If African organisational policies and procedures are largely extracted from Western values where our language, poise, and attire also come from without first grounding them in our own culture, then that lady was not wrong.
For the chairman of a global brand like UBA to say โI donโt subscribe to that Oyinbo lifeโ is selective and inconsistent.
You cannot enjoy the benefits of Western corporate structures and then reject the parts that donโt suit you.
You canโt eat your cake and have it. Titles and respect are not the same thing. The standard should apply without exception.
This is my submission.
If African organisational policies and procedures are largely extracted from Western values where our language, poise, and attire also come from without first grounding them in our own culture, then that lady was not wrong.
For the chairman of a global brand like UBA to say โI donโt subscribe to that Oyinbo lifeโ is selective and inconsistent. You cannot enjoy the benefits of Western corporate structures and then reject the parts that donโt suit you.
You canโt eat your cake and have it. Titles and respect are not the same thing. The standard should apply without exception.
This is my submission.
Thereโs a clear double standard in the Tony Elumelu โGood morning Tonyโ saga, and people are dancing around it.
A UBA graduate trainee called him โTonyโ during the GMAP event. He corrected her publicly and said he doesnโt subscribe to that โOyinbo life.โ Online, many jumped on her: โdisrespectful,โ โno home training,โ โthis is Nigeria, we have our culture.โ
But look at the full picture:
1. UBAโs own graduate training encourages first-name culture. Former GMAP staff have said trainees are taught to call colleagues (including seniors) by first name. Some even said the example given was that the GMD is โyour colleague.โ
2. At Stanford, a young Nigerian woman (Chisom Obi-Okoye) opened an interview with โHi, Tony.โ Elumelu replied warmly. No correction. No โOyinbo lifeโ lecture.
Same first-name address. Same young Nigerian woman. Different reaction depending on location and power.
Now the cultural defence: โThis is Nigeria, she canโt do that, we have our culture.โ
But almost every major Nigerian organisation, including UBA, runs on Western corporate structures โ the suits, the policies, the performance systems, the graduate programmes, the language. Nobody is running these banks on pure traditional protocols. We copy the Western standard in almost every area, then suddenly become selective and reach for โour cultureโ only when a junior person addresses a big man too casually.
If the organisation has already adopted the Western playbook (suits and all), it is inconsistent to treat first-name address as culturally illegitimate only when it is directed upward.
The trainee followed what the bank taught. She misread the power distance in that specific room โ thatโs a situational mistake, not a lack of home training.
Elumelu has every right to prefer formal address from his staff. Framing it as a principle he rejects, while accepting the exact same behaviour abroad, is where the double standard and the misleading part come in.
Thatโs the honest reading.
@AnglicanBeing Bro what is good for the goose is good for the gander, you donโt make policies and make an exception cos you own the place or the momentโฆ Thatโs not disrespect
@AnglicanBeing Yes!!!! A Governorโs name is a Governors name
Here in the United Kingdom the Prime Minister is Andy Burnham and we call him Andy
Respect is not in Titles itโs in how you treat people