"Worldbuilding" is a premise, not a story, and nobody wants to be handed a premise to read. But a story without a premise is also extremely unfun.
This is not an affliction that is unique to fantasy, nor one that fantasy is uniquely immune to!
being a creative writing major has given me a real resentment for fantasy. i don’t care about worldbuilding or magic systems or any of that shit. just write about people man. just write about people
@Cary_Bleasdale One of my blurst creative decisions was adding an adventure into a ontologically-corrosive vacuum of meaning, which is one of those cool things that only fantasy can do. Too late, I realised how much care this brief aside would require.
@s_r_tarnmoor@Scholars_Stage I think this points at another factor in popular perception: if you reclassify all thoughtfully constructed fantasy fiction as sci-fi then, yes, the remainder will seem sloppy.
@noredshirthere I suspect you may have a grudge against a single individual? That grudge may possibly be deserved, but I don't think you can generalise from that dude to the entire literary endeavour.
@Scholars_Stage There's a lot of contemporary fantasy that operates very well as considered thought experiments and/or vibes machines, but those books don't have the same proportionate public profile.
https://t.co/ugF6QWGFi9
the high/low fantasy and hard/soft sci-fi distinctions resolve easily if you realise:
1. fantasy & sci-fi are the same genre
2. high/low is about AUDACITY
3. hard/soft is about CONSISTENCY
4. these are orthogonal, and every fantasy/sci-fi settings ought to be classified by BOTH
@Scholars_Stage I think that this is a good diagnostic! Although I do wonder whether the apparent gap is down to how far each genre has been swallowed by the monster that eats literature and spits out young adult fiction.
@FedericoVa80507 There's lots of very good and creative modern fantasy! I've especially enjoyed Harrison, Bakker, Mieville, and Muir. I don't think that they make Tolkien any less great, or that Tolkien makes them any less great.