@BrookeJoyTV This is a good point to bring up. I really wish they would have told us and just kind of tied off that storyline. I'm never a big fan of when books or movies don't give a distinct ending to a storyline. #engl20512
@SophDugan23 I really enjoyed reading this part as well. Her character development and growing into herself and her power has probably been the best aspect of the book for me. It's not really a coming of age story but she's definitely maturing. #engl20512
On pages 280-281 we see sierra shadowshape. The book mentions "become one" with the spirits. I think this scene really show's how far Sierra has come in her shadow shaping and really embracing her power/family legacy. #engl20512
@Cierra51570013 I definitely thought that Robbie had something to do with it or at least knew about the shadow shaper world so I wasn't too surprised but it for sure added some suspense to the story. #engl20512
@SophDugan23 I think you make a great point! Sierra not only feels betrayed but also excluded. No one likes when something is kept from them but not their sibling. I think it adds to Sierra being relatable and having emotions that YA readers can relate to. #engl20512
On page 93, Sierra and Robbie talk about shadow shaping and how it really happens. I feel like it's interesting how the author describes shadowshaping and I think that he maybe could have elaborated and painted a better picture because it's maybe slightly confusing. #engl20512
@trevorr177 I would also say that 95% of books I read had a white main character and possibly had supporting characters that were POC. Even if there were people of color playing any sort of role in the book, their lives and personality were barely touched on. #engl20512
@MorganSchenkel This is very important. Like we're discussing in class reading about blackjoy is important. Blackjoy can also tie into representation because the more representation that we see, the more stories we read about different black lives and possibly more happy stories. #engl20512
The cosmo article "don't just read about racism" mentions how what we read and watch shapes us. I think everyone can relate to pressure from the media to look a certain way but especially when you have no representation it has to be so much more difficult. #engl20512
@Cierra51570013 His uncles response surprised me. I know that the rules are important to them but personally I think that someone wouldn't want their own nephew wrapped up in violence even if it was to avenge Shawn. It made me wonder if he cared about Will's safety. #engl20512
@valatkas_payton I like how your mentioned that the portrayal is realistic because a lot of times authors are too worried about the response to write about gun violence but Reynold's was very upfront and did it in a way that was beneficial to learning about the actual effects. #engl20512
This scene was so emotional and sad. It really makes me think about people who have had to go through a loved one dying from violence. I really wasn't expecting shawn to get on the elevator even though everyone else was on, I just didn't expect it.#engl20512
@paytonchandle11 This page also stood out to me but for different reasons. I couldn't imagine having to talk to cops after something so traumatic happened. I don't think most people could form a coherent sentence. It made me think about people who actually have to go through it. #engl20512
@BrookeJoyTV I agree with this completely, especially when their mother is next to Shawn, I could only imagine her pain but it was conveyed so well through the text and images combined. #engl20512
After Shawn dies, before Will steps on the elevator, he gives reason as to why he thinks Riggs killed his brother. To me none of those reasons really explain why he would what to kill shawn and at this point the reasoning doesn't make much sense. #engl20512
@MadelynMeder I think this is interesting because I have never read graphic novels before, so I am looking forward to seeing what deeper meaning I can look for or if the book will be difficult to comprehend at all. #engl20512
@MorganSchenkel I thought that was really thought provoking and something that might show up in the novel. From what the story is about it seems like doing the right thing may even be a theme of the novel. #engl20512
The website Riveted by sion teen mentions that not only is the book a graphic novel but it also is written as poetry. They call it a "novel in verse." This is interesting to me because i don't read graphic novels or poetry. #engl20512