@FrankDomenicJr@sportingnews@grantmccagg@TheHockeyNews How am I moving the goalposts ? Your acting like this all knowing hockey god who can only say Crosby is better because he has three cups. You complained about jagr out of position so put Crosby out of position if he deserves to be on this list because he isn’t as a C
@FrankDomenicJr@sportingnews@grantmccagg@TheHockeyNews Comparing a season when Crosby played 41 games to them swapping Jagr from right to left wing in a season he played 82 games and had 62 goals and 149 points is a little disingenuous. If you want Crosby in there on a position swap goes he have a season better than any listed?
@FrankDomenicJr@sportingnews@grantmccagg@TheHockeyNews If this were based on overall careers then I would 100% agree with you, he’s currently the third best centre to ever live. The lineup is based off most dominate single seasons though, Crosby has a greater cumulative career but not a better single season individual performance
@FrankDomenicJr@sportingnews@grantmccagg@TheHockeyNews 32 years old and played/watched my whole life. If the only qualification for a better season is winning the cup then surely Letang should be on here over some other defensemen as well ? Crosby is a top 5 player of all time but he doesn’t have a season as dominate as ‘23 McDavid
@ASinToronto@sportingnews@grantmccagg@TheHockeyNews Being the literal best player in the NHL and one of two defensemen ever to win the hart and Norris in the same season? as opposed to winning a team award with multiple other hall of famers ? Yes that’s more impressive to me
@OnTheCLOCK__@puckempire Not trying to be rude but I take it you’re not Canadian ? Terry Fox is probably the greatest Canadian to ever live, I’d recommend looking into what he did for cancer research
@Bbbbhhhhbb88996@ChiSox_Mike All of these players could have been drafted the year prior by any team, they made the draft to find the next Cirelli and barely anyone impactful has came from it
@drw_prospects@BigSiouxGuy@JFreshHockey McDavid, MacKinnon, Drai, Matthews, Hughes, Crosby, Eichel, Carlsson, celebrini, Barkov, scheiffele, Suzuki, Johnston, Bedard, Tage, Aho, Stutzle, Thomas I think are better than him then Hischier, horvat, Hintz, Point, Barzal are debatable
@drw_prospects@BigSiouxGuy@JFreshHockey You are absolutely overrating him then, there is a debate he’s not even a top 20 C in the league let alone top 40 player
@rizzleschmizzle@WinnyBuilt@HotTakeHockey McDavid, MacKinnon, Drai, Matthews, Hughes, Crosby, Eichel, Carlsson, celebrini, scheiffele, Suzuki, Johnston, Bedard, Tage, Aho, Stutzle, Thomas I think are better than him. I think he’s in the top of the low end 1C/ elite 2C with the likes of Horvat, Hischier, O’Reilly, Hintz
@pitchforkedpuck As a devils fan I’m doing that in a heart beat. 4 wild cards for a very good 2C ? Push Jack to the wing and hope that helps him stay a little more healthy or run the best C core in the NHL 1,2,3
@itkovian23@AwayTeam1101d@JhanHky you’re going to be severely disappointed if you think you’re getting a similar return as Thomas. You’ll get Byfield and a pick and you’ll like it