Most dead UGC accounts weren't killed by bad content.
They were killed on day one.
New account. Posts a product video immediately. The algorithm sees a brand-new account pushing a product with zero history and treats it like a bot.
Every video after that is fighting uphill.
That's why every new creator account I run goes through a warm-up period before the first real post. A few days of acting like a real person in the niche: following, watching, engaging.
Then a warm-up video. Then the campaign starts.
It costs you a few days. It saves you the whole account.
There's a lot more that goes into a proper warm-up than this, and it's honestly the most important step in organic UGC that nobody talks about.
Do you warm up new creator accounts, or post day one?
Follow for more UGC playbooks.
A simple rule that saves hours every week in UGC:
Maximum 2 revisions per video. Ideally one.
When a video needs 4 rounds of feedback, most brands blame the creator.
The problem usually isn't the creator. It's the brief.
A vague brief creates vague videos. Then you spend your week writing feedback that should have been in the brief from the start.
A great brief answers every question before the creator has to ask it:
- Who is this for, specifically
- What problem it solves for them
- 3 to 5 hook options to test
- What a great video looks like (show a real example)
- What to avoid
- What happens next once it's approved
Fix the brief and three things happen at once:
Your revision count drops. Your output goes up. Your creators stop feeling micromanaged.
The brief is the most leveraged document in any UGC program, and it's usually the one brands spend the least time on.
How many revisions does your average video go through right now?
Follow for more UGC playbooks.
Great question david. I agree with the creators part, but scale your top creators to earn that. I love base pay then we move toward that incentive. The creators then think there is more room to grow in the company. Commission cap it at 10% but there is so many variables and directions you can do.
Earlier this week I said there's a third layer that makes DTC creators work harder than view bonuses ever will.
Here it is.
Give your UGC creators an affiliate link or a TikTok Shop setup on top of their base pay.
Now every video they make can earn them more than you're paying them.
That flips the entire dynamic.
Creators stop making content for you and start making it for themselves. They post more. They iterate faster. They study what sells instead of what just gets views. Some of them start optimizing harder than your own team.
So the full stack looks like this:
Base pay for consistency.
View bonuses for reach.
Affiliate for sales.
Each one rewards a different behavior, and together they line up what the creator wants with what the brand needs.
The catch: how you balance those three depends on the brand, the margins and the product. Get it wrong and you overpay for views that don't sell. Get it right and it compounds every month.
If you're DTC, are your creators earning on sales yet?
Follow for more UGC playbooks.
Don't deploy your full UGC budget on day one.
I see it constantly. A brand gets excited, signs 30 creators, commits a big monthly budget, and launches everything at once.
Six weeks later they've spent a lot and learned very little, because nothing was set up to teach them anything.
The brands that win run it differently:
1. Start with a test group
2. Run it for 2 weeks
3. Track everything daily: views, hooks, personas, angles, what's converting
4. Find what's working
5. Scale only what's proven
Two weeks of disciplined testing will save you months of expensive guessing.
And the data you get becomes the brief for every creator you add next. Your second wave of creators starts where the first wave finished.
One more thing most people underestimate: track daily, not weekly.
If you're only looking at results once a week, you're reacting a week late, every week. Over a quarter that adds up to a month of wasted spend.
How often are you actually looking at your UGC numbers?
Follow for more UGC playbooks.
"We'll pay you $2 for every 1,000 views. Post as much as you want."
This is the most popular UGC pay structure right now, and I think it's quietly broken.
On paper it's fair. You only pay for results.
In reality:
- Most new accounts don't pop in week one
- Creators make 20 videos and earn almost nothing
- Your best creators leave for brands that pay a base
- You're left with whoever has nothing better to do
Can it work long term? Yes. Once creators have proven accounts, a CPM can be great.
But to start, creators need a floor. Base pay buys you consistency. Bonuses buy you performance, and they can be as simple as an extra $500 to your top creator of the month.
Pay for the behavior you want, not just the outcome you hope for.
Do you pay creators a base, a CPM, or both?
Follow for more UGC playbooks.
4 variables decide whether a UGC video works:
Hook. Persona. Angle. Format.
And the biggest testing mistake I see is changing all 4 at once and calling it a test.
New creator. New script. New angle. New format. It wins. Great.
But why did it win? Nobody knows. So nobody can repeat it.
Or it loses, and a perfectly good hook gets thrown out because it was paired with the wrong persona.
Here's how I test instead:
Change one variable. Hold the other three. Run it across multiple creators at the same time.
One creator is an anecdote. Ten creators is data.
I do that every week, and it builds a library of what actually works for each product: the hooks that stop the scroll, the personas buyers trust, the angles that convert, the formats the algorithm rewards.
That library is worth more than any single viral video.
And the variable most brands under-test? Persona. By a mile. Most teams test 20 hooks and 1 type of person saying them.
Which variable do you test the most?
Follow for more UGC playbooks.
I save 20 to 30 hours a week running creator programs.
Not by working harder. By building an AI ops dashboard my whole team runs on.
Here's what it does:
- Tracks every creator and every video
- Builds a cut list and a keep list automatically
- Shows who's performing over the last 7 days
- Tracks payouts so nothing gets missed
- Holds every brief, hiring link and client request in one place
- Drafts creator messages for me to approve
Before this, half my week was spreadsheets and chasing updates. Now my team sees everything, deadlines don't slip, and I spend my time on the part that actually matters: making the content better.
Most UGC programs still run on scattered spreadsheets and group chats.
What's the most manual part of how you run creators right now?
Follow for more UGC playbooks.
The hardest skill in UGC isn't finding creators.
It's cutting them.
Most brands hold on too long. They like the creator. They feel bad. They hope next week will be different.
Meanwhile they're paying for content that isn't working, and the creators who are working watch it happen.
Here's the routine I run on every roster, every week:
1. Review who's hitting view minimums and who isn't
2. Look at who's improving vs. who's flat
3. Cut who isn't working
4. Replace them with creators who look like my top performers, not my average ones
Your roster should get better every single week.
If it looks the same as it did a month ago, you're paying for comfort, not results.
And cutting doesn't have to be cold. Be direct. Be respectful. Thank them. Leave the door open.
The creators you keep are watching how you treat the ones you let go. Handle it well and your team trusts you more, not less.
What's harder for you, finding great creators or letting go of average ones?
Follow for more UGC playbooks.
100% agree, the best set up is setting up there own page and dedicated toward the brand, the smallest signal i find is a combo of early traction on reviews, but shares is a massive one in my opinion and I will lean on that a lot. There is no minimal as different things can work. Lmk what you think?
Not every UGC video should be an ad.
This is one of the most misunderstood parts of creator marketing, and it costs brands a lot of money.
There are two kinds of UGC:
Organic content is built to earn attention. It feels native. Entertaining. Real. People watch it because they want to, not because it was served to them.
Paid content is built to convert. It gets to the point faster, handles objections, and makes the next step obvious.
They open differently. They pace differently. They end differently.
Most brands pick the videos they think will work, put ad spend behind them, and pay to find out they were wrong.
Here's the order I run it in:
1. Post everything organically first
2. Let the audience show me what actually resonates
3. Put spend behind the proven winners
4. Cut ad-specific versions of those winners where needed
Testing in organic is close to free. Testing in paid is not.
Let your audience pick your ads for you.
Which do you test first right now, organic or paid?
Follow for more UGC playbooks.
The most underrated lever in UGC isn't pay.
It's making creators feel like they're part of the company.
Most brands treat creators like vendors. Send a brief. Wait for a video. Pay an invoice. Repeat.
And they get vendor-level effort back.
When creators believe in what you're building, everything changes:
- They post more consistently
- Their content gets better every week
- They stay longer
- They start bringing you ideas instead of waiting for instructions
- They actually care whether it works
That's why I talk to creators daily, or every other day at minimum.
Not just about deliverables. About what's working right now. What we're testing next. Which video is the current winner and why. Where the brand is headed.
I've had creators message me just to say they love being part of a campaign. That doesn't happen by accident. It happens because they feel like they're on a team.
You can pay creators well and still get average work. Or you can make them believe in the mission and watch the output change.
How often do you talk to your creators?
Follow for more UGC playbooks.
The fastest way to find a winning UGC format isn't coming up with one.
It's stealing one.
Every niche has 5 to 10 brands already spending real money on ads. Their top videos have been tested with thousands of dollars before you ever see them.
So I do this:
1. Pull the top-performing ads from the biggest competitors in the niche
2. Break down what's working: hook, persona, angle, format
3. Rebuild it for our product, in our creators' voices
4. Have the whole roster hammer that format
5. Keep a few creators testing brand new angles on the side
Original ideas are great. But you don't win by being original. You win by being fast.
Let the competitors pay to test. You take the winners.
Do you study your competitors' ads, or start from scratch every time?
Follow for more UGC playbooks.
Unpopular UGC opinion: skip the paid trial week.
Most brands bring creators on with a "let's see how the first week goes" trial. It sounds safe.
It quietly kills your content.
A creator who feels like they're auditioning plays it safe. Generic hooks. Careful scripts. Nothing that takes a risk.
So I do the opposite.
I tell creators from day one: we want you. You're part of this. Here's where we're going.
Confidence changes the work. A creator who feels chosen takes swings.
Then I protect quality with structure, not fear:
1. A view minimum per video. It filters low-effort content fast without me micromanaging anyone.
2. Bonuses at 50K and 100K views. Now creators are chasing performance, not just checking off deliverables.
You can still cut anyone who isn't a fit. You just never make them feel temporary while they're on the team.
For DTC brands there's a third layer that makes creators work even harder than bonuses do. I'll break it down this week.
Do you run creator trials, or go all in from day one?
Follow so you don't miss part 2.
Talent is the 4th thing I vet UGC creators for.
Here's why it isn't first.
When you run 200+ creators, the bottleneck is never talent. It's response time.
If I ask a question and hear back 2 days later:
- The brief update is late
- The trend is gone
- The winning format moved on without them
Here's what I look for when vetting, in order:
1. Communication. Do they reply fast?
2. Consistency. Will they keep posting when nothing hits for 2 weeks?
3. Work ethic. Do they actually want to understand the product?
4. On camera. Do they feel natural, not forced?
Notice what's not on the list. Follower count.
Skills can be coached. Communication can't.
What's your #1 dealbreaker with a creator?
Follow for more UGC playbooks.
Most brands kill their own viral UGC videos.
With one message to every creator: "Do that again."
Every creator copies the exact video. The audience sees the same thing 30 times. Performance drops in a week. The brand decides it was luck.
Here's what I do instead:
Step 1: Figure out WHY it worked.
It's almost always one of four things:
- The hook (the first 2 seconds)
- The persona (who's saying it)
- The angle (the reason to care)
- The format (how it's shot and paced)
Step 2: Isolate that one variable.
Step 3: Build 5 to 10 variations around it and hand a version to every creator, in their own voice and style.
What works for one creator almost always works for many others. Just never the exact same video.
The hard part is step 1. Most brands guess the wrong variable, copy the wrong thing, and wonder why the magic disappeared.
Next time something of yours hits, which of the four would you bet it was?
Follow for more UGC playbooks.
The most expensive UGC mistake isn't bad content.
It's great content from the wrong person.
I've seen creators make genuinely good videos that did nothing for sales. Great lighting. Great hook. Solid views.
Zero conversions.
Because the person on screen didn't look like the person buying.
Before I recruit a single creator for a brand, I want answers to 3 questions:
1. Who is actually buying this product?
2. Who do they already trust?
3. Who do they want to become?
Most brands only answer #1. They recruit people who look like their customer and stop there.
#3 is where the real upside is.
People don't just buy from people like them. They buy from the version of themselves they're trying to become. The creator who represents that aspiration often outperforms everyone else on the roster.
Experiment at the edges. Test a persona you're unsure about. But don't go off the rails chasing views from an audience that will never buy.
Who's the most unexpected creator persona that's ever worked for your brand?
Follow for more UGC playbooks.