I think you’re still missing Coach Martin’s point. You keep going back to when CPA played public schools, but the 2014 team that beat Alcoa was built largely around players who had been at CPA since they were young. CPA was not recruiting football players.
The concern is how much the high school football landscape has changed since then. Coach Martin is speaking up for the student who loves football and wants to play for his school, even if he isn’t an elite college prospect. That student deserves a place in high school football, too.
And if CPA’s goal were simply to avoid tougher competition, it could have stayed quiet. Based on the recently published enrollment numbers, CPA would have moved down to AA for the next two years, assuming LA and BA continued to opt up to AAA.
@NateBeeson@NashvillePreps I didn’t say all schools. I have no idea what school your child goes to. Nor do I need to know. But the fact is a fact, there are schools that do recruit players from out of state to replace the current players that they have that have been at that school for years.
I'm not throwing shade, I am simply stating a fact that there are some schools who actively recruit players (whether direct or indirectly) from all over the country. I said there is no judgement, it is just different than the model that CPA follows and wants for their athletics program.
Do you have evidence that CPA recruited while in Division I-AAA, or are you simply repeating a baseless claim? In other words, which player/s were recruited? Did you know that when CPA was in Division 1 AAA and won the state championship in 2014 against Alcoa, of their 22 starters, 20 of them had been enrolled at CPA since they were young. Before you continue to hate on CPA, I suggest you take a look at today’s enrollment numbers that were published a few hours ago by TSSAA. You will see that if CPA had stayed quiet and done nothing, they would have moved back down to AA because LA and BA continued to opt to play up in AAA. Coach Martin is standing up for what he believes in.
It is not a lack of money or ability of families at CPA to "buy" players, believe me there is plenty of money at CPA just like all of the other private schools. However, Coach Martin does not accept, support, or condone that type of athletic program. I have known him as a colleague when I used to coach at CPA years ago and now as parent whose child plays for him. He is one of the most honorable men I know and I am blessed my son has had the privilege to play for him.
Speaking as parent of a current CPA football player, I promise you there is no quit in these boys. They continue to show up every day and work and fight knowing that for many games they will face programs and coaches who have a different value and purpose than ours. You can call it quitting if you want but there are plenty of coaches and programs who feel the same as Coach Martin but may not have the support from their school leadership to stand up and make the difficult decision. The easy decision is to stay silent. The hard one is to stand up for what you believe in even when you know others will criticize you.
I’m beyond grateful my son has spent four years under Coach Martin, learning character, commitment and perseverance. Scores fade and trophies collect dust, but relationships and lessons endure. Proud of CPA for choosing student development over a recruiting arms race and championships at any cost. This was undoubtedly a difficult decision for Coach Martin and CPA leadership but that is what true leaders do, they make hard decisions in spite of the criticism they know they will face. I’ve already heard and seen the predictable response: “It’s because they aren’t winning anymore.” But that misses the larger point. Whatever you believe motivated CPA’s decision, the reality remains that some Tennessee high schools (we all know which ones) have created mini-college programs centered on recruiting elite athletes and winning championships rather than developing the students already there. If winning at all costs is what you value most in your child’s high school experience, there is no judgment, but CPA may simply not be the right fit for you.
I’m beyond grateful my son has spent four years under Coach Martin, learning character, commitment and perseverance. Scores fade and trophies collect dust, but relationships and lessons endure. Proud of CPA for choosing student development over a recruiting arms race and championships at any cost. This was undoubtedly a difficult decision for Coach Martin and CPA leadership but that is what true leaders do, they make hard decisions in spite of the criticism they know they will face. I’ve already heard and seen the predictable response: “It’s because they aren’t winning anymore.” But that misses the larger point. Whatever you believe motivated CPA’s decision, the reality remains that some Tennessee high schools (we all know which ones) have created mini-college programs centered on recruiting elite athletes and winning championships rather than developing the students already there. If winning at all costs is what you value most in your child’s high school experience, there is no judgment, but CPA may simply not be the right fit for you.