@edu_andy24 parts that they want.
The thing is, if Malfoid was part of the OG books, JK could've actually done a real slow burn romance where we don't know if Malfoid actually gets redeemed or not... because we don't know how the story ends yet. But because we do, it complicates things.
@edu_andy24 you're basically asking them to do minimal changes for a full 3 1/2 or even 4 books. And that would be pretty boring, not just for their readers but for them as well. They'd either have to jump str8 to around book 4/5 or speedrun the first half of the story to get to the juicy-
@regularhuman01@Ihaventthoughta@EthosHeretica@DeadWhisperof Then let's continue to gatekeep as we have.
The community has done a good job at keeping troons and the LGTV mafia away. What I would caution against is adding "rules" that end up being used to witch hunt people like what heretic and his butt buddy were doing.
@Eschatos00@NWBroJaneway her father gets put in azkaban. So that's just over two books Worth of time. Still, it all then hinges on how you build their relationship in the first 4 books.
@Eschatos00@NWBroJaneway Still. 1 book though? Maybe have them drift away from each other by the end of Book 4, we still get Malfoid joining the Inquisitorial squad in Book 5 and get the readers used to the return of "evil" Malfoid. Plus we get extra justification of her wanting to go against Harry when-
@Eschatos00@NWBroJaneway Next book immediately would be too much of a whiplash. Maybe not for us because we know the ending and want to see it. But if this was how JK presented it to a new audience with no future sight? They'd think she had no idea what to do with Malfoid, even with the justification.
@Eschatos00@NWBroJaneway I'd argue that giving Malfoid only 1 book's worth of time to act like a heel wouldn't be enough for Harry to classify her as an enemy. He'd just think that something is up and would probably be obsessed on trying to find out what happened.
And then to switch her again in the -
@ShunKanpeki@NWBroJaneway As emotionally scarring as possible. It's a weird paradox, really. The more emotion an author builds to make sure that the betrayal of SS really hurts, the less I can imagine Harry actually pulling the trigger, even in panic mode. You get me 🤔?
@ShunKanpeki@NWBroJaneway Levicorpus? He knows what they do.
So going back to the Harry X Malfoid fight.
A spell for enemies that he doesn't know what it does.
Malfoid is a former friend at this point but he still has feelings for her, is clearly not in a good head space.
Would Harry use a spell -
@ShunKanpeki@NWBroJaneway Tagged for enemies on someone who he may not view as one, especially at that moment in time.
I lean towards No. Roughly around 80/20 if you told me to give a percentage.
It's just hard for me to picture it assuming the author had done their best to try to make the scene -
@ShunKanpeki@NWBroJaneway To be clear, SS can still happen and be great in the hands of a really good writer, but you'll need a way better build and set up to justify it and not just because Harry blanked (because you'd think he'd use his BnB spell expelliarmus if that were the case).
@ShunKanpeki@NWBroJaneway And again, your basing what Harry would do in a fight against a clearly distraught Malfoid vs Draco.
Malfoid isn't Draco in a Dress.
He would have different experiences and relations or ex relations with her.
Plus he can clearly see that something is wrong with her.