I'm not saying Marxism or socialism is finished (it's not), but liberalism has proven exceptionally adaptive in a way that 20th century socialism was evidently not, and 21st century socialism has really nothing to show for itself. Doesn't look like that's changing soon either. It comes off as completely detached from reality to act like Soviet collapse was just a minor setback
Lots of leftist cope in response to this but the demise of an Actually Existing Socialist global hegemon was indisputably catastrophic to Marxism as a political project because the Soviet Union presented a durable, real-world alternative to capitalist liberal democracy.
One cannot overstate the magnitude of that defeat, and it's pointless to deny it.
China has no rival ideological or hegemonic vision. At most, it wants to renegotiate its position within the existing world order, not topple or disrupt the world order itself. This is bc its political economy is essentially capitalist.
A curious thing on Western social media is that Soviet architecture is almost always shown from winter photos, but rarely summer, when the trees are in leaf and the gardens in bloom.
NEW ARTICLE: What if the late USSR followed in China's footsteps instead of Gorbachev's failed policies? Indeed, a kind of "Soviet Dengism" was seriously discussed during the late Soviet era, but never pursued. In a different timeline, could the free market have saved the USSR?
When you weaponize false narratives of victimhood to deflect from your own obvious hatred of muslims, it's pretty clear what nationalist playbook you're drawing from. If it quacks like a duck
This cretin will do things like casually shrug off the tens of thousands of massacred Palestinian children as having less moral worth than animals, and then proceed to cry racism when people notice the insane Hitlerite things he says. You are not a victim.
An interesting thing about the Holocaust Museum in DC is that it quite literally falsifies history. It features the famous "First They Came" Niemöller poem as the final words of the exhibition but excises the "First they came for the Communists" part. https://t.co/cA4cjPnk9f
Of course it was never Marxist. Because the Soviet Union never existed, its existence largely cobbled together as a "retrospective boogeyman" pieced together from assorted nationalist myths disseminated by IR and Eastern European area studies departments in the 1990s.
Obviously, there are major differences between the Russian Orthodox Church in the early 20th century, which was intertwined with the Tsarist state, and religious institutions in the US today. Nevertheless, the necessity of principled atheism in America could hardly be more apparent in light of the immense power Jewish supremacists wield over American institutions + the threat posed by MAGA Christian nationalism.
One could have easily said the same thing about 1900s Tsarist Russia. For the Bolsheviks, atheism was never seen as a condition for working class political organization, but was still an integral aspect of their programme because they were principled and committed Marxists.
All that means is that you need to formulate a sensible long term political strategy around organizing against religious reaction, and maybe not sell your values at the first opportunity to gain some marginal electoral appeal
We need a climate Stalin & I don't just mean 5 Year Plans for green development; I mean political leadership conscious of the fact that if we don't abruptly & violently reorient our entire society to defend itself against an imminent existential threat, *we will have no society*
China has no rival ideological or hegemonic vision. At most, it wants to renegotiate its position within the existing world order, not topple or disrupt the world order itself. This is bc its political economy is essentially capitalist.
NEW ARTICLE: The notion that Soviet collapse was an inevitable product of a broken economic system is a stubborn myth. In reality, a close reading of late Soviet economic history reveals that the USSR was entirely stable until Gorbachev's reforms. A different future was possible.
In this series, I sketch out the possibilities of the lost 21st Soviet century. Link in reply