managing Editor @PaulVicol for setting it up!
https://t.co/EQnkrqmkAg
Another detail that might be interesting to folks:
"The fraction of desk rejected papers at TMLR used to be about 6% in 2023 but is now at about 53%."
(Important caveat that our policies and stances towards desk rejection have shifted, not just submission quality.)
TMLR has faced a deluge of submissions, necessitating stricter desk rejection policies due to limited reviewer capacity
Co-EiC Nihar Shah reached out to authors of 10 papers slated for desk reject. Could they answer questions about their *own* submission?
https://t.co/vhX5w6gcx2
Spoilers: all 10 ended up being desk rejected.
- 1 paper withdrawn
- 1 author was too busy for a call
- 1 author no-showed
- Authors of 3 papers couldn't answer basic qs
- Authors of 3 papers could, but not technical qs
- 1 author answered all qs, but paper had a major flaw
Starting September 1, 2026, TMLR will no longer be considering survey papers for review. This is in part due to limited reviewer resources and significant required labour for reviewing surveys, as well as the evolving role of surveys in our field.
Some of the TMLR Editors in Chief are doing a meet-and-greet tomorrow at #ICML2026!
July 7 at 11 AM in The Platz
Come and:
- discuss new policies (submission quotas, AI reviewer)
- pick up stickers if you're an AE, expert reviewer, etc.
- just hang out!
TMLR will be experimenting with an AI reviewer, solely to judge submissions against the soundness criterion ("are the claims supported by accurate, clear, and convincing evidence?"). More details in the following blog post.
We're pleased to announce our newest Editor-in-Chief, Yoshitomo Matsubara (@yoshitomo_cs)! He started his term July 1, 2026. He has long been one of our most committed and thoughtful Action Editors, and we know he'll do a great job as a leader of the journal.
More details in our post: https://t.co/G2zGZL07ve
We understand this will (by design!) prevent submissions that authors would have liked to undergo review. But strong measures (this is one of several) are necessary to protect our valuable and human team of reviewers and AEs. 5/5
TMLR has been facing an significant uptick in the number of submissions since the start of the year. This is placing an extreme burden on our amazing team of reviewers and action editors.
To ease this burden, TMLR will be implementing submission quotas, effective July 1. 1/n
Members of our editorial team, including AEs and reviewers, enjoy doubled quotas. You can self-nominate to be an AE or a reviewer, see our FAQ: https://t.co/kXdVR4YMLR 4/n