@AuditeInsulae Indefectibility was never identified with one see’s triumphs or failures. Rome defected from the fullness of the orthodoxy, in ecclesiology and pneumatology. As St Vincent of Lérins wrote “cleave to antiquity, which at this day cannot possibly be seduced by any fraud of novelty”
@AuditeInsulae Sure, all of that doesn’t prove Christ abandoned His Church. But the harder question for Catholics is can Vatican I ecclesiology survive a situation where being a traditional Catholic seems to regularly require testing, reinterpreting, even resisting the living Roman magisterium.
@AuditeInsulae@PaulinusOfTrier@timotheeology I don’t think many traditionalist Catholics have wrestled with the gravity of this. Rome’s liturgical identity and continuity has dissolved. lex orandi, lex credendi is crucial. What does it mean when a communion’s normative experience of worship is distorted for generations. 2/2
@AuditeInsulae@PaulinusOfTrier@timotheeology I’m Orthodox Christian, but sympathise with the position the SSPX find themselves in. ‘traditional Catholicism’ is a tolerated subculture in the Roman communion. It is a drop in the ocean of Catholicism. Rome has moved on from its liturgical patrimony, probably permanently. 1/2
@AuditeInsulae@RorateCaeli There’s a deeper issue. Traditional Catholics are increasingly having to defend Tradition against the living magisterium. Rome is supposed to be the guardian of Tradition. This claim looks very fragile these days. Rome has moved decisively away from its past, never to return.
@FrMatthewLC ”Here, one should also mention the death penalty, for this also violates the inalienable dignity of every person, regardless of the circumstances” (Dignitas Infinita, 34)
@DrKwasniewski There’s a bigger issue here. If Catholicism is increasingly forced to appeal to tradition against missteps of the living Roman magisterium, then Rome’s claim to be the uniquely reliable interpreter of Tradition looks fragile. As Orthodox, we hold Holy Tradition as the sure norm.
@DrKwasniewski Francis seemed to teach the death penalty was always wrong regardless of the circumstances, now Leo seems to have followed suit. I agree capital punishment was always permitted. The dilemma is the living Roman magisterium is meant to be a safe proximate rule of faith. How so now?