@zhongus_dongus@4Evil_Resident2 ok, im willing to concede that harry potter sucks way more than lotr at least, considering harry potter is now to be considered an extension of jk rowlings anti-trans ideological body of work. at least tolkien regretted writing some bad stuff
@FuckableF@4Evil_Resident2 yeah but its like v excessive for whats at stake. im not even talking abt anything groundbreaking here, again this has been a topic since the 80s
@zhongus_dongus@4Evil_Resident2 u can read lotr if ud like! im not saying that. just gonna say im not surprised that lotr gets appropriated for dehumanizing purposes again and again
@zhongus_dongus@4Evil_Resident2 and is it not fucking insane that i get shit on for having a problem with something that tolkien himself disliked??? im not saying that tolkien was a bad person, just that lotr is kinda bad
@FuckableF@4Evil_Resident2 u posted abt how tolkien had a hard time with his own writing in hindsight and yeah, i agree, its good tolkien felt that way cuz morally lotr is kind of a horrible story
@zhongus_dongus@4Evil_Resident2 lotr functions similarly to that. killing orcs is a little sad but it must be done to protect western civilization i mean the shire, its all a part of The Big Fight, godly forces are at play
@zhongus_dongus@4Evil_Resident2 also, the basic narrative structure is the same between the books and the movies, so both. we are naturally good hobbits, here comes evil to corrupt our shire, must expunge this evil without mercy and return to our hobbit life. #wearehobbits so we can do no evil
@zhongus_dongus@4Evil_Resident2 which is why lotr can be used for populist narrative purposes by both the left and right. it rly doesnt matter how much copium tolkien had to huff after finishing lotr, theyre still nasty ass books imo
@FuckableF@4Evil_Resident2 another point of why i dislike lotr is that ppl get fucking insanely defensive abt it. ive had like 4 ppl in a row explode at me on this topic, it was being treated more like something holy, instructive, life affirming rather than just some books
@FuckableF@4Evil_Resident2 and westall never gave way on his problems with the portrayal of the orcs. i dislike lotr much more now cuz it seems to be v easy for populists, especially on the right, to appropriate it for antagonistic patriotic propaganda
@FuckableF@4Evil_Resident2 i was talking abt why its possible for fascists to appropriate lotr by showing the basic thought process, not anything that tolkien himself said or thought lol
@FuckableF@4Evil_Resident2 im not saying that tolkien himself was fascist. he was probably a really nice guy. all im saying is that lotr is a chuddy and stupid story
@FuckableF@4Evil_Resident2 'the hunt for evil' was the narrative of nazi germany. righteously destroy the evil corrupting our world, etc. lotr is open for appropriation by modern and old fascists cuz its the same narrative at its core