My hope: the CFP makes public the data they’re sharing with the committee. We get that in basketball. It’s time for football.
It’s nonsense.
SEC deserves its roses, yes. That’s not my issue. It’s the lack of transparency over a product made for TV and public consumption.
Tim “Brass Balls” Brando goes absolutely SCORCHED EARTH on ESPN and SEC corruption
Good to see people calling this stuff out.
But I’m just a conspiracy theorist…..
@HarryPitt19@bkbeban@PatMcAfeeShow@KirkHerbstreit I don’t disagree for a second that there’s SEC bias - it’s astronomical. I was only giving an example of anyone can justify anything when everything is subjective and there’s a thousand metrics so pick the one that fits your narrative.
@HarryPitt19@bkbeban@PatMcAfeeShow@KirkHerbstreit It’s as simple as how you want to write it out, yes. Any decision can be justified when there’s no defined published criteria for everyone. I could do the same thing with the SEC bias. Oh yeah they had the best P4 non-conference record they deserve everything. See how easy it is?
It’s reached cartoonish levels — and everyone sees it. With the billions of dollars involved, you have to wonder what the fallout will be if, in time, meaningful people start looking into the questions about whether the 2026 CFP was rigged.
@HarryPitt19@bkbeban@PatMcAfeeShow@KirkHerbstreit You say there’s an obvious SEC bias bc it benefits you. You deny placing UofO/OSU in front of Iowa has anything to do with “brand, benefit of the doubt, potential, roster strength”…whatever else people want to sell us. Yes, the CFP selection process is subjective, not defined.
@HarryPitt19@bkbeban@PatMcAfeeShow@KirkHerbstreit I have no problem w/ UofO qualifying over Iowa. I do have a problem w/ undefined qualifiers, and I’m not on an island with that thinking. The sport is fcked up & ruled by ESPN and other TV networks. Talk about disingenuous. But, favorable to the Ducks, so I get you’re onboard.
Great article by @bmarcello. It's a must read.
The amount of SEC bias this year is absurd.
Tony Petitti and the Big Ten must come out with a statement and stop leaving the fight to their coaches.
Here's the question: WHY ARE THE COMMITTEE MEETINGS SECRET?
Livestream the debates. Show us the reasoning. Make committee members defend their rankings AND their bias.
@HarryPitt19@PatMcAfeeShow@KirkHerbstreit Win games. Records should take priority over any other bs narrative metric people can manipulate to push whoever they wish forward or backward. You’re in the same conference. They have a better record. No other fcking sport on planet earth is going to throw out a win-loss record.
@HarryPitt19@PatMcAfeeShow@KirkHerbstreit BS SOS metrics shouldn’t outweigh win-loss records, especially in a same conference.
Let’s call Oregon’s loss to UCLA and Iowa’s loss to early-season Ohio State a wash.
You can’t tell me two losses to Oklahoma State & Illinois is not worse than one loss to Minnesota. Win games.
The CFP committee is lying to itself about the 100% FACT that Ohio State is a shell of its former self. The team that beat Iowa earlier this season no longer exists.
Because if you’re honest about Ohio State, you also have to be honest about Oregon’s recent win against them.