@queserasarasara Qurbani is Wajib according to the Hanafis but highly recommended by the other madhabs. Pakistan is predominantly a country where majority follow Hanafi Madhab. If you meet the threshold then you need to give it as prescribed. Yes one should dispose of the waste and be clean.
@frossfross1 Not entirely sure about how authentic this narration is but Al Bidayah is known to have a lot of fabricated and weak narrations as well as some authentic. Recall a narration I think where Jibraeel عليه السلام conveyed salam to Muawiya which is known to be fabricated.
@MrAdnanRashid Just for once maybe get out of the ego box and put Shia Sunni differences aside, and look at the bigger picture. You're knowledgeable no doubt but I fear you suffer from egotism as well unfortunately! In these times we need unity as Muslims. Period!!
@MrAdnanRashid I think we hve bigger issues in the Umrah then If QA Jinnah was a Shia/Sunni. I think we can all safely agree he was a Muslim. These debates/discussions can be for another day. In current times the Umrah requires being united in the face of oppression. Egos aside and let it be.
@_mawadda Generally, the Umayyads with the exception of few were tyrants or incompetent rulers. The same goes for the Abbasids. One thing common for both was they initially all claimed to be bearers of justice for Ahlul Bayt but in fact did further injustices with them.
@TruePathSeeker@xumas_iq There's a difference between insult and criticism. You shouldn't be insulting anyone. Constructive criticism can be valid but there are more important things currently going on than discussing Muawiya. Leave this matter to the Almighty and discussions to ulama.Don't cause fitna.
@FikrAlJabarti@anzarml Imam Nasai stated there are no authentic narrations in praise of Muawiya due to which the pro Umayyad/supporters of Muawiya beat him to death.
Muawiyah is a very controversial figure in history. Best to neither sing his praise or insult. Silence is the best option.
@_mawadda One shouldn't be insulting anyone. Yes, Muawiyah's actions were detrimental to the cause of Islam and him appointing his son was just the start of a downfall and other actions he committed but one should be objective. State the truth, be rational and that's it. No insults.
@MrAdnanRashid Your unwavering defence of Yazid is worrying. There's one thing defending the sahaba, but going to one extreme of defending Yazid? Thats the opposite end of extreme the Rawafid do regarding certain companions. You should reflect on that One should be fair. May Allah guide us all
@Hestia2007 What's wrong with an interview? Political prisoners have been interviewed in jail or whilst in custody, so what's so childish about such a desire?