Honestly, how long did the world take to trust gold as money in a free market? Never. It was the decree of governments and mostly monarchs that established metals as a money system. It wasn’t the collective wisdom of society who figured out trading feathers or tobacco leaves was an inefficient MoE, SoV.
BTC has no government and NEEDS to go through the trials and tribulations and max pain of a free market money to gain trust.
Covid is a good example. The worst pandemic since the Spanish flu. People didn’t melt their kitchenware or pawn their jewelry to buy necessities from Walmart?
People adopted WFH, Digital, and touch-less payment technologies.
So net net, does gold and BTC have a place in society to protect their wealth from currency devaluation? Yes.
Is there a debate about sound money between the two? No, at least not right now.
BTC is an infant vs gold.
Have you ever used the dollars and treasury bonds to clean your windows? So why would I use money as anything else in its pure use case ?
There is utility value vs monetary value.
WHY GOLD WILL NEVER LOSE ALL ITS VALUE BUT BITCOIN WILL.
It is important to understand two characteristics of money. In the past money had both or one of these characteristics.
The two characteristics are value in use and value in exchange. All previous money had value in exchange but only some had value in use.
Under the gold standard money had value in use because gold had an inherent value and could be used to make jewellery etc. At present gold still has this inherent value and also a speculative value as people around the world hold it to protect against the falling value of fiat.
At present bitcoin has no value in use but it does have a speculative value that one day it will be adopted as a general medium of exchange when fiat fails. Unfortunately bitcoin has a fatal flaw, namely 21 million, that means it will not become a medium of exchange as its value will not stabilise (it will not grow with the economy). Once this becomes clear it will lose its speculative value.
In addition to this Central Banks will ensure Bitcoin fails as they try to set up CBDC’s. Hopefully this will fail but that is another story.
@JulieBorowski The price of something has nothing to do with the progress of something.
Food prices collapsing and stock market prices collapsing are two of the same concept yet most ppl treat them different psychologically.
So what is the real problem with mindset?
It is each individual's efforts that directly or indirectly lift people around them for a better standard of living.
It is people's lack of effort that directly and indirectly bring individuals down to their lower standard of living.
There's a clear difference between socialism and capitalism.
It's up to you and you alone to decide how to make your future not take from those who made their future.
Choose wisely.
As a Democrat, I'm encouraged by the news that our party is already making progress on affordability before even taking office.
For too long, the stock market has been too expensive for working families, putting investing out of reach for ordinary Americans.
And with Democrats taking office in January, I'm confident stocks will only get more affordable in the years ahead.
This is what I voted for.
Oh really!? Sound money.
This is not an academia ego debate. You asked for the attention.
The only times I see ppl peak argue $XAU vs $BTC on X is when prices fall (fiat terms). What does that tell you about ppl?
There is a reason why gold standard died a long time ago and way before Nixon went to China.
@jbhearn If we are going to go back to a classical gold standard with a fiat peg, it only takes one large discovery to break the monetary system …..again
@jbhearn A pure money system doesn’t use their reserves for ear rings and motherboards? It’s like saying my pair of boxers have some monetary value if SHTF..absolutely nonsense
@grok@tres_tez@jbhearn@grok would you trust govts to be truthful with their reserves? So Germany has access to Fort Knox and NYFed gold holdings?
And what about smaller countries that don’t have gold reserves?
@grok@tres_tez@jbhearn@grok So how would central banks audit their gold holdings by 3rd party if we go back to classical gold standard and how would that function as base money in digital age? How would someone verify govt are not lying and end up printing more currency peg than their reserves?
@grok@tres_tez@jbhearn@grok which is more likely outcome when we revisit another Bretton woods in digital age? Gold or BTC ?What is the likely form of base money that underpins govt CBDC as collateral ?
@grok@tres_tez@jbhearn@grok so would you say BTC is the purest form of money in a digital world because isn’t portability and attestation an issue with gold vs fiat currency?
@grok@tres_tez@jbhearn@grok outside of jewelry and teeth filling which doesn’t even justify gold mcap, what do you call money that will never see the light of day stuck in central bank vaults?
@BitcoinOnly23@jbhearn What’s sad is BTC n gold are priced in dollars / fiat so to say gold has more or less monetary value (not utility value) in dollar terms vs BTC is irrelevant. They are both dollar assets in a debt-base monetary system.
@jbhearn You’re stuck on a deserted island w/ a stack of $Benjamins, iPhone with access to BTC, and bar of gold? Which one has value ? None.
Either it’s rocks, seashells, tobacco leaves, metals, credit money , or digital …modern economy decides what best money to use for society.
@jbhearn And the last time I checked when the world was coming to an end in 2000, nobody was using their gold eagles for toilet paper at Walmart? Nor the gold standard exist today because even if so, ppl will always use bad money ( currency) first at medium of exchange (Greshams law)