Below are my thoughts on why $LMND continues to get crushed even after what I consider a good 3Q26, where the metrics that matter most to the business model long-term moved in the right direction.
The only fly in the ointment in 3Q26 were the LR comments on pet and Europe, but $LMND made rate filings months ago to address these. This is the kind of temporary fluctuation that all insurers deal with in the ordinary course of business. Nothing thesis changing here.
And yet the stock trades like death. It is always possible I am missing something, but my working theory is that the company put itself in the penalty box earlier this year by overpromising, blowing up their own guidance and their supporters in the process.
$LMND started the year guiding for flat opex, even with the structural upward pressures of other insurance expenses that are proportional to revenues. But then they also saw an opportunity to make strategic hires to take advantage of the progress in AI to significantly accelerate their geographic and product rollouts. Between those two things we got a huge spike in expenses that blew up the prior guidance.
Ironically, I believe they made the right business decisions. We want them to invest to maximize long-term business value. The ongoing accelerating in growth with improving marketing efficiency suggests so. The problem was not the execution. The problem was setting unrealistic expectations that they would have failed to meet even without the extra investment.
Put differently, if (even economically rational) decisions violate prior expectations set by the company, it makes investors ask why the company missed their self-imposed targets and whether the underlying model is broken. This happened in two consecutive quarters earlier this year. That is why $LMND is in the penalty box.
Companies don't need to tell every bullish story under the sun. Since $LMND is a fast evolving business (especially with the accelerating progress in AI), they need some room in the guidance to make the most value accretive business decisions day to day, even if those sometimes hurt short term numbers.
The answer is not to guide on things that you cannot be reasonably certain you can deliver with the normal volatility in the business and investment opportunity set. Instead, be accountable for the top and bottom line guidance you do give, and deliver on it with no excuses. No drama beat and raise stories are good. Long explanations after the fact are bad. Guidance on other metrics is good only as long as you are willing to be accountable for them under a no excuses policy, even while the world around you evolves.
The business model of a structurally low cost provider of insurance was fabulous even pre AI (just look at the track record of value creation at Geico and Progressive). And $LMND is super charging this with AI in a way no one else is. You do not have to promise any more than that.
The Investor Day will be important. It is a real opportunity to reset the narrative. I hope that the company sets reasonable, first principles, achievable targets, and then just gets to work on beating, raising, and rebuilding investor confidence.
I am bullish on Nick Stead, the incoming CFO. Even though he is a young guy just stepping into the role for the first time, his comments on the last few earnings calls suggests that he gets it.
I am also glad that @daschreiber acknowledged the other insurance cost pressure in his interview with @PaperBagInvest earlier this year. It suggests that the company understands they should not promise things that are unsupported by the fundamental economics of the business.
The reaction to 3Q26 earnings suggests that investors have PTSD over this stock. And anyone who as consistently defended $LMND looks like a bit of an idiot right now, given where the stock is. That is why the stock is having a hard time finding a bottom, imo.
Personally, I don't often fight the tape like this, but I currently have my largest long position in $LMND ever. I think that $LMND's business model is special and has the opportunity to deliver tremendous long-term value. And I think that within a couple of quarters the noise from earlier this year will fade as opex growth returns to a normal trend rate. And maybe growth continues to accelerate as a result of this year's investments as well.
I have been early, and it has been painful, so feel free to take my opinion with a grain of salt. But I also think it is our job as investors to stand up for good companies going through hard times.
I look forward to the Investor Day and to brighter days ahead.
cc: @shai_wininger
$LMND did a great job at today's Investor Day. Alas, it is a tough market day, particularly for many correlated tech and software stocks.
It is as clear as ever that $LMND is an AI winner and a compounding machine. In time, $LMND will have its moment.
https://t.co/33A1lNK4VJ
@Lemonade_Inc now has approx. 10% of the US renters market and 9% of the US pet insurance market!
But here's the number that blows my mind:
We estimate that half of all net new renters policies in the US are Lemonade's, and 40% in Pet.
And we're still relatively young, competing with insurers that have been around for generations.
Now consider this: our market share in Car is still tiny -just 0.1%, in a $400B market.
Reading this reminds me of Winston Churchill's quip that "democracy is the worst form of government except for all the other forms that have been tried."
What does history teach us about dictatorships? Even by a "benevolent machine god?"
https://t.co/UKgTJkYOTK
It is critically important that everyone thinking about AI become familiar with the term “handoverism.”
Many in the AI community believe that humanity should—or inevitably will—hand control of the world over to AI itself. Some view this not as a risk to be avoided, but as an outcome to be welcomed. Are we actually designing toward this future?
This worldview is particularly relevant at Anthropic. Co-founder Tom Brown said: “There’s going to be a handoff where humanity will hand off control to transformative AI at some point.”
In his seminal essay, Machines of Loving Grace, CEO Dario Amodei contemplates:
“It could be a capitalist economy of AI systems, which then give out resources (huge amounts of them, since the overall economic pie will be gigantic) to humans based on some secondary economy of what the AI systems think makes sense to reward in humans (based on some judgment ultimately derived from human values).”
Are you prepared to receive your “resources” from an AI system, based on criteria it determines? The full title of the poem Dario borrowed the title from is "All Watched Over by Machines of Loving Grace." Do you want to be "watched over" by AI?
If Anthropic's founders believe that the ultimate destination is the transfer of human control to AI, the world deserves to know. Washington, D.C. deserves to know. American citizens deserve to know. And if that belief informs Anthropic's corporate objectives, it belongs in the Risk Factors section of its S-1. It isn't there today.
I am decidedly anti-handoverism. I'm not here to tell you what your view should be. But I believe anyone making consequential decisions about AI—especially those drafting, advocating for, or enacting AI regulation—should be required to disclose where they stand on this fundamental question.
A wonderfully thoughtful piece on the subject by @RuxandraTeslo:
https://t.co/9rdlBoNX5j
It is critically important that everyone thinking about AI become familiar with the term “handoverism.”
Many in the AI community believe that humanity should—or inevitably will—hand control of the world over to AI itself. Some view this not as a risk to be avoided, but as an outcome to be welcomed. Are we actually designing toward this future?
This worldview is particularly relevant at Anthropic. Co-founder Tom Brown said: “There’s going to be a handoff where humanity will hand off control to transformative AI at some point.”
In his seminal essay, Machines of Loving Grace, CEO Dario Amodei contemplates:
“It could be a capitalist economy of AI systems, which then give out resources (huge amounts of them, since the overall economic pie will be gigantic) to humans based on some secondary economy of what the AI systems think makes sense to reward in humans (based on some judgment ultimately derived from human values).”
Are you prepared to receive your “resources” from an AI system, based on criteria it determines? The full title of the poem Dario borrowed the title from is "All Watched Over by Machines of Loving Grace." Do you want to be "watched over" by AI?
If Anthropic's founders believe that the ultimate destination is the transfer of human control to AI, the world deserves to know. Washington, D.C. deserves to know. American citizens deserve to know. And if that belief informs Anthropic's corporate objectives, it belongs in the Risk Factors section of its S-1. It isn't there today.
I am decidedly anti-handoverism. I'm not here to tell you what your view should be. But I believe anyone making consequential decisions about AI—especially those drafting, advocating for, or enacting AI regulation—should be required to disclose where they stand on this fundamental question.
A wonderfully thoughtful piece on the subject by @RuxandraTeslo:
https://t.co/9rdlBoNX5j
@MichaelAlbertMD As far as you are aware, have any approaches improved on the dual GLP-1 / GIP agonism MoA? Improved in terms of a better weight loss / AE tradeoff.
Seems like many of the new approaches have issues with SAEs or discontinuation rates...
This latest decline in $LMND is quizzical, to be polite. This was a great quarter by any metric that matters.
There have been quarters in the past where I understood a weak market reaction. This is not one of them...
Would not exactly be shocking. AI is certainly making it faster and easier to be a quant.
There are very large firms spending a lot of money on compute, and they are unlikely to advertise their advances either...
https://t.co/quygjvIuiW
@scaling01 Interesting thought. So the big question in this paradigm would be: How quickly do we transition S curves? Seems like the pace is accelerating (orange was the frontier for a shorter period than blue).
The net result might be super-linear.
And what happens with RSI?
@ContrarianCurse Doesn't it depend on the person and what type of learner they are? Some people retain things best with careful listening. Some people retain things best writing them out long hand. Know thyself...
@JeremyFalmouth Pretty cool. Thank you for sharing. Out of curiosity - did you use one of the AI coding harnesses, and if so which one? How hard was it to set this up?
@bioinvestor24 FWIW - a variety of outlets report that Betaville issued an "uncooked alert" on $VKTX. I have not seen it first hand, so I am not sure if that's actually true. But that seems to be what drove the stock.