She said her children were alive and that she would take police to them. A judge said no. That was 12 years ago, and nobody has seen Sarah and Jacob since.
On September 7, 2014, Catherine Hoggle was the last person seen with her two kids in Montgomery County, Maryland. Sarah was 3 and Jacob was 2. Their father, Troy Turner, reported all three missing. Days later, police found Hoggle wandering alone in Germantown. The children weren’t with her, and she wouldn’t say where they were.
Two months later, prosecutors told a judge she had told her mother and Turner that the kids were alive, and that she was willing to lead police to them. They asked for an order letting police take her to search. The judge refused. Hoggle had been diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia, and he didn’t believe she was competent to go. The search never happened.
What followed was a decade of hospitals and court dates. She was ruled incompetent to stand trial and committed to a state psychiatric hospital, and she stayed there for years. In July 2025 she was released. Weeks later, prosecutors said they had new evidence and arrested her on two counts of first-degree murder. In October 2025, a judge ruled her competent to stand trial.
Her lawyers now say she isn’t criminally responsible, which is Maryland’s version of an insanity defense. They argue she was severely mentally ill when the children vanished. The trial was supposed to start last month. In September it was pushed back to October 2027.
The children’s bodies have never been found. She is charged with their murders, but she hasn’t been convicted.
[In the video below…]
She offered to take police to her kids, and a judge stopped it. Was that the one chance to find Sarah and Jacob, or was she never going to lead them anywhere?
@Tomdotdev A kid with a threat on record and a rifle at home isn't a 'wait and see' case. Departments need a rule that says so, not a deputy's gut feeling