@FrJody@freverett Yes, HOD rules of order. XIV.A. "Every Deputy must vote...." Section B allows for POHD to excuse someone.
We agree to the rules of order as Deputies.
@MarcoGSerrano That they feel comfortable doing so speaks to the effectiveness of your ministry! Your flock must have learned from your modeling compassionate care that they know they can reach out to you in times of need.
@AnnaBower Is it possible that the 3 judge panel shared any or all of the decision with the remaining 12 members? Would they have solicited input into the argument from them to stem any reversal if brought en banc?