Now up on #SSRN, my essay on place-based approach for the rights of nature: Natural Jurisdiction: Shifting Boundaries from Exploitation to Connection @SSRN https://t.co/nez5Qr7BbO
This open letter to libraries in Alberta is excellent and important. For everyone.
“To be clear, no public library in Canada has anything in its collection that is obscene or is child pornography – both are violations of Canada’s Criminal Code.”
https://t.co/CmbRyxvwjJ
In a little-noticed webpage update, the Environmental Protection Agency has announced a plan to decommission its online web archive at the end of the year, a move that would wipe tens of thousands of publicly available environmental resources from the web. https://t.co/2C7PsUoyUb
I'll say it again for the AI risk experts in the back:
We've already run a real life, large scale experiment on what happens when a superintelligence is unleashed on a narrow objective.
Look no further than U.S. capital markets.
Millions of investors, analysts, traders and algorithms, backed by trillions of dollars and wired together through prices, all chasing one goal: the highest risk-adjusted return on capital.
And it is spectacularly good at its job. It funds the best ideas, punishes the worst ones, and turns new information into prices faster than any of us can react. No individual can out-think it. 99+ percent of professionals can't beat it.
But look at what else it's done along the way:
- Optimized the measure instead of the intent. Quarterly earnings became the scoreboard, so companies learned to manage the scoreboard.
- Treated anything without a price as free. Pollution, addiction, obesity, depression, political fragmentation, fragile supply chains, the long-term health of the communities it operates in.
- Found every gap in the rules, then paid lobbyists to help write the next set and pull up the ladder behind incumbents.
- Remade the world around its objective. Companies, pension funds and our retirement accounts now answer to the S&P 500.
- Made itself impossible to switch off, because everything else now depends on it.
None of this required malice. Nobody sat in a room and chose these outcomes. It's simply what a very capable optimizer does when its objective is a narrow proxy for what we actually care about.
And note that we never solved this alignment problem. We've managed it, imperfectly, with regulation, taxes, disclosure rules and the occasional crisis to show us where the guardrails were missing. Over time, the market has captured the instutions designed to constrain it. We've been at it the better part of a century, and the misalignment is the worst it's ever been.
So the next time someone tells you AI is only dangerous if it "wants" something bad, or if its goals are mis-specified, point them at the S&P 500. It doesn't want anything. It just optimizes.
That's the whole problem.
Hey @ABDanielleSmith your government is about to needlessly harm tens of thousands of severely disabled people by dismantling AISH.
All major cities are urging you to stop. Albertans from all over are urging you to stop.
Please stop before people are hurt.
#alberta#AISH
Lots of DM’s today from folks being transitioned from AISH to ADAP looking for legal recourse…
Any legal beagles able to weigh in?
#abpoli#ableg#cdnpoli
Bats and newts are not the reason Britain struggles to build things.
They are scapegoats for a regulatory system obsessed with paperwork, consultation and litigation, but incapable of delivering either ecological recovery or efficient development, writes @kittyraethomp.
https://t.co/HfRaMbiayp
The AER issued an order requiring MAGA Energy Ltd. (MAGA) to suspend its operations to protect the public and environment.
🔗Learn more: https://t.co/vQnKPtAOnF
#ABEnergy#ABregulator#Alberta
“Danielle Smith's government is exempting celebrity investor Kevin O'Leary's massive Wonder Valley data centre near Grand Prairie, AB, from a provincial environmental assessment”
Because of course they did.
#abpoli#ableg#cdnpoli https://t.co/i0mnrrsP4i
We’ve assembled a list of provincial nature and environmental advocacy organizations in Western Canada. Can you suggest any additions? https://t.co/cMQlr5LEVo
‘My ideas are a little revolutionary’ says ecologist Suzanne Simard (professor of forest ecology at the University of BC). Her research popularized the idea of the wood wide web, but the scientific backlash was brutal. https://t.co/hUwTuBWsyN #ecology#SciComm#CdnSci#SciChat
Mark Carney’s Post-American Economic Strategy
Phew. This essay took a lot of work.
The argument is simple: PM @MarkJCarney has an economic strategy for Canada, it's just not obvious.
I try to connect the dots for readers.
https://t.co/WkNU2WViLF
@DrJStrategy As somebody who has served and has served on that base, I disagree, keeping the troops safe is a #1 priority.
Read this excellent summary, minus the fake Conservative outrage.
https://t.co/NJGG9GRhRA
“You’ll never find a boyfriend like me!”
“Yes, that’s the idea.”
But in all seriousness, to learn what deal Canada has made with China, pls read this deepdive: https://t.co/HiFuBjsxHY
@JimSharkey9@G_Gecko1980@MPelletierCIO Keystone XL was approved from Canada side. It was numerous court cases, siting issues in the US, over a decade time span, that ultimately led to its failure.