@upholdparenti@NathanJRobinson Do you think there are voters who believe Trump is a progressive, and will only be convinced otherwise if he vetoes M4A?
@CalBearCanha@LGMets5150@baseballisdead_@jaysonst What happened in the 1980s is irrelevant. MLB expanded its postseason in 1995. Within 20 years, every team had made the postseason, a majority had appeared in the World Series, and 11 franchises won championships (the same number that won Super Bowls in that window).
@CalBearCanha@LGMets5150@baseballisdead_@jaysonst Can you not remember what you said yesterday? You called the Browns a “perfect example” and said they showed why NFL fans feel more excited about their teams than baseball fans. You don’t seem capable of following your own argument.
@CalBearCanha@LGMets5150@baseballisdead_@jaysonst The Wild Card era began in 1995, not 1985.
The Browns are one game over .500 after 9 games. The reason that “feels” exciting to you is that the NFL season is 1/10th as long, so teams literally cannot fall out of contention as fast. Nothing to do with the salary cap!
@CalBearCanha@LGMets5150@baseballisdead_@jaysonst The NFL has one team with a 10+ year playoff droughts. MLB has two (with a smaller postseason). There is no baseball team that has gone 20-30 years without a postseason appearance since the wild card era began. You are just making things up based on what feels true to you
@CalBearCanha@LGMets5150@baseballisdead_@jaysonst Ask a Browns if they feel like they can contend each year. Or a Cardinals fan. Or a Jets fan; they haven’t seen the playoffs since 2010, longer than any team in baseball
Every league has sad sack franchises, cap or no. There’s no league where “all teams are successful” obviously
@CalBearCanha@LGMets5150@baseballisdead_@jaysonst Every WS winner is, by definition, an exception. It’s been 11 years since the Royals won the WS… and 17 since the Yankees did. 40 since the Mets won.
It’s hard to win the WS, even for big spenders. But plenty of small market teams have had sustained success, as you conceded
@MattLoveless The Yankees’ most productive player this year was a pitcher making six figures. Phil’s was Sanchez, making less than $4m… even the Dodgers got more from Andy Pages than Kyle Tucker.
Prized free agents just aren’t that big of a deal in a sport like baseball
@MattLoveless Why not? Most baseball players never reach free agency. The vast majority of production comes from young players under team control, or unheralded veterans on cheap contracts. Not only does the Brewers model seem replicable to me - it seems like the model every WS team ever uses!
@MattLoveless What do you mean by 1?
That it's not a model to be replicated because he should be making way more? Or that other teams cannot duplicate it?
@MattLoveless I mean, once again: the Brewers just won a WS while getting below-average production from a $30M/year investment.
The differences you're citing are overstated. Every team needs to draft/develop well, while also signing FAs, and even great GMs miss sometimes. That's baseball!
@MattLoveless It's interesting that you say you don't mind giving up KWIII as a Seahawks fan. I think it kind of sucks that guys like Myles Garret and Giannis, who should be franchise icons, become toxic assets and have to be traded in order for those teams to compete.
@MattLoveless What we DO see is that fans in those leagues have to care way more about the ins and outs of cap rules and contract structure. Contracts are far more likely to become franchise-ruining albatrosses in those leagues, and that is bad for fans, IMO
@MattLoveless They didn't have to match that because they were able to sign him before he was a FA.
A capped system would either make such long-term deals illegal, or make them so onerous that stars would have to get salary dumped to bigger markets, the way Giannis just was.
@MattLoveless Yes, exactly, success in baseball is spread between big market teams that spend and small market teams that draft and develop. There is a correlation between spending and success, but it is by no means determinative or predictive.
So what exactly is the problem? And is i