The Socratic Method survived the collapse of the Classical World, the Dark Ages, and the apocalyptic 20th Century, but it couldn't survive one generation of women in academia.
To hammer in further what is being deliberately portrayed by Tolkien, the entirety of the fellowship of the Ring is landed nobility or gentry of some stripe, save for Gandalf. Gandalf is an angelic being incarnated in the flesh, but Aragorn is obviously the heir of Gondor, Legolas a prince, Gimli is a lord, Boromir the heir to the Stewards.
But the hobbits are where people really miss things. Merry is the heir to Buckland, a politically autonomous outpost of the hobbits near the shire, making him nobility as well, and Pippin is the heir to the Thain of the Shire, the military leader and the closest thing they have to a king, making him a prince. Frodo is landed gentry himself and upper class. Literally only Sam works for a living.
The three hobbits save Sam are upper class young men living lives of total leisure where they do not work at all for a living and instead collect rents and live off their inheritance and estate while spending all day enjoying the simple things of life while someone like Sam works their garden.
And Sam’s virtue is in how faithful he is to his master to whom he owes his allegiance. It is because he upholds this order dutifully that he is good.
The actual story of the hobbits is that three upper class trust fund kids and their servant go off to save the world then come back home and save that as well, and this is the virtue of why we should have hierarchical classes of which they will do no labor whatsoever and simply collect inherited money and have workers for their estates, that they will hold inherited status above others, and that this is actually a good thing for society because these people are better.
@TBOE07997714@Jbus21_@KaiserLoengramm To the movies’ credit, Aragorn embraces his destiny and immediately goes through the Path’s of the Dead, this proving his legitimacy as king.
@TBOE07997714@Jbus21_@KaiserLoengramm I guess a big charge would be how reluctant Aragorn seems in the movies.
The audience knows from the first film that he is the heir, but he only seems to truly embrace that after Elrond gives him Andúril in the Return of the King.
Boromir is interesting in particular as he contests against Aragorn, which is the real, good power, the heir of Elendil who is bearing Anduril the sword of the west. Narsil is reforged and given to Aragorn right at the very beginning in the books. Boromir rejects this at first, but in the end he submits before Aragorn as well as turning from the ring.
That’s what you keep missing in all of this, that the book blatantly displays good power as traditional hereditary monarchical lines and restoration, and the magic sword of the west, and the ring is the bad one because it’s about unnatural subjugation made by evil people.
The movie does a really bad job of conveying this, and in fact makes it the opposite. Movie Aragorn is highly reluctant, only taking up this position of power and as the heir because he is forced to, and only getting Anduril at the very end.
Book Aragorn however immediately asserts himself as heir, declares that he is going to take back the throne of Gondor, with Boromir present. Boromir as the heir to the stewards hears this man claim what he believes is his birthright, and contends that he alone has been actually fighting whereas Aragorn has been hiding away, to which Aragorn replies he has been fighting battles in the North his whole life with the Rangers, and now it is time for his return.
The reason why Boromir succumbs to the ring isn’t simply that he “wants power.” He is highly reluctant to honor the covenant made by his ancestors as stewards holding the throne until the line of Elendil returns. That’s something that happened hundreds of years ago, and not something he would have ever been expected to be asked to honor.
So, rather than holding to what has been provided to him as the savior of his people, the rightful king returning with the sword of the west in hand, he instead is seduced by the one true ring.
This is very clearly a story about natural order, natural hierarchy, honoring agreements and covenants, and the restoration of good and order to the world against entropy and chaos.
What about this is liberal, within the actual text of the book? Because you can make these arguments with the movie, but then trying to attribute that to the fault of Tolkien would be like attributing Nolan’s Odyssey to the fault of Homer.
@KaiserLoengramm I would also like to add that the “Campi Hobbit” (Hobbit Camps) got thousands of young Italian right wingers together in the late 70’s and early 80’s. Not really complacent, and hardly something the work of leftist subversive could do.
Este é o Cardeal albanês Ernest Simoni, considerado hoje um verdadeiro "mártir vivo" da Igreja Católica. Na década de 1960, durante a brutal ditadura comunista na Albânia, ele foi preso após rezar uma missa pela alma do presidente americano John F. Kennedy.
Condenado à morte e depois a trabalhos forçados, ele passou quase 30 anos entre prisões, minas e canais de esgoto. Mesmo no cárcere, ele nunca deixou de ser padre: rezava missas escondido em latim, de memória, espremendo uvas com as próprias mãos para fazer o vinho e usando migalhas de pão cozidas em fogareiros improvisados como hóstia.
Décadas depois, em 2016, sua história de resistência e perdão emocionou tanto o Papa Francisco que ele foi nomeado cardeal — um reconhecimento raro para quem nunca havia sido bispo.
Um grande homem, sem dúvida.
Quando era menor eu tinha a impressão de que cigarro era coisa de homens legais e másculos (como Clint Eastwood, James Bond e meu pai), mas desde que passei a observar esse monte de puta e viado fumando na rua eu passei a ter uma certa aversão ao tabaco
I think that this interaction is needlessly cruel
That said, it show how a lot of women enjoy dehumanising “men” as a whole, while seemingly making exceptions for the men they love
Columnist Julie Burchill mocked the idea of male suicide, then years later her son killed himself
@nordestizzo@IsaacRondhart@Davi18184554 Também não é a primeira vez que esse aí aparece nos meus comentários. Acho admirável o esforço dele de acompanhar os posts de tanta gente que ele odeia.