Honestly with GTAVI adding more and more realistic features this could have been an insane opportunity for Saints Row to make an actual comeback and be the complete opposite of it but... yeah we know it will never happen sadly
This is more what it should look like, meh should be 5/10, I don't think 10/10 should be flawless, but it should have so little flaws they should be able to get ignored easily ( which if you read most of the 10/10 GTA 6 reviews, you can easily see they would have given it a 8 or 9/10 if they weren't scared/influenced )
While yes, they won two years, I don't deny that, they also lost in 2023 and 2024 where gacha games were nominated but didn't end up winning, so I find his post disingenuous, while I kind of agree gacha games shouldn't be nominated and maybe should have a different category ( I know mobile game category exists but still ) because most of them have a mobile audience which is bigger than most people realize and it gives them more chance to win out of sheer popularity, it is still not an instant win as implied
Let me introduce everyone to my favorite gacha games that have released and won Player's Voice since 2020, Black Myth: Wukong, Baldur's Gate 3, Halo Infinite and Ghost of Tsushima!
"It should be vote of people. GAMERS should vote for the games."
1. TGAs has a category for the people & gacha games win every year
2. Let me introduce to you the Golden Joystick Awards
@sophiekeen Ah yes, my favorite gacha game of 2024, Black Myth Wukong, alongside my other favorite gacha game of 2023, Baldur's gate 3, can't also forget my other two favorite gachas of 2021 and 2020, Halo Infinite and Ghost of Tsushima
@BlisssAbyss@2ndartbook Not everything is subjective in a video game, if I play a standard fps but miss an enemy because his hit box is only 50% the size of the actual model that's just objectively bad
@GiveMeBanHammer That's because only journalists who got the game early can nominate games at the game awards ( which makes them definitely trustworthy and we can be sure they didn't nominate it/gave a positive review so they can get an early copy of the next rockstar game in 20 years )
@juperder Wasn't this something that was made by a dev just because he was bored? I don't think it's about chasing realism or not, man was just bored and made something he liked that got put into the game
@wesleytypes@thegameawards Halo infinite no, all the others I could see arguments for, anyway, the real issue is that it's a 90% journalists and 10% players split, which makes player votes useless, I'd like to see stats but I'm 99% sure anyway that players vote never swayed anything except player's voice
"Multiplayer. it" game doesn't even have a multiplayer mode yet
"Isn't a perfect game." gives it a perfect score
This is one of the reasons pretty much nobody takes journalists seriously anymore
@Fightincowboy Yeah honestly voting is pointless they should just allow you to vote for the "Player's choice award" as it's the only one where votes actually matters
My problem is ultimately how The Game Awards is marketed as an event for gamers. Keighley's general messaging and the marketing around "Vote now!" portrays it as an event for players when in reality fan votes account for 10% aside from Players' Voice.
If they want to be a critic driven show such as the Oscars, Grammys, etc. that's fine, but they should fully present themselves as such and stop marketing it as if player voices matter in a meaningful capacity.
At the end of the day it's a 3hr long paid advertisement with closed door voting, and I'll watch to see what's coming up regardless, but the marketing of it rubs me the wrong way.
@GeraltofGoonia Lowering graphic settings in game post 2020 barely affects framerate because most games don't care about optimization, every time I change a game from ultra to low I get at best 10 fps, the only feature that highly changes the framerate is whether RTX is on or off
I think we need to make it clear that soundtracks that are overwhemingly licensed shouldn't be nominated for this award. Score and music needs to be original music FOR video games. Not repurposed licensed music.