As a Christian, one of the things I find hardest about this new incarnation of Twitter is that it seems to bring out the worst in us as Christians. A big reason for this is tied to the concept of "freedom of speech." ๐งต
@PSWsenate@matpolloy Understood :) Full confession, I'd never even noticed that line in TLJ till you pointed it out just now. I guess, in the end, there's no right answer; just a creative choice.
-We may have lost the new Stargate series, but I have gained incredible respect for the creative development team behind the original series:
-@BaronDestructo and the writing team were extremely dedicated to creating a new chapter of our beloved series, but also fiercely protective of it, so when he says the series "avoided the pitfalls of several modern remakes and reboots" we know he and the team fought the good fight.
-Lessor creators would have caved and made the slop. The Stargate creative team did not. For that, I am grateful. I'd rather have no new show, than one that "forgot where it came from".
@PSWsenate@matpolloy In Andor's case, it wouldn't have been appropriate. It would've pulled you out of the story that was being told, which was more grounded; and so Lucasfilm chose to use the swear words. Which is fine as a creative choice.
@PSWsenate@matpolloy Because they felt it was appropriate for the medium they were writing in. And, as I say, sometimes it worked; sometimes it really didn't, and was resoundingly mocked (NJO being a case in point).
@matpolloy@PSWsenate I think that's the thing; mental association is what makes a swear word work. In theory, I suppose you could find ways to evoke that same sense, but given we're believing this other galaxy uses all our other words anyway...
@matpolloy@PSWsenate But I remember even some New Jedi Order books where you had the incongruity of things like the Embrace of Pain moving to "Sithspit" and it just... didn't work. Not at all.
@matpolloy@PSWsenate Honestly? I think most of the time they infantalise the text, and actually pull you out of the story by making you laugh. They work fine in some contexts, maybe younger books or when done with a self-aware wink. I'm fine with them in the KJA books, for example; they work so well.
@PSWsenate@matpolloy Eh, it means tons to *some* Star Wars fans. I've seen it being repeatedly mocked by so, so many fans for as long as I've been in the fandom, and defended vigorously by others!
Iโm very confused when someone shoots a door panel. It either locks the door or opens it. What causes it to have a different reaction? What if youโre trying to lock it and you accidentally open it?
@SCentralized@Wexie14@StarWars5W From an article going up later today... "Dan has the curious distinction of being the galaxy's only real expert on this alien race, known as the Dor Namethians." ๐