Will

[Will @Will451923]

I say no. If you take away his 5 peak years where he is arguably the best player in baseball, he has 13 replacement level seasons. He’s one of the guys who is a lot better in memory than he was in real time.

[OldTimeHardball @OleTimeHardball]

You hold the deciding vote in the Hall of Fane case for Dale Murphy. Does he get in?

[Will @Will451923]

@OleTimeHardball He took their money. But he was the best player in the series. Yes. If MLB can take gambling money Joe can be in the HOF.

[Will @Will451923]

@VinnysCorner1 Top this.

[Will @Will451923]

@OleTimeHardball Yes. Schilling’s pitching WAR of 79.5 is sandwiched between Bob Gibson and Clayton Kershaw.

[Will @Will451923]

@OleTimeHardball Greatest bad ball hitter of all time. Can handle the cutter away and hit it to right. And the steel balls to meet the moment.

[Will @Will451923]

The problem you have is Vizquel, Smith and Aparicio had long careers so that they played past their peak at SS and lost points. A better comparison would be Simmons vs the others peak DWAR years.

[HT @HunterTreacy]

@OleTimeHardball There are only two contenders for this title: Belanger and Simmons.

[Will @Will451923]

@uscfan981 Wells was the best inning eater of his generation. The ability to take the ball throw 150 pitches every fifth day in the steroid era saved the rest of the staff fatigue on teams that played late into October. Not overrated.

[Will @Will451923]

@VinnysCorner1 It reminds me of when baseball didn’t suck.

[Will @Will451923]

@Jimfrombaseball Gossage for President 2028. Who’s with me?

[Will @Will451923]

@RossyPrime Don’t make us wish for forever wars.

[Will @Will451923]

@itsrosesm If it happens it will be a last day in office pardon.

[Will @Will451923]

@AntiLeftMemes Popeye’s fried chicken

[Will @Will451923]

@ojessie__ I dig chicks

[Will @Will451923]

@BBGreatMoments Seeing as how it was his age 39 season and you can only have a season like that at the age on the rocket sauce. I’d say it’s tainted.

[Will @Will451923]

@TroyPSilva Babe Ruth

[Will @Will451923]

@TroyPSilva Stan Musial

[Will @Will451923]

@TroyPSilva Andres Galarraga, Bobby Tolan

[Will @Will451923]

@ClayTravis Somehow you just knew she’d look like this. I’d wager a buck I could guess which spouse wears the fake penis at her house.

[Will @Will451923]

@PatriotEagle776 I know one thing. She’ll never swing on a man again.

[Will @Will451923]

@Bunni_54 @PatriotEagle776 Never put your hands on someone if you’re not willing to get hit back. Sorry Bunni. No such thing as a free shot.