Our pools were routed part of this huge swap(s) through uniswap v4 and charged the hacker 5.47% on the initial massive impact he created.
The next few rebal swaps were charged between 1-4% so our LPs were properly compensated for:
1. being exit liquidity by the hacker
2. making the market for arbers to profit from
If you LPed in a vanilla pool (maybe 0.3% or 1% pool at best), you got gamed. The hacker is walking away with more than he should have.
Most LPs know impermanent loss and some have heard about LVR (loss-versus-rebalancing).
They look like different costs, but in expectation they are the same.
A simple 4-row table shows why and how to use it to your benefit as an LP ๐งต
This chart paints the picture. Any pool with fee/LVR < 1 has collected less in fees than the cost of being the stale-price counterparty.
Lets take a major pair like ETH/USD during a volatile period last week, almost all of the depth across Uniswap sat in pools below that break-even line. Nothing deeper than about $100K cleared it.
So if Fee/LVR was negatively correlated with depth over this period, two things might explain it well;
Arb flow outpaces swapper flow. Swapper volume goes to whoever offers the best execution, and there is only so much of it. This suggests that beyond a certain depth that it takes to win swapper flow, every extra dollar adds LVR and minimal fees.
Fees too low. If the deepest pools rely on arb flow for revenue, then pools with the highest fees will cover more of their costs compared to lower fee tiers.
However this doesn't always work, else everybody would always sit in the highest tier pool, but during less volatile periods the highest tier pools dont win as much flow.
That's the trade-off a fixed tier pool can't make, and it's why we built Ascnt pools to do this for you instead: a fee that adjust with the market.
Pool selection is an undervalued skill. You cant just watch APRs.
What if a liquidity pool could charge a ~2% fee and a ~0.01% fee on two swaps within minutes of each other and reach a 24h APR of 240%
That just happened in our SPCXon/USDC pool, here's why:
11:29pm a balanced pool state, where two-way flow is trading in a tight price range of +/-1%. These are the best conditions to provide liquidity with low risk of impermanent loss.
To win volume, the pool quotes low fees, the lowest of these swaps being 0.0116%.
11:39pm a series of 3 directional buys within a minute of each other, increase the pool price by a combined 1.467%. These are risky conditions to provide liquidity, if the fast directional price is sticky and never reverts, LPs may suffer (im)permanent loss.
To compensate LPs for the risk of IL, the pool charged these 3 swaps a fee of 0.21%->1.1%->1.95% respectively.
After directional trading cools off the pool fees do too:
5 minutes later the pool is charging <0.1% again.
10 minutes later the pool is charging <0.05% again.
15 minutes later the pool is chargin <0.02% again.
This is what smart liquidity looks like.