One Person Who Should Return and One Who Never Should (per season)
Obviously I won't include any returning players and will be excluding full returnee seasons.
David vs Goliath-
Should- I can see many many people returning from this season but I have a super soft spot for Davie.
Shouldn't- He ended up doing a nice job on the jury but he's rich and already got a lot out of a single season experience so yet another Mike joins the list.
David vs Goliath-
Very strange because I think most people on this season are appropriately rated! Even Nick didn't get a sloppy BJ of an edit! So I'm just going to go with Mike even though he did okay at the end.
Edge of Extinction-
Should- Only one answer for this one, DUDE.
Shouldn't- He's probably a lock to return but I have no desire to watch another second of the Rick Devens show SORRY.
I just want to say that I recently revisited some of Game Changers and Sierra (and her QAnon husband) can go fuck themselves and I regret placing her in my top 4.
@djfattyd They're all pre merge boots though! I tried to factor in who I actually think could stand a chance at returning on the seasons that haven't been totally picked over.