@Nickhasdoubts@eepy_ruby@CerosTV I am generally familiar with game theory. My understanding was that red is the correct strategy although I could be mistaken.
However, game theory really doesn’t apply here since your actions don’t meaningfully interact with others outcomes. Again, it is an ill-posed question.
@Nickhasdoubts@eepy_ruby@CerosTV Thanks for the back and forth, I’m still not convinced on the blue position. Again, if the world would be able to talk about it I’m all blue.
The original question still is really asking: “Given the world outcome that’s about to happen anyway, which button would you press?”
@Nickhasdoubts@eepy_ruby@CerosTV This is where we diverge, because there is a threshold. The global population is specifically mentioned in the question. If you and I were in a room with 8 strangers and faced with the same question, I’m picking blue, but it doesn’t translate to the global population.
@Nickhasdoubts@eepy_ruby@CerosTV I get it, there will always be blue-pressers. My issue is that it is a bad question, there is no causality. My red vote only “kills you” if it changes the global threshold. If it doesn’t, then it didn’t determine your death, it only determined whether I survive the outcome.
@Nickhasdoubts@eepy_ruby@CerosTV Really I am picking the question apart here, not saying saving yourself > saving others
If there was an implication of collaboration beforehand, I would agree with you. But the question is posed in a way that does not give your decision weight, you are only voting for yourself.
@Nickhasdoubts@coffeeglorpian@eepy_ruby@CerosTV If the red/blue scenario happened as the question was posed, then your decision does not meaningfully influence the final result. Your vote is lost in the sea of ~8 billion. There is no reason then not to press red.
@peterrhague If the red/blue scenario happened as the question was posed, then your decision does not meaningfully influence the final result. Your vote is lost in the sea of ~8 billion. There is no reason then not to press red.
@JoshFurness1 Jalen Hurts (who has had pre-marital sex) will be obtaining his first ring this weekend on the short, yet heroic journey of denying Patrick Mahomes (who has tried Marijuana) his second ring. Tom Brady is not in this conversation