🚨 Ryan Giggs on Antonio Conte Links to Manchester United:
🗣️ Antonio Conte?
He’s brutal… and that is exactly what Manchester United needs right now - both for the players and the club.
I don’t think he will tolerate some of the behaviours we’ve seen from the players or even from the club.
Michael Carrick is very calm and peaceful… and that’s not the hand United needs at the moment.
Let me use Real Madrid as an example.
During the era of Xabi Alonso and Arbeloa, you saw the outbursts in the dressing room - between Valverde, Tchouaméni, Kylian Mbappé and others - simply because there was no control and no discipline.
Do you know the end result? Zero trophies last season.
But look at them now. José Mourinho is there… and you can already see the difference.
I don’t see any difference between that situation and Manchester United right now. Bruno Fernandes and the rest of the players doing what they like. No order. No discipline.
Do you think Antonio Conte will accept that?
No way.
Yes, I know Pochettino is also in the picture… but if Carrick is eventually replaced, I would prefer Conte.
🚨Gary Neville on Manchester United sacking Michael Carrick and replacing him with Mauricio Pochettino:
🗣️ Gary Neville: “I’m exhausted watching Manchester United change managers every time things go wrong.
Carrick should probably have gone before now. I’ve never seen him as the long-term answer, and nothing this season has changed my mind.
But this is where I have a problem.
We sack Carrick, fine.
Then what?
Mauricio Pochettino?
I’m not saying Pochettino is a bad manager. He isn’t. But Manchester United have to stop believing that hiring a famous name automatically fixes the football club.
What exactly are we buying?
The Tottenham version?
Because that manager was excellent. He built a young team, played good football and reached a Champions League final.
But that was years ago.
Since then, he has been at PSG, Chelsea and the United States.
At PSG, he had Messi, Neymar and Mbappé and still didn’t win the Champions League.
At Chelsea, it became another story of inconsistency before the relationship with the club broke down.
And now he is managing the USMNT.
So Manchester United are saying this is the man to rebuild one of the biggest clubs in world football?
I need somebody to explain that to me.
I’m tired of Manchester United making decisions based on reputation.
We bring somebody in, spend a fortune, lose matches, panic, sack him and start again.
That isn’t a football strategy.
That is gambling.
And if Carrick is getting sacked because the team is in a mess, I have no argument with it.
You cannot have Manchester United sitting in the relegation zone, conceding goals and looking disorganised, then pretend everything is fine.
But don’t sack him simply to put another big name in the chair because supporters are angry.
That is how we end up having the same conversation again.
Manchester United don’t need another manager who arrives, gets everyone excited, wins a few games and then we’re back at the beginning.
We need structure.
We need recruitment.
We need football people making football decisions.
Pochettino might be that man. I genuinely don’t know.
And that’s my problem.
His Premier League record is good, but it isn’t extraordinary enough for me to ignore everything else.
His Chelsea spell wasn’t convincing.
His PSG spell wasn’t convincing enough in Europe.
And managing the USMNT is completely different from managing Manchester United every three days under the pressure of Old Trafford.
So if Manchester United are appointing Pochettino, tell me why.
Not because he’s available.
Not because he’s famous.
Not because he managed Tottenham.
Tell me what the plan is.
Because I’m sick of hearing ‘new era’. I’m sick of hearing ‘project’. I’m sick of being told that this time we’ve finally got it right.
If Pochettino comes in, back him properly.
Give him the players.
Give him the structure.
Give him the authority.
Carrick needed to go.
But replacing one uncertain decision with another isn’t progress.
Manchester United need to stop changing the face of the problem and start fixing the actual problem.
Because the biggest problem at Manchester United has never been the shortage of managers.
It has been the shortage of good decisions.”