Utah Jazz, BYU sports, and bad opinions
Sports podcast host: @OnceDribble
Root beer connoisseur
Future novelist: "The Chasm of Nations", out Winter 2027
Hot take: instant replay simply doesn’t work.
It generally worked 20 years ago. Even 10 years ago. But today’s game moves so fast and game rules are so intricate, that even in slow motion replay, many calls are just subjective.
And if replay is subjective, replay DOES NOT WORK.
This play from BYU/Kansas is simply an incomplete pass. It was ruled catch and down. Replay reversed to fumble.
He did not have control long enough to perform an act common to the game.
During the review, it was casually stated that it was a catch without any discussion or video of the entire process.
Kirby Smart has gotta be the only dude in the world who unironically wears a visor hat in 2026. Like, I’m 99% the only reason Nike even manufactures them at all is exclusively for Kirby Smart
@JonnyRoot_@ClayTravis Any previous 4th down conversion history should have absolutely no bearing whatsoever on that decision. You don’t risk giving the ball just 10-15 yards from field goal range. If they’d been up by 4, it’d be a different story. No justification for that knuckleheaded coaching.
If BYU got the ball with 4:35 to play leading 24-17 they would call nothing but run plays until the drive stalled at the 45 yard line with 1:40 to play,
At which time they would punt, and the opponent would drive 75 yards in 90 seconds, and have a chance to tie (or win) on the last play of the game.
🤮
I wish Kalani Sitake and BYU would finish games like Utah.
TD with 5:46 left—24-17.
Ball back with 4:35 mins left—TD
Ball back with 3 mins left—TD
If it’s BYU, the game ends at 24-17.
Utah clearly has the Killer mentality that BYU’s coaches lack.
I’ve said many times that I think A-Rod is one of the best play designers in college football,
But his situational play calling is below average.
It’s a completely different skill than player development or play design. You essentially have 15-30 seconds to evaluate the situation, could be dozen factors all at once, and make an appropriate call. It’s VERY hard to do. And he’s just not great at it in many instances.
I’m calling it right now:
This is the JoJo Phillips moment of ascension
He’s been on the brink of breaking out for years (crazy he’s still only a junior, feels like he’s been here like 6 years)
But I think now he’s nearing full potential!
Exciting!