@Brexit_Refugee@Ignasss1992@scrowder There was nothing more democratic in Ukraine. In those same years, the British Parliament, which appointed the government that ruled the entire British Empire, was elected by only a few percent of the inhabitants of this empire. Was it democratic?
@Ignasss1992@Brexit_Refugee@scrowder In the Ukrainian Soviet Republic in all the Soviets the people were represented by Ukrainians, just as in the Republic of Lithuania by Lithuanians. This independent country since 1918 became a co-founder of the USSR in 1922, along with Russia.
@Brexit_Refugee@Ignasss1992@scrowder If the US occupation of its own territory is bad and the US understood this only recently, then why should the USSR have understood this earlier?
@Brexit_Refugee@Ignasss1992@scrowder If you said that grain was exported from Ukraine to Russia at the beginning of 1933, then confirm this fact with documents that indicate the balance of mutual transportation of grain between the republics during this period.
@Brexit_Refugee@Ignasss1992@scrowder You have already familiarized yourself with these documents, give exact references to them and tell us what is written in them, what was the value of the "controversial transfers of power", from whom and to whom they occurred.
@Brexit_Refugee@Ignasss1992@scrowder The peasants themselves killed their livestock, who else "captured" it, in what quantity, in what periods and where did the meat of this livestock go? In tons every year. How, after the removal of seed material in 1933, the harvest in Ukraine became 50% higher than in 1932?
@Brexit_Refugee@Ignasss1992@scrowder The famine began in early 1933 and ended after the 1933 harvest in June. If you have complete data on the movement and availability of grain across the territory of the USSR at that time and earlier, then give them, not a single genocide researcher has them.
@Brexit_Refugee@Ignasss1992@scrowder You have already researched everything, so just answer my questions, you can also add why the dispossession directives in 1929, 30 and 33 led to very large crops, and in 1932 to very low and 40% harvest losses.
@Ignasss1992@Brexit_Refugee@scrowder I am also glad that you both agree that the star F 12356785885 in the galaxy NYDR 34 C:HK456 has a mass of exactly 10400877077458575776667776860606 galactic tons, and it does not matter whether such a star exists in reality and what is the value of a galactic ton.
@Brexit_Refugee@Ignasss1992@scrowder Where could the class of landowners come from in 1932, if all the land was nationalized by the Bolsheviks in early 1918 and redistributed for the use of the working peasantry in the early 1920s after the end of the Civil War?