Richard Cottingham (The Torso Killer): "I wasn't stupid, you know." He says it to two detectives in prison in 2014. For years he worked as a computer operator at Blue Cross in Manhattan and drove home to his family in New Jersey. Then he explains why no one linked the murders:
He never killed two women the same way. "Any place within driving distance that was not connected to me, I would try," he says. No pattern, no signature.
He was caught on May 22, 1980, at a Quality Inn in New Jersey, because motel staff heard a woman screaming in his room and called police. She survived. He was convicted of murders in New Jersey and New York and has been in prison ever since.
Retired Bergen County chief of detectives Robert Anzilotti kept visiting him for years, and the confessions came one cold case at a time. The detectives who sat with him say he wanted to control how the murders were told.
In the video below, the white-bearded Cottingham sits with his arms spread across the chair and argues with Anzilotti about the label. "I wasn't a serial killer," he says. Anzilotti reminds him he has claimed more than 80. "That fits the definition pretty well."
Later he says he never had any joy in it. "It was very hard." Then Anzilotti asks what the thrill was, and he answers: being able to do "the perfect murder every time."
In January 2026, police in Fair Lawn, New Jersey closed their only unsolved homicide. Cottingham, now 79, confessed to killing 18-year-old nursing student Alys Eberhardt in 1965. He told detectives he first saw her outside Hackensack Hospital and followed her home. No new charges were filed. He is serving life.
He has confessed to more than 20 murders. He claims 80 to 100.
He told them he couldn't count that high. He still says he wasn't a serial killer.
When he says it was never about joy, is that the truth, or one more thing he gets to control?