Big 12 statement:
"Following the Big 12’s review of the final play of Saturday’s Notre Dame-BYU game, it was determined that time remained on the clock when the ball hit the ground and the play was incorrectly cleared by the replay officiating crew. The Conference will conduct a complete review of its end-of-game officiating process in advance of next week's games."
I deleted my initial comment because I see there are different interpretations here.
It states that the in-stadium game clock is the official clock. It says again later that the game clock is the in-stadium clock. No sides to be taken here.
In a replay review, the official's decision will be based on the embedded game clock contained within the program feed. So, the expectation is that the broadcaster embeds the official game clock in that program feed. If not, then the official uses the clock graphic in the broadcast feed.
Further, it says at the bottom that the official should only restore time when the game clock shows time should have remained, and again clarifies that the game clock is the in-stadium clock.
So, with Michigan, we know the in-stadium clock showed time remaining; that's why time was added back on. The issue appears to be that the Big Ten used their own camera view of the correct clock. Presumably because NBC didn't provide it, and their broadcast clock was wrong? The team that was almost screwed here was Michigan because NBC's graphic didn't match the official clock.
Everyone is going to interpret this through their own bias, but if this clarifies that the in-stadium clock is the correct time, and the burden is on the network to provide that to the officials, then I want to hear from NBC that they are going to make sure the officials have a view of the actual game clock, not their graphic, which was proven to be wrong in this game.
@HausenKS I’m as harsh on Michigan as any one. I just don’t blast it on social media. According to the rules it was the correct call. Sorry opposing fan bases don’t like it.
Big Ten replay officials got it wrong in using a clock no one else could see over the game clock to give Michigan an extra play per @MikePereira on @joelklatt show. Good explanation here.
NBC is a terrible network for many reasons (can we see a damn replay?) but the whole spiel about how their clock is always synced perfectly when it clearly isn’t…. Incredibly annoying
@HausenKS Not sure how Michigan cheated? They didn’t make the call. Officiating errors happen all the time. If you consider this an officiating error. Probably happened 5 to 10 times this game.
@HausenKS It won’t, lol. Did Michigan ‘deserve’ to win by how they played? Absolutely not. There was time still on the clock, according to everyone in the know. Sucks for CMU, but also….stop a 45 yard Hail Mary.