https://t.co/0KohZfzl9q
Let's follow and support one another, and help each other grow our long-form video channels on X!
Please also take a moment to read my post and the concerns I've raised. I hope we can work together, support each other, and stand up against YouTube's unfair treatment of creators.
Hello everyone.
I believe one of the main reasons many creators are moving to X is that YouTube has suddenly demonetized their channels without a clear explanation, leaving them with almost nowhere to turn when they try to appeal.
We shouldn't remain scattered, each of us complaining on our own. If we're willing to pay for X Premium and maintain our blue checkmarks, it means we still want to keep making videos and making our voices heard.
We're different from accounts that simply repost other people's content. Paying for X shows that we're serious creators who are willing to invest in our own work.
So I'd like to suggest a few things we can start doing together.
First, upload one of your older long-form videos every day. Our old videos are valuable assets. Reposting them also gives us an opportunity to share behind-the-scenes stories, explain our creative process, or add thoughts we didn't get to share before.
Second, tell people how YouTube treated you. Share your experiences, and include screenshots whenever possible. We can post about these experiences every day so more people understand that these aren't isolated incidents.
Third, follow and support one another. Watch each other's work. Building an audience and qualifying for long-form video monetization on X takes time, and supporting each other could help us establish another source of income here.
We need to organize if we want our voices to have real impact. If enough creators come together, perhaps we could even formally bring our concerns to Elon Musk's attention.
Right now, I believe X is probably the second-best platform for hosting long-form videos.
Facebook is another option, although without a paid membership barrier, content may be more vulnerable to unauthorized reposting. Still, it's worth trying.
There's also Kick, which currently focuses mainly on gaming and livestreaming. If its operators ever recognize this opportunity and welcome creators who produce narrative films, I believe it could gradually become another viable platform.
At the moment, I think X's biggest weakness is its relatively limited long-form video ecosystem.
Meanwhile, YouTube seems to be pushing away creators who genuinely invest their time and effort into producing long-form content.
This could be our opportunity to fill that gap and help expand long-form video content on X.
If we could eventually reach television audiences as well, we might finally stop being completely dependent on a single platform.
Many AI video creators have been demonetized for supposedly producing "repetitive content" or "template-based content."
But when the same person directs multiple films, of course there will be similarities in style!
You cannot expect emotionless AI systems to fairly judge works created with genuine human emotion.
Every creator has their own way of expressing feelings, and naturally, some patterns will appear across their work.
How can an AI system reliably determine whether those similarities make the content repetitive?
YouTube previously cut large numbers of employees, and now it seems to be relying on AI in ways that are causing chaos for smaller channels.
What makes this even worse is that demonetized channels can still upload videos, and their videos can still be watched with advertisements.
The creators receive nothing.
It feels like YouTube is deliberately encouraging people to work for free.
YouTube appears to want a subscription-driven business model similar to Netflix. On one hand, it encourages everyone to upload videos, opening the door to creative people beyond the traditional Hollywood industry.
On the other hand, its monetization decisions can leave those same creators providing content without compensation.
That's shameless.
To some extent, this reflects YouTube's dominance over long-form video. Platforms like TikTok, Xiaohongshu, and others simply don't have the same volume of long-form content.
Many demonetized creators have channels with tens of thousands or even hundreds of thousands of subscribers.
Yet it often feels as though YouTube only takes creators with more than a million subscribers seriously, while everyone else is treated as disposable.
YouTube knows it dominates long-form video, and that's exactly why we should support each other and help build a stronger long-form video community on X.
If people are willing to spend their time watching our work, then that work has value.
Viewers could also discover different kinds of content here.
And as people spend more time on X, they may naturally spend less time on YouTube.
In some ways, this is still an untapped market. That's why we should unite.
As for me, I create fairy-tale adaptations that aim to stay as faithful as possible to the original works of Giambattista Basile, Charles Perrault, and the Brothers Grimm.
My goal is to build a cinematic library of literary works.
I had only just been approved for YouTube monetization at the end of October, and then, on November 18, my monetization was removed.
If YouTube believed there was something wrong with my content from the beginning, why approve my channel for the YouTube Partner Program in the first place?
Later, I was told my content was repetitive.
But my Shorts are simply memorable scenes taken from my own original long-form films.
For example, the scene in Hansel and Gretel where the witch is pushed into the oven, or the magical transformation of Cinderella's pumpkin carriage.
These are exactly the kinds of attention-grabbing moments YouTube has always encouraged creators to use as hooks.
We're constantly told to put the most engaging moments at the beginning to capture viewers' attention.
Countless creators turn highlights from their long-form videos into Shorts.
And now we're being told that this is repetitive content?
YouTube is contradicting its own advice!
If you've experienced something similar, I encourage you to share your story too.
Let's start by bringing creators together here on X.
We shouldn't have to face this alone.
https://t.co/0KohZfyNjS
Let's follow and support one another, and help each other grow our long-form video channels on X!
Please also take a moment to read my post and the concerns I've raised. I hope we can work together, support each other, and stand up against YouTube's unfair treatment of creators.
Hello everyone.
I believe one of the main reasons many creators are moving to X is that YouTube has suddenly demonetized their channels without a clear explanation, leaving them with almost nowhere to turn when they try to appeal.
We shouldn't remain scattered, each of us complaining on our own. If we're willing to pay for X Premium and maintain our blue checkmarks, it means we still want to keep making videos and making our voices heard.
We're different from accounts that simply repost other people's content. Paying for X shows that we're serious creators who are willing to invest in our own work.
So I'd like to suggest a few things we can start doing together.
First, upload one of your older long-form videos every day. Our old videos are valuable assets. Reposting them also gives us an opportunity to share behind-the-scenes stories, explain our creative process, or add thoughts we didn't get to share before.
Second, tell people how YouTube treated you. Share your experiences, and include screenshots whenever possible. We can post about these experiences every day so more people understand that these aren't isolated incidents.
Third, follow and support one another. Watch each other's work. Building an audience and qualifying for long-form video monetization on X takes time, and supporting each other could help us establish another source of income here.
We need to organize if we want our voices to have real impact. If enough creators come together, perhaps we could even formally bring our concerns to Elon Musk's attention.
Right now, I believe X is probably the second-best platform for hosting long-form videos.
Facebook is another option, although without a paid membership barrier, content may be more vulnerable to unauthorized reposting. Still, it's worth trying.
There's also Kick, which currently focuses mainly on gaming and livestreaming. If its operators ever recognize this opportunity and welcome creators who produce narrative films, I believe it could gradually become another viable platform.
At the moment, I think X's biggest weakness is its relatively limited long-form video ecosystem.
Meanwhile, YouTube seems to be pushing away creators who genuinely invest their time and effort into producing long-form content.
This could be our opportunity to fill that gap and help expand long-form video content on X.
If we could eventually reach television audiences as well, we might finally stop being completely dependent on a single platform.
Many AI video creators have been demonetized for supposedly producing "repetitive content" or "template-based content."
But when the same person directs multiple films, of course there will be similarities in style!
You cannot expect emotionless AI systems to fairly judge works created with genuine human emotion.
Every creator has their own way of expressing feelings, and naturally, some patterns will appear across their work.
How can an AI system reliably determine whether those similarities make the content repetitive?
YouTube previously cut large numbers of employees, and now it seems to be relying on AI in ways that are causing chaos for smaller channels.
What makes this even worse is that demonetized channels can still upload videos, and their videos can still be watched with advertisements.
The creators receive nothing.
It feels like YouTube is deliberately encouraging people to work for free.
YouTube appears to want a subscription-driven business model similar to Netflix. On one hand, it encourages everyone to upload videos, opening the door to creative people beyond the traditional Hollywood industry.
On the other hand, its monetization decisions can leave those same creators providing content without compensation.
That's shameless.
To some extent, this reflects YouTube's dominance over long-form video. Platforms like TikTok, Xiaohongshu, and others simply don't have the same volume of long-form content.
Many demonetized creators have channels with tens of thousands or even hundreds of thousands of subscribers.
Yet it often feels as though YouTube only takes creators with more than a million subscribers seriously, while everyone else is treated as disposable.
YouTube knows it dominates long-form video, and that's exactly why we should support each other and help build a stronger long-form video community on X.
If people are willing to spend their time watching our work, then that work has value.
Viewers could also discover different kinds of content here.
And as people spend more time on X, they may naturally spend less time on YouTube.
In some ways, this is still an untapped market. That's why we should unite.
As for me, I create fairy-tale adaptations that aim to stay as faithful as possible to the original works of Giambattista Basile, Charles Perrault, and the Brothers Grimm.
My goal is to build a cinematic library of literary works.
I had only just been approved for YouTube monetization at the end of October, and then, on November 18, my monetization was removed.
If YouTube believed there was something wrong with my content from the beginning, why approve my channel for the YouTube Partner Program in the first place?
Later, I was told my content was repetitive.
But my Shorts are simply memorable scenes taken from my own original long-form films.
For example, the scene in Hansel and Gretel where the witch is pushed into the oven, or the magical transformation of Cinderella's pumpkin carriage.
These are exactly the kinds of attention-grabbing moments YouTube has always encouraged creators to use as hooks.
We're constantly told to put the most engaging moments at the beginning to capture viewers' attention.
Countless creators turn highlights from their long-form videos into Shorts.
And now we're being told that this is repetitive content?
YouTube is contradicting its own advice!
If you've experienced something similar, I encourage you to share your story too.
Let's start by bringing creators together here on X.
We shouldn't have to face this alone.
https://t.co/0KohZfzl9q
Let's follow and support one another, and help each other grow our long-form video channels on X!
Please also take a moment to read my post and the concerns I've raised. I hope we can work together, support each other, and stand up against YouTube's unfair treatment of creators.
Hello everyone.
I believe one of the main reasons many creators are moving to X is that YouTube has suddenly demonetized their channels without a clear explanation, leaving them with almost nowhere to turn when they try to appeal.
We shouldn't remain scattered, each of us complaining on our own. If we're willing to pay for X Premium and maintain our blue checkmarks, it means we still want to keep making videos and making our voices heard.
We're different from accounts that simply repost other people's content. Paying for X shows that we're serious creators who are willing to invest in our own work.
So I'd like to suggest a few things we can start doing together.
First, upload one of your older long-form videos every day. Our old videos are valuable assets. Reposting them also gives us an opportunity to share behind-the-scenes stories, explain our creative process, or add thoughts we didn't get to share before.
Second, tell people how YouTube treated you. Share your experiences, and include screenshots whenever possible. We can post about these experiences every day so more people understand that these aren't isolated incidents.
Third, follow and support one another. Watch each other's work. Building an audience and qualifying for long-form video monetization on X takes time, and supporting each other could help us establish another source of income here.
We need to organize if we want our voices to have real impact. If enough creators come together, perhaps we could even formally bring our concerns to Elon Musk's attention.
Right now, I believe X is probably the second-best platform for hosting long-form videos.
Facebook is another option, although without a paid membership barrier, content may be more vulnerable to unauthorized reposting. Still, it's worth trying.
There's also Kick, which currently focuses mainly on gaming and livestreaming. If its operators ever recognize this opportunity and welcome creators who produce narrative films, I believe it could gradually become another viable platform.
At the moment, I think X's biggest weakness is its relatively limited long-form video ecosystem.
Meanwhile, YouTube seems to be pushing away creators who genuinely invest their time and effort into producing long-form content.
This could be our opportunity to fill that gap and help expand long-form video content on X.
If we could eventually reach television audiences as well, we might finally stop being completely dependent on a single platform.
Many AI video creators have been demonetized for supposedly producing "repetitive content" or "template-based content."
But when the same person directs multiple films, of course there will be similarities in style!
You cannot expect emotionless AI systems to fairly judge works created with genuine human emotion.
Every creator has their own way of expressing feelings, and naturally, some patterns will appear across their work.
How can an AI system reliably determine whether those similarities make the content repetitive?
YouTube previously cut large numbers of employees, and now it seems to be relying on AI in ways that are causing chaos for smaller channels.
What makes this even worse is that demonetized channels can still upload videos, and their videos can still be watched with advertisements.
The creators receive nothing.
It feels like YouTube is deliberately encouraging people to work for free.
YouTube appears to want a subscription-driven business model similar to Netflix. On one hand, it encourages everyone to upload videos, opening the door to creative people beyond the traditional Hollywood industry.
On the other hand, its monetization decisions can leave those same creators providing content without compensation.
That's shameless.
To some extent, this reflects YouTube's dominance over long-form video. Platforms like TikTok, Xiaohongshu, and others simply don't have the same volume of long-form content.
Many demonetized creators have channels with tens of thousands or even hundreds of thousands of subscribers.
Yet it often feels as though YouTube only takes creators with more than a million subscribers seriously, while everyone else is treated as disposable.
YouTube knows it dominates long-form video, and that's exactly why we should support each other and help build a stronger long-form video community on X.
If people are willing to spend their time watching our work, then that work has value.
Viewers could also discover different kinds of content here.
And as people spend more time on X, they may naturally spend less time on YouTube.
In some ways, this is still an untapped market. That's why we should unite.
As for me, I create fairy-tale adaptations that aim to stay as faithful as possible to the original works of Giambattista Basile, Charles Perrault, and the Brothers Grimm.
My goal is to build a cinematic library of literary works.
I had only just been approved for YouTube monetization at the end of October, and then, on November 18, my monetization was removed.
If YouTube believed there was something wrong with my content from the beginning, why approve my channel for the YouTube Partner Program in the first place?
Later, I was told my content was repetitive.
But my Shorts are simply memorable scenes taken from my own original long-form films.
For example, the scene in Hansel and Gretel where the witch is pushed into the oven, or the magical transformation of Cinderella's pumpkin carriage.
These are exactly the kinds of attention-grabbing moments YouTube has always encouraged creators to use as hooks.
We're constantly told to put the most engaging moments at the beginning to capture viewers' attention.
Countless creators turn highlights from their long-form videos into Shorts.
And now we're being told that this is repetitive content?
YouTube is contradicting its own advice!
If you've experienced something similar, I encourage you to share your story too.
Let's start by bringing creators together here on X.
We shouldn't have to face this alone.
https://t.co/0KohZfzl9q
Let's follow and support one another, and help each other grow our long-form video channels on X!
Please also take a moment to read my post and the concerns I've raised. I hope we can work together, support each other, and stand up against YouTube's unfair treatment of creators.
Hello everyone.
I believe one of the main reasons many creators are moving to X is that YouTube has suddenly demonetized their channels without a clear explanation, leaving them with almost nowhere to turn when they try to appeal.
We shouldn't remain scattered, each of us complaining on our own. If we're willing to pay for X Premium and maintain our blue checkmarks, it means we still want to keep making videos and making our voices heard.
We're different from accounts that simply repost other people's content. Paying for X shows that we're serious creators who are willing to invest in our own work.
So I'd like to suggest a few things we can start doing together.
First, upload one of your older long-form videos every day. Our old videos are valuable assets. Reposting them also gives us an opportunity to share behind-the-scenes stories, explain our creative process, or add thoughts we didn't get to share before.
Second, tell people how YouTube treated you. Share your experiences, and include screenshots whenever possible. We can post about these experiences every day so more people understand that these aren't isolated incidents.
Third, follow and support one another. Watch each other's work. Building an audience and qualifying for long-form video monetization on X takes time, and supporting each other could help us establish another source of income here.
We need to organize if we want our voices to have real impact. If enough creators come together, perhaps we could even formally bring our concerns to Elon Musk's attention.
Right now, I believe X is probably the second-best platform for hosting long-form videos.
Facebook is another option, although without a paid membership barrier, content may be more vulnerable to unauthorized reposting. Still, it's worth trying.
There's also Kick, which currently focuses mainly on gaming and livestreaming. If its operators ever recognize this opportunity and welcome creators who produce narrative films, I believe it could gradually become another viable platform.
At the moment, I think X's biggest weakness is its relatively limited long-form video ecosystem.
Meanwhile, YouTube seems to be pushing away creators who genuinely invest their time and effort into producing long-form content.
This could be our opportunity to fill that gap and help expand long-form video content on X.
If we could eventually reach television audiences as well, we might finally stop being completely dependent on a single platform.
Many AI video creators have been demonetized for supposedly producing "repetitive content" or "template-based content."
But when the same person directs multiple films, of course there will be similarities in style!
You cannot expect emotionless AI systems to fairly judge works created with genuine human emotion.
Every creator has their own way of expressing feelings, and naturally, some patterns will appear across their work.
How can an AI system reliably determine whether those similarities make the content repetitive?
YouTube previously cut large numbers of employees, and now it seems to be relying on AI in ways that are causing chaos for smaller channels.
What makes this even worse is that demonetized channels can still upload videos, and their videos can still be watched with advertisements.
The creators receive nothing.
It feels like YouTube is deliberately encouraging people to work for free.
YouTube appears to want a subscription-driven business model similar to Netflix. On one hand, it encourages everyone to upload videos, opening the door to creative people beyond the traditional Hollywood industry.
On the other hand, its monetization decisions can leave those same creators providing content without compensation.
That's shameless.
To some extent, this reflects YouTube's dominance over long-form video. Platforms like TikTok, Xiaohongshu, and others simply don't have the same volume of long-form content.
Many demonetized creators have channels with tens of thousands or even hundreds of thousands of subscribers.
Yet it often feels as though YouTube only takes creators with more than a million subscribers seriously, while everyone else is treated as disposable.
YouTube knows it dominates long-form video, and that's exactly why we should support each other and help build a stronger long-form video community on X.
If people are willing to spend their time watching our work, then that work has value.
Viewers could also discover different kinds of content here.
And as people spend more time on X, they may naturally spend less time on YouTube.
In some ways, this is still an untapped market. That's why we should unite.
As for me, I create fairy-tale adaptations that aim to stay as faithful as possible to the original works of Giambattista Basile, Charles Perrault, and the Brothers Grimm.
My goal is to build a cinematic library of literary works.
I had only just been approved for YouTube monetization at the end of October, and then, on November 18, my monetization was removed.
If YouTube believed there was something wrong with my content from the beginning, why approve my channel for the YouTube Partner Program in the first place?
Later, I was told my content was repetitive.
But my Shorts are simply memorable scenes taken from my own original long-form films.
For example, the scene in Hansel and Gretel where the witch is pushed into the oven, or the magical transformation of Cinderella's pumpkin carriage.
These are exactly the kinds of attention-grabbing moments YouTube has always encouraged creators to use as hooks.
We're constantly told to put the most engaging moments at the beginning to capture viewers' attention.
Countless creators turn highlights from their long-form videos into Shorts.
And now we're being told that this is repetitive content?
YouTube is contradicting its own advice!
If you've experienced something similar, I encourage you to share your story too.
Let's start by bringing creators together here on X.
We shouldn't have to face this alone.
https://t.co/0KohZfzl9q
Let's follow and support one another, and help each other grow our long-form video channels on X!
Please also take a moment to read my post and the concerns I've raised. I hope we can work together, support each other, and stand up against YouTube's unfair treatment of creators.
Hello everyone.
I believe one of the main reasons many creators are moving to X is that YouTube has suddenly demonetized their channels without a clear explanation, leaving them with almost nowhere to turn when they try to appeal.
We shouldn't remain scattered, each of us complaining on our own. If we're willing to pay for X Premium and maintain our blue checkmarks, it means we still want to keep making videos and making our voices heard.
We're different from accounts that simply repost other people's content. Paying for X shows that we're serious creators who are willing to invest in our own work.
So I'd like to suggest a few things we can start doing together.
First, upload one of your older long-form videos every day. Our old videos are valuable assets. Reposting them also gives us an opportunity to share behind-the-scenes stories, explain our creative process, or add thoughts we didn't get to share before.
Second, tell people how YouTube treated you. Share your experiences, and include screenshots whenever possible. We can post about these experiences every day so more people understand that these aren't isolated incidents.
Third, follow and support one another. Watch each other's work. Building an audience and qualifying for long-form video monetization on X takes time, and supporting each other could help us establish another source of income here.
We need to organize if we want our voices to have real impact. If enough creators come together, perhaps we could even formally bring our concerns to Elon Musk's attention.
Right now, I believe X is probably the second-best platform for hosting long-form videos.
Facebook is another option, although without a paid membership barrier, content may be more vulnerable to unauthorized reposting. Still, it's worth trying.
There's also Kick, which currently focuses mainly on gaming and livestreaming. If its operators ever recognize this opportunity and welcome creators who produce narrative films, I believe it could gradually become another viable platform.
At the moment, I think X's biggest weakness is its relatively limited long-form video ecosystem.
Meanwhile, YouTube seems to be pushing away creators who genuinely invest their time and effort into producing long-form content.
This could be our opportunity to fill that gap and help expand long-form video content on X.
If we could eventually reach television audiences as well, we might finally stop being completely dependent on a single platform.
Many AI video creators have been demonetized for supposedly producing "repetitive content" or "template-based content."
But when the same person directs multiple films, of course there will be similarities in style!
You cannot expect emotionless AI systems to fairly judge works created with genuine human emotion.
Every creator has their own way of expressing feelings, and naturally, some patterns will appear across their work.
How can an AI system reliably determine whether those similarities make the content repetitive?
YouTube previously cut large numbers of employees, and now it seems to be relying on AI in ways that are causing chaos for smaller channels.
What makes this even worse is that demonetized channels can still upload videos, and their videos can still be watched with advertisements.
The creators receive nothing.
It feels like YouTube is deliberately encouraging people to work for free.
YouTube appears to want a subscription-driven business model similar to Netflix. On one hand, it encourages everyone to upload videos, opening the door to creative people beyond the traditional Hollywood industry.
On the other hand, its monetization decisions can leave those same creators providing content without compensation.
That's shameless.
To some extent, this reflects YouTube's dominance over long-form video. Platforms like TikTok, Xiaohongshu, and others simply don't have the same volume of long-form content.
Many demonetized creators have channels with tens of thousands or even hundreds of thousands of subscribers.
Yet it often feels as though YouTube only takes creators with more than a million subscribers seriously, while everyone else is treated as disposable.
YouTube knows it dominates long-form video, and that's exactly why we should support each other and help build a stronger long-form video community on X.
If people are willing to spend their time watching our work, then that work has value.
Viewers could also discover different kinds of content here.
And as people spend more time on X, they may naturally spend less time on YouTube.
In some ways, this is still an untapped market. That's why we should unite.
As for me, I create fairy-tale adaptations that aim to stay as faithful as possible to the original works of Giambattista Basile, Charles Perrault, and the Brothers Grimm.
My goal is to build a cinematic library of literary works.
I had only just been approved for YouTube monetization at the end of October, and then, on November 18, my monetization was removed.
If YouTube believed there was something wrong with my content from the beginning, why approve my channel for the YouTube Partner Program in the first place?
Later, I was told my content was repetitive.
But my Shorts are simply memorable scenes taken from my own original long-form films.
For example, the scene in Hansel and Gretel where the witch is pushed into the oven, or the magical transformation of Cinderella's pumpkin carriage.
These are exactly the kinds of attention-grabbing moments YouTube has always encouraged creators to use as hooks.
We're constantly told to put the most engaging moments at the beginning to capture viewers' attention.
Countless creators turn highlights from their long-form videos into Shorts.
And now we're being told that this is repetitive content?
YouTube is contradicting its own advice!
If you've experienced something similar, I encourage you to share your story too.
Let's start by bringing creators together here on X.
We shouldn't have to face this alone.
https://t.co/0KohZfzl9q
Let's follow and support one another, and help each other grow our long-form video channels on X!
Please also take a moment to read my post and the concerns I've raised. I hope we can work together, support each other, and stand up against YouTube's unfair treatment of creators.
Hello everyone.
I believe one of the main reasons many creators are moving to X is that YouTube has suddenly demonetized their channels without a clear explanation, leaving them with almost nowhere to turn when they try to appeal.
We shouldn't remain scattered, each of us complaining on our own. If we're willing to pay for X Premium and maintain our blue checkmarks, it means we still want to keep making videos and making our voices heard.
We're different from accounts that simply repost other people's content. Paying for X shows that we're serious creators who are willing to invest in our own work.
So I'd like to suggest a few things we can start doing together.
First, upload one of your older long-form videos every day. Our old videos are valuable assets. Reposting them also gives us an opportunity to share behind-the-scenes stories, explain our creative process, or add thoughts we didn't get to share before.
Second, tell people how YouTube treated you. Share your experiences, and include screenshots whenever possible. We can post about these experiences every day so more people understand that these aren't isolated incidents.
Third, follow and support one another. Watch each other's work. Building an audience and qualifying for long-form video monetization on X takes time, and supporting each other could help us establish another source of income here.
We need to organize if we want our voices to have real impact. If enough creators come together, perhaps we could even formally bring our concerns to Elon Musk's attention.
Right now, I believe X is probably the second-best platform for hosting long-form videos.
Facebook is another option, although without a paid membership barrier, content may be more vulnerable to unauthorized reposting. Still, it's worth trying.
There's also Kick, which currently focuses mainly on gaming and livestreaming. If its operators ever recognize this opportunity and welcome creators who produce narrative films, I believe it could gradually become another viable platform.
At the moment, I think X's biggest weakness is its relatively limited long-form video ecosystem.
Meanwhile, YouTube seems to be pushing away creators who genuinely invest their time and effort into producing long-form content.
This could be our opportunity to fill that gap and help expand long-form video content on X.
If we could eventually reach television audiences as well, we might finally stop being completely dependent on a single platform.
Many AI video creators have been demonetized for supposedly producing "repetitive content" or "template-based content."
But when the same person directs multiple films, of course there will be similarities in style!
You cannot expect emotionless AI systems to fairly judge works created with genuine human emotion.
Every creator has their own way of expressing feelings, and naturally, some patterns will appear across their work.
How can an AI system reliably determine whether those similarities make the content repetitive?
YouTube previously cut large numbers of employees, and now it seems to be relying on AI in ways that are causing chaos for smaller channels.
What makes this even worse is that demonetized channels can still upload videos, and their videos can still be watched with advertisements.
The creators receive nothing.
It feels like YouTube is deliberately encouraging people to work for free.
YouTube appears to want a subscription-driven business model similar to Netflix. On one hand, it encourages everyone to upload videos, opening the door to creative people beyond the traditional Hollywood industry.
On the other hand, its monetization decisions can leave those same creators providing content without compensation.
That's shameless.
To some extent, this reflects YouTube's dominance over long-form video. Platforms like TikTok, Xiaohongshu, and others simply don't have the same volume of long-form content.
Many demonetized creators have channels with tens of thousands or even hundreds of thousands of subscribers.
Yet it often feels as though YouTube only takes creators with more than a million subscribers seriously, while everyone else is treated as disposable.
YouTube knows it dominates long-form video, and that's exactly why we should support each other and help build a stronger long-form video community on X.
If people are willing to spend their time watching our work, then that work has value.
Viewers could also discover different kinds of content here.
And as people spend more time on X, they may naturally spend less time on YouTube.
In some ways, this is still an untapped market. That's why we should unite.
As for me, I create fairy-tale adaptations that aim to stay as faithful as possible to the original works of Giambattista Basile, Charles Perrault, and the Brothers Grimm.
My goal is to build a cinematic library of literary works.
I had only just been approved for YouTube monetization at the end of October, and then, on November 18, my monetization was removed.
If YouTube believed there was something wrong with my content from the beginning, why approve my channel for the YouTube Partner Program in the first place?
Later, I was told my content was repetitive.
But my Shorts are simply memorable scenes taken from my own original long-form films.
For example, the scene in Hansel and Gretel where the witch is pushed into the oven, or the magical transformation of Cinderella's pumpkin carriage.
These are exactly the kinds of attention-grabbing moments YouTube has always encouraged creators to use as hooks.
We're constantly told to put the most engaging moments at the beginning to capture viewers' attention.
Countless creators turn highlights from their long-form videos into Shorts.
And now we're being told that this is repetitive content?
YouTube is contradicting its own advice!
If you've experienced something similar, I encourage you to share your story too.
Let's start by bringing creators together here on X.
We shouldn't have to face this alone.
https://t.co/0KohZfzl9q
Let's follow and support one another, and help each other grow our long-form video channels on X!
Please also take a moment to read my post and the concerns I've raised. I hope we can work together, support each other, and stand up against YouTube's unfair treatment of creators.
Hello everyone.
I believe one of the main reasons many creators are moving to X is that YouTube has suddenly demonetized their channels without a clear explanation, leaving them with almost nowhere to turn when they try to appeal.
We shouldn't remain scattered, each of us complaining on our own. If we're willing to pay for X Premium and maintain our blue checkmarks, it means we still want to keep making videos and making our voices heard.
We're different from accounts that simply repost other people's content. Paying for X shows that we're serious creators who are willing to invest in our own work.
So I'd like to suggest a few things we can start doing together.
First, upload one of your older long-form videos every day. Our old videos are valuable assets. Reposting them also gives us an opportunity to share behind-the-scenes stories, explain our creative process, or add thoughts we didn't get to share before.
Second, tell people how YouTube treated you. Share your experiences, and include screenshots whenever possible. We can post about these experiences every day so more people understand that these aren't isolated incidents.
Third, follow and support one another. Watch each other's work. Building an audience and qualifying for long-form video monetization on X takes time, and supporting each other could help us establish another source of income here.
We need to organize if we want our voices to have real impact. If enough creators come together, perhaps we could even formally bring our concerns to Elon Musk's attention.
Right now, I believe X is probably the second-best platform for hosting long-form videos.
Facebook is another option, although without a paid membership barrier, content may be more vulnerable to unauthorized reposting. Still, it's worth trying.
There's also Kick, which currently focuses mainly on gaming and livestreaming. If its operators ever recognize this opportunity and welcome creators who produce narrative films, I believe it could gradually become another viable platform.
At the moment, I think X's biggest weakness is its relatively limited long-form video ecosystem.
Meanwhile, YouTube seems to be pushing away creators who genuinely invest their time and effort into producing long-form content.
This could be our opportunity to fill that gap and help expand long-form video content on X.
If we could eventually reach television audiences as well, we might finally stop being completely dependent on a single platform.
Many AI video creators have been demonetized for supposedly producing "repetitive content" or "template-based content."
But when the same person directs multiple films, of course there will be similarities in style!
You cannot expect emotionless AI systems to fairly judge works created with genuine human emotion.
Every creator has their own way of expressing feelings, and naturally, some patterns will appear across their work.
How can an AI system reliably determine whether those similarities make the content repetitive?
YouTube previously cut large numbers of employees, and now it seems to be relying on AI in ways that are causing chaos for smaller channels.
What makes this even worse is that demonetized channels can still upload videos, and their videos can still be watched with advertisements.
The creators receive nothing.
It feels like YouTube is deliberately encouraging people to work for free.
YouTube appears to want a subscription-driven business model similar to Netflix. On one hand, it encourages everyone to upload videos, opening the door to creative people beyond the traditional Hollywood industry.
On the other hand, its monetization decisions can leave those same creators providing content without compensation.
That's shameless.
To some extent, this reflects YouTube's dominance over long-form video. Platforms like TikTok, Xiaohongshu, and others simply don't have the same volume of long-form content.
Many demonetized creators have channels with tens of thousands or even hundreds of thousands of subscribers.
Yet it often feels as though YouTube only takes creators with more than a million subscribers seriously, while everyone else is treated as disposable.
YouTube knows it dominates long-form video, and that's exactly why we should support each other and help build a stronger long-form video community on X.
If people are willing to spend their time watching our work, then that work has value.
Viewers could also discover different kinds of content here.
And as people spend more time on X, they may naturally spend less time on YouTube.
In some ways, this is still an untapped market. That's why we should unite.
As for me, I create fairy-tale adaptations that aim to stay as faithful as possible to the original works of Giambattista Basile, Charles Perrault, and the Brothers Grimm.
My goal is to build a cinematic library of literary works.
I had only just been approved for YouTube monetization at the end of October, and then, on November 18, my monetization was removed.
If YouTube believed there was something wrong with my content from the beginning, why approve my channel for the YouTube Partner Program in the first place?
Later, I was told my content was repetitive.
But my Shorts are simply memorable scenes taken from my own original long-form films.
For example, the scene in Hansel and Gretel where the witch is pushed into the oven, or the magical transformation of Cinderella's pumpkin carriage.
These are exactly the kinds of attention-grabbing moments YouTube has always encouraged creators to use as hooks.
We're constantly told to put the most engaging moments at the beginning to capture viewers' attention.
Countless creators turn highlights from their long-form videos into Shorts.
And now we're being told that this is repetitive content?
YouTube is contradicting its own advice!
If you've experienced something similar, I encourage you to share your story too.
Let's start by bringing creators together here on X.
We shouldn't have to face this alone.
https://t.co/0KohZfzl9q
Let's follow and support one another, and help each other grow our long-form video channels on X!
Please also take a moment to read my post and the concerns I've raised. I hope we can work together, support each other, and stand up against YouTube's unfair treatment of creators.
Hello everyone.
I believe one of the main reasons many creators are moving to X is that YouTube has suddenly demonetized their channels without a clear explanation, leaving them with almost nowhere to turn when they try to appeal.
We shouldn't remain scattered, each of us complaining on our own. If we're willing to pay for X Premium and maintain our blue checkmarks, it means we still want to keep making videos and making our voices heard.
We're different from accounts that simply repost other people's content. Paying for X shows that we're serious creators who are willing to invest in our own work.
So I'd like to suggest a few things we can start doing together.
First, upload one of your older long-form videos every day. Our old videos are valuable assets. Reposting them also gives us an opportunity to share behind-the-scenes stories, explain our creative process, or add thoughts we didn't get to share before.
Second, tell people how YouTube treated you. Share your experiences, and include screenshots whenever possible. We can post about these experiences every day so more people understand that these aren't isolated incidents.
Third, follow and support one another. Watch each other's work. Building an audience and qualifying for long-form video monetization on X takes time, and supporting each other could help us establish another source of income here.
We need to organize if we want our voices to have real impact. If enough creators come together, perhaps we could even formally bring our concerns to Elon Musk's attention.
Right now, I believe X is probably the second-best platform for hosting long-form videos.
Facebook is another option, although without a paid membership barrier, content may be more vulnerable to unauthorized reposting. Still, it's worth trying.
There's also Kick, which currently focuses mainly on gaming and livestreaming. If its operators ever recognize this opportunity and welcome creators who produce narrative films, I believe it could gradually become another viable platform.
At the moment, I think X's biggest weakness is its relatively limited long-form video ecosystem.
Meanwhile, YouTube seems to be pushing away creators who genuinely invest their time and effort into producing long-form content.
This could be our opportunity to fill that gap and help expand long-form video content on X.
If we could eventually reach television audiences as well, we might finally stop being completely dependent on a single platform.
Many AI video creators have been demonetized for supposedly producing "repetitive content" or "template-based content."
But when the same person directs multiple films, of course there will be similarities in style!
You cannot expect emotionless AI systems to fairly judge works created with genuine human emotion.
Every creator has their own way of expressing feelings, and naturally, some patterns will appear across their work.
How can an AI system reliably determine whether those similarities make the content repetitive?
YouTube previously cut large numbers of employees, and now it seems to be relying on AI in ways that are causing chaos for smaller channels.
What makes this even worse is that demonetized channels can still upload videos, and their videos can still be watched with advertisements.
The creators receive nothing.
It feels like YouTube is deliberately encouraging people to work for free.
YouTube appears to want a subscription-driven business model similar to Netflix. On one hand, it encourages everyone to upload videos, opening the door to creative people beyond the traditional Hollywood industry.
On the other hand, its monetization decisions can leave those same creators providing content without compensation.
That's shameless.
To some extent, this reflects YouTube's dominance over long-form video. Platforms like TikTok, Xiaohongshu, and others simply don't have the same volume of long-form content.
Many demonetized creators have channels with tens of thousands or even hundreds of thousands of subscribers.
Yet it often feels as though YouTube only takes creators with more than a million subscribers seriously, while everyone else is treated as disposable.
YouTube knows it dominates long-form video, and that's exactly why we should support each other and help build a stronger long-form video community on X.
If people are willing to spend their time watching our work, then that work has value.
Viewers could also discover different kinds of content here.
And as people spend more time on X, they may naturally spend less time on YouTube.
In some ways, this is still an untapped market. That's why we should unite.
As for me, I create fairy-tale adaptations that aim to stay as faithful as possible to the original works of Giambattista Basile, Charles Perrault, and the Brothers Grimm.
My goal is to build a cinematic library of literary works.
I had only just been approved for YouTube monetization at the end of October, and then, on November 18, my monetization was removed.
If YouTube believed there was something wrong with my content from the beginning, why approve my channel for the YouTube Partner Program in the first place?
Later, I was told my content was repetitive.
But my Shorts are simply memorable scenes taken from my own original long-form films.
For example, the scene in Hansel and Gretel where the witch is pushed into the oven, or the magical transformation of Cinderella's pumpkin carriage.
These are exactly the kinds of attention-grabbing moments YouTube has always encouraged creators to use as hooks.
We're constantly told to put the most engaging moments at the beginning to capture viewers' attention.
Countless creators turn highlights from their long-form videos into Shorts.
And now we're being told that this is repetitive content?
YouTube is contradicting its own advice!
If you've experienced something similar, I encourage you to share your story too.
Let's start by bringing creators together here on X.
We shouldn't have to face this alone.
https://t.co/0KohZfzl9q
Let's follow and support one another, and help each other grow our long-form video channels on X!
Please also take a moment to read my post and the concerns I've raised. I hope we can work together, support each other, and stand up against YouTube's unfair treatment of creators.
Hello everyone.
I believe one of the main reasons many creators are moving to X is that YouTube has suddenly demonetized their channels without a clear explanation, leaving them with almost nowhere to turn when they try to appeal.
We shouldn't remain scattered, each of us complaining on our own. If we're willing to pay for X Premium and maintain our blue checkmarks, it means we still want to keep making videos and making our voices heard.
We're different from accounts that simply repost other people's content. Paying for X shows that we're serious creators who are willing to invest in our own work.
So I'd like to suggest a few things we can start doing together.
First, upload one of your older long-form videos every day. Our old videos are valuable assets. Reposting them also gives us an opportunity to share behind-the-scenes stories, explain our creative process, or add thoughts we didn't get to share before.
Second, tell people how YouTube treated you. Share your experiences, and include screenshots whenever possible. We can post about these experiences every day so more people understand that these aren't isolated incidents.
Third, follow and support one another. Watch each other's work. Building an audience and qualifying for long-form video monetization on X takes time, and supporting each other could help us establish another source of income here.
We need to organize if we want our voices to have real impact. If enough creators come together, perhaps we could even formally bring our concerns to Elon Musk's attention.
Right now, I believe X is probably the second-best platform for hosting long-form videos.
Facebook is another option, although without a paid membership barrier, content may be more vulnerable to unauthorized reposting. Still, it's worth trying.
There's also Kick, which currently focuses mainly on gaming and livestreaming. If its operators ever recognize this opportunity and welcome creators who produce narrative films, I believe it could gradually become another viable platform.
At the moment, I think X's biggest weakness is its relatively limited long-form video ecosystem.
Meanwhile, YouTube seems to be pushing away creators who genuinely invest their time and effort into producing long-form content.
This could be our opportunity to fill that gap and help expand long-form video content on X.
If we could eventually reach television audiences as well, we might finally stop being completely dependent on a single platform.
Many AI video creators have been demonetized for supposedly producing "repetitive content" or "template-based content."
But when the same person directs multiple films, of course there will be similarities in style!
You cannot expect emotionless AI systems to fairly judge works created with genuine human emotion.
Every creator has their own way of expressing feelings, and naturally, some patterns will appear across their work.
How can an AI system reliably determine whether those similarities make the content repetitive?
YouTube previously cut large numbers of employees, and now it seems to be relying on AI in ways that are causing chaos for smaller channels.
What makes this even worse is that demonetized channels can still upload videos, and their videos can still be watched with advertisements.
The creators receive nothing.
It feels like YouTube is deliberately encouraging people to work for free.
YouTube appears to want a subscription-driven business model similar to Netflix. On one hand, it encourages everyone to upload videos, opening the door to creative people beyond the traditional Hollywood industry.
On the other hand, its monetization decisions can leave those same creators providing content without compensation.
That's shameless.
To some extent, this reflects YouTube's dominance over long-form video. Platforms like TikTok, Xiaohongshu, and others simply don't have the same volume of long-form content.
Many demonetized creators have channels with tens of thousands or even hundreds of thousands of subscribers.
Yet it often feels as though YouTube only takes creators with more than a million subscribers seriously, while everyone else is treated as disposable.
YouTube knows it dominates long-form video, and that's exactly why we should support each other and help build a stronger long-form video community on X.
If people are willing to spend their time watching our work, then that work has value.
Viewers could also discover different kinds of content here.
And as people spend more time on X, they may naturally spend less time on YouTube.
In some ways, this is still an untapped market. That's why we should unite.
As for me, I create fairy-tale adaptations that aim to stay as faithful as possible to the original works of Giambattista Basile, Charles Perrault, and the Brothers Grimm.
My goal is to build a cinematic library of literary works.
I had only just been approved for YouTube monetization at the end of October, and then, on November 18, my monetization was removed.
If YouTube believed there was something wrong with my content from the beginning, why approve my channel for the YouTube Partner Program in the first place?
Later, I was told my content was repetitive.
But my Shorts are simply memorable scenes taken from my own original long-form films.
For example, the scene in Hansel and Gretel where the witch is pushed into the oven, or the magical transformation of Cinderella's pumpkin carriage.
These are exactly the kinds of attention-grabbing moments YouTube has always encouraged creators to use as hooks.
We're constantly told to put the most engaging moments at the beginning to capture viewers' attention.
Countless creators turn highlights from their long-form videos into Shorts.
And now we're being told that this is repetitive content?
YouTube is contradicting its own advice!
If you've experienced something similar, I encourage you to share your story too.
Let's start by bringing creators together here on X.
We shouldn't have to face this alone.
https://t.co/0KohZfzl9q
Let's follow and support one another, and help each other grow our long-form video channels on X!
Please also take a moment to read my post and the concerns I've raised. I hope we can work together, support each other, and stand up against YouTube's unfair treatment of creators.
Hello everyone.
I believe one of the main reasons many creators are moving to X is that YouTube has suddenly demonetized their channels without a clear explanation, leaving them with almost nowhere to turn when they try to appeal.
We shouldn't remain scattered, each of us complaining on our own. If we're willing to pay for X Premium and maintain our blue checkmarks, it means we still want to keep making videos and making our voices heard.
We're different from accounts that simply repost other people's content. Paying for X shows that we're serious creators who are willing to invest in our own work.
So I'd like to suggest a few things we can start doing together.
First, upload one of your older long-form videos every day. Our old videos are valuable assets. Reposting them also gives us an opportunity to share behind-the-scenes stories, explain our creative process, or add thoughts we didn't get to share before.
Second, tell people how YouTube treated you. Share your experiences, and include screenshots whenever possible. We can post about these experiences every day so more people understand that these aren't isolated incidents.
Third, follow and support one another. Watch each other's work. Building an audience and qualifying for long-form video monetization on X takes time, and supporting each other could help us establish another source of income here.
We need to organize if we want our voices to have real impact. If enough creators come together, perhaps we could even formally bring our concerns to Elon Musk's attention.
Right now, I believe X is probably the second-best platform for hosting long-form videos.
Facebook is another option, although without a paid membership barrier, content may be more vulnerable to unauthorized reposting. Still, it's worth trying.
There's also Kick, which currently focuses mainly on gaming and livestreaming. If its operators ever recognize this opportunity and welcome creators who produce narrative films, I believe it could gradually become another viable platform.
At the moment, I think X's biggest weakness is its relatively limited long-form video ecosystem.
Meanwhile, YouTube seems to be pushing away creators who genuinely invest their time and effort into producing long-form content.
This could be our opportunity to fill that gap and help expand long-form video content on X.
If we could eventually reach television audiences as well, we might finally stop being completely dependent on a single platform.
Many AI video creators have been demonetized for supposedly producing "repetitive content" or "template-based content."
But when the same person directs multiple films, of course there will be similarities in style!
You cannot expect emotionless AI systems to fairly judge works created with genuine human emotion.
Every creator has their own way of expressing feelings, and naturally, some patterns will appear across their work.
How can an AI system reliably determine whether those similarities make the content repetitive?
YouTube previously cut large numbers of employees, and now it seems to be relying on AI in ways that are causing chaos for smaller channels.
What makes this even worse is that demonetized channels can still upload videos, and their videos can still be watched with advertisements.
The creators receive nothing.
It feels like YouTube is deliberately encouraging people to work for free.
YouTube appears to want a subscription-driven business model similar to Netflix. On one hand, it encourages everyone to upload videos, opening the door to creative people beyond the traditional Hollywood industry.
On the other hand, its monetization decisions can leave those same creators providing content without compensation.
That's shameless.
To some extent, this reflects YouTube's dominance over long-form video. Platforms like TikTok, Xiaohongshu, and others simply don't have the same volume of long-form content.
Many demonetized creators have channels with tens of thousands or even hundreds of thousands of subscribers.
Yet it often feels as though YouTube only takes creators with more than a million subscribers seriously, while everyone else is treated as disposable.
YouTube knows it dominates long-form video, and that's exactly why we should support each other and help build a stronger long-form video community on X.
If people are willing to spend their time watching our work, then that work has value.
Viewers could also discover different kinds of content here.
And as people spend more time on X, they may naturally spend less time on YouTube.
In some ways, this is still an untapped market. That's why we should unite.
As for me, I create fairy-tale adaptations that aim to stay as faithful as possible to the original works of Giambattista Basile, Charles Perrault, and the Brothers Grimm.
My goal is to build a cinematic library of literary works.
I had only just been approved for YouTube monetization at the end of October, and then, on November 18, my monetization was removed.
If YouTube believed there was something wrong with my content from the beginning, why approve my channel for the YouTube Partner Program in the first place?
Later, I was told my content was repetitive.
But my Shorts are simply memorable scenes taken from my own original long-form films.
For example, the scene in Hansel and Gretel where the witch is pushed into the oven, or the magical transformation of Cinderella's pumpkin carriage.
These are exactly the kinds of attention-grabbing moments YouTube has always encouraged creators to use as hooks.
We're constantly told to put the most engaging moments at the beginning to capture viewers' attention.
Countless creators turn highlights from their long-form videos into Shorts.
And now we're being told that this is repetitive content?
YouTube is contradicting its own advice!
If you've experienced something similar, I encourage you to share your story too.
Let's start by bringing creators together here on X.
We shouldn't have to face this alone.
https://t.co/0KohZfzl9q
Let's follow and support one another, and help each other grow our long-form video channels on X!
Please also take a moment to read my post and the concerns I've raised. I hope we can work together, support each other, and stand up against YouTube's unfair treatment of creators.
Hello everyone.
I believe one of the main reasons many creators are moving to X is that YouTube has suddenly demonetized their channels without a clear explanation, leaving them with almost nowhere to turn when they try to appeal.
We shouldn't remain scattered, each of us complaining on our own. If we're willing to pay for X Premium and maintain our blue checkmarks, it means we still want to keep making videos and making our voices heard.
We're different from accounts that simply repost other people's content. Paying for X shows that we're serious creators who are willing to invest in our own work.
So I'd like to suggest a few things we can start doing together.
First, upload one of your older long-form videos every day. Our old videos are valuable assets. Reposting them also gives us an opportunity to share behind-the-scenes stories, explain our creative process, or add thoughts we didn't get to share before.
Second, tell people how YouTube treated you. Share your experiences, and include screenshots whenever possible. We can post about these experiences every day so more people understand that these aren't isolated incidents.
Third, follow and support one another. Watch each other's work. Building an audience and qualifying for long-form video monetization on X takes time, and supporting each other could help us establish another source of income here.
We need to organize if we want our voices to have real impact. If enough creators come together, perhaps we could even formally bring our concerns to Elon Musk's attention.
Right now, I believe X is probably the second-best platform for hosting long-form videos.
Facebook is another option, although without a paid membership barrier, content may be more vulnerable to unauthorized reposting. Still, it's worth trying.
There's also Kick, which currently focuses mainly on gaming and livestreaming. If its operators ever recognize this opportunity and welcome creators who produce narrative films, I believe it could gradually become another viable platform.
At the moment, I think X's biggest weakness is its relatively limited long-form video ecosystem.
Meanwhile, YouTube seems to be pushing away creators who genuinely invest their time and effort into producing long-form content.
This could be our opportunity to fill that gap and help expand long-form video content on X.
If we could eventually reach television audiences as well, we might finally stop being completely dependent on a single platform.
Many AI video creators have been demonetized for supposedly producing "repetitive content" or "template-based content."
But when the same person directs multiple films, of course there will be similarities in style!
You cannot expect emotionless AI systems to fairly judge works created with genuine human emotion.
Every creator has their own way of expressing feelings, and naturally, some patterns will appear across their work.
How can an AI system reliably determine whether those similarities make the content repetitive?
YouTube previously cut large numbers of employees, and now it seems to be relying on AI in ways that are causing chaos for smaller channels.
What makes this even worse is that demonetized channels can still upload videos, and their videos can still be watched with advertisements.
The creators receive nothing.
It feels like YouTube is deliberately encouraging people to work for free.
YouTube appears to want a subscription-driven business model similar to Netflix. On one hand, it encourages everyone to upload videos, opening the door to creative people beyond the traditional Hollywood industry.
On the other hand, its monetization decisions can leave those same creators providing content without compensation.
That's shameless.
To some extent, this reflects YouTube's dominance over long-form video. Platforms like TikTok, Xiaohongshu, and others simply don't have the same volume of long-form content.
Many demonetized creators have channels with tens of thousands or even hundreds of thousands of subscribers.
Yet it often feels as though YouTube only takes creators with more than a million subscribers seriously, while everyone else is treated as disposable.
YouTube knows it dominates long-form video, and that's exactly why we should support each other and help build a stronger long-form video community on X.
If people are willing to spend their time watching our work, then that work has value.
Viewers could also discover different kinds of content here.
And as people spend more time on X, they may naturally spend less time on YouTube.
In some ways, this is still an untapped market. That's why we should unite.
As for me, I create fairy-tale adaptations that aim to stay as faithful as possible to the original works of Giambattista Basile, Charles Perrault, and the Brothers Grimm.
My goal is to build a cinematic library of literary works.
I had only just been approved for YouTube monetization at the end of October, and then, on November 18, my monetization was removed.
If YouTube believed there was something wrong with my content from the beginning, why approve my channel for the YouTube Partner Program in the first place?
Later, I was told my content was repetitive.
But my Shorts are simply memorable scenes taken from my own original long-form films.
For example, the scene in Hansel and Gretel where the witch is pushed into the oven, or the magical transformation of Cinderella's pumpkin carriage.
These are exactly the kinds of attention-grabbing moments YouTube has always encouraged creators to use as hooks.
We're constantly told to put the most engaging moments at the beginning to capture viewers' attention.
Countless creators turn highlights from their long-form videos into Shorts.
And now we're being told that this is repetitive content?
YouTube is contradicting its own advice!
If you've experienced something similar, I encourage you to share your story too.
Let's start by bringing creators together here on X.
We shouldn't have to face this alone.
https://t.co/0KohZfzl9q
Let's follow and support one another, and help each other grow our long-form video channels on X!
Please also take a moment to read my post and the concerns I've raised. I hope we can work together, support each other, and stand up against YouTube's unfair treatment of creators.
Hello everyone.
I believe one of the main reasons many creators are moving to X is that YouTube has suddenly demonetized their channels without a clear explanation, leaving them with almost nowhere to turn when they try to appeal.
We shouldn't remain scattered, each of us complaining on our own. If we're willing to pay for X Premium and maintain our blue checkmarks, it means we still want to keep making videos and making our voices heard.
We're different from accounts that simply repost other people's content. Paying for X shows that we're serious creators who are willing to invest in our own work.
So I'd like to suggest a few things we can start doing together.
First, upload one of your older long-form videos every day. Our old videos are valuable assets. Reposting them also gives us an opportunity to share behind-the-scenes stories, explain our creative process, or add thoughts we didn't get to share before.
Second, tell people how YouTube treated you. Share your experiences, and include screenshots whenever possible. We can post about these experiences every day so more people understand that these aren't isolated incidents.
Third, follow and support one another. Watch each other's work. Building an audience and qualifying for long-form video monetization on X takes time, and supporting each other could help us establish another source of income here.
We need to organize if we want our voices to have real impact. If enough creators come together, perhaps we could even formally bring our concerns to Elon Musk's attention.
Right now, I believe X is probably the second-best platform for hosting long-form videos.
Facebook is another option, although without a paid membership barrier, content may be more vulnerable to unauthorized reposting. Still, it's worth trying.
There's also Kick, which currently focuses mainly on gaming and livestreaming. If its operators ever recognize this opportunity and welcome creators who produce narrative films, I believe it could gradually become another viable platform.
At the moment, I think X's biggest weakness is its relatively limited long-form video ecosystem.
Meanwhile, YouTube seems to be pushing away creators who genuinely invest their time and effort into producing long-form content.
This could be our opportunity to fill that gap and help expand long-form video content on X.
If we could eventually reach television audiences as well, we might finally stop being completely dependent on a single platform.
Many AI video creators have been demonetized for supposedly producing "repetitive content" or "template-based content."
But when the same person directs multiple films, of course there will be similarities in style!
You cannot expect emotionless AI systems to fairly judge works created with genuine human emotion.
Every creator has their own way of expressing feelings, and naturally, some patterns will appear across their work.
How can an AI system reliably determine whether those similarities make the content repetitive?
YouTube previously cut large numbers of employees, and now it seems to be relying on AI in ways that are causing chaos for smaller channels.
What makes this even worse is that demonetized channels can still upload videos, and their videos can still be watched with advertisements.
The creators receive nothing.
It feels like YouTube is deliberately encouraging people to work for free.
YouTube appears to want a subscription-driven business model similar to Netflix. On one hand, it encourages everyone to upload videos, opening the door to creative people beyond the traditional Hollywood industry.
On the other hand, its monetization decisions can leave those same creators providing content without compensation.
That's shameless.
To some extent, this reflects YouTube's dominance over long-form video. Platforms like TikTok, Xiaohongshu, and others simply don't have the same volume of long-form content.
Many demonetized creators have channels with tens of thousands or even hundreds of thousands of subscribers.
Yet it often feels as though YouTube only takes creators with more than a million subscribers seriously, while everyone else is treated as disposable.
YouTube knows it dominates long-form video, and that's exactly why we should support each other and help build a stronger long-form video community on X.
If people are willing to spend their time watching our work, then that work has value.
Viewers could also discover different kinds of content here.
And as people spend more time on X, they may naturally spend less time on YouTube.
In some ways, this is still an untapped market. That's why we should unite.
As for me, I create fairy-tale adaptations that aim to stay as faithful as possible to the original works of Giambattista Basile, Charles Perrault, and the Brothers Grimm.
My goal is to build a cinematic library of literary works.
I had only just been approved for YouTube monetization at the end of October, and then, on November 18, my monetization was removed.
If YouTube believed there was something wrong with my content from the beginning, why approve my channel for the YouTube Partner Program in the first place?
Later, I was told my content was repetitive.
But my Shorts are simply memorable scenes taken from my own original long-form films.
For example, the scene in Hansel and Gretel where the witch is pushed into the oven, or the magical transformation of Cinderella's pumpkin carriage.
These are exactly the kinds of attention-grabbing moments YouTube has always encouraged creators to use as hooks.
We're constantly told to put the most engaging moments at the beginning to capture viewers' attention.
Countless creators turn highlights from their long-form videos into Shorts.
And now we're being told that this is repetitive content?
YouTube is contradicting its own advice!
If you've experienced something similar, I encourage you to share your story too.
Let's start by bringing creators together here on X.
We shouldn't have to face this alone.
https://t.co/0KohZfzl9q
Let's follow and support one another, and help each other grow our long-form video channels on X!
Please also take a moment to read my post and the concerns I've raised. I hope we can work together, support each other, and stand up against YouTube's unfair treatment of creators.
Hello everyone.
I believe one of the main reasons many creators are moving to X is that YouTube has suddenly demonetized their channels without a clear explanation, leaving them with almost nowhere to turn when they try to appeal.
We shouldn't remain scattered, each of us complaining on our own. If we're willing to pay for X Premium and maintain our blue checkmarks, it means we still want to keep making videos and making our voices heard.
We're different from accounts that simply repost other people's content. Paying for X shows that we're serious creators who are willing to invest in our own work.
So I'd like to suggest a few things we can start doing together.
First, upload one of your older long-form videos every day. Our old videos are valuable assets. Reposting them also gives us an opportunity to share behind-the-scenes stories, explain our creative process, or add thoughts we didn't get to share before.
Second, tell people how YouTube treated you. Share your experiences, and include screenshots whenever possible. We can post about these experiences every day so more people understand that these aren't isolated incidents.
Third, follow and support one another. Watch each other's work. Building an audience and qualifying for long-form video monetization on X takes time, and supporting each other could help us establish another source of income here.
We need to organize if we want our voices to have real impact. If enough creators come together, perhaps we could even formally bring our concerns to Elon Musk's attention.
Right now, I believe X is probably the second-best platform for hosting long-form videos.
Facebook is another option, although without a paid membership barrier, content may be more vulnerable to unauthorized reposting. Still, it's worth trying.
There's also Kick, which currently focuses mainly on gaming and livestreaming. If its operators ever recognize this opportunity and welcome creators who produce narrative films, I believe it could gradually become another viable platform.
At the moment, I think X's biggest weakness is its relatively limited long-form video ecosystem.
Meanwhile, YouTube seems to be pushing away creators who genuinely invest their time and effort into producing long-form content.
This could be our opportunity to fill that gap and help expand long-form video content on X.
If we could eventually reach television audiences as well, we might finally stop being completely dependent on a single platform.
Many AI video creators have been demonetized for supposedly producing "repetitive content" or "template-based content."
But when the same person directs multiple films, of course there will be similarities in style!
You cannot expect emotionless AI systems to fairly judge works created with genuine human emotion.
Every creator has their own way of expressing feelings, and naturally, some patterns will appear across their work.
How can an AI system reliably determine whether those similarities make the content repetitive?
YouTube previously cut large numbers of employees, and now it seems to be relying on AI in ways that are causing chaos for smaller channels.
What makes this even worse is that demonetized channels can still upload videos, and their videos can still be watched with advertisements.
The creators receive nothing.
It feels like YouTube is deliberately encouraging people to work for free.
YouTube appears to want a subscription-driven business model similar to Netflix. On one hand, it encourages everyone to upload videos, opening the door to creative people beyond the traditional Hollywood industry.
On the other hand, its monetization decisions can leave those same creators providing content without compensation.
That's shameless.
To some extent, this reflects YouTube's dominance over long-form video. Platforms like TikTok, Xiaohongshu, and others simply don't have the same volume of long-form content.
Many demonetized creators have channels with tens of thousands or even hundreds of thousands of subscribers.
Yet it often feels as though YouTube only takes creators with more than a million subscribers seriously, while everyone else is treated as disposable.
YouTube knows it dominates long-form video, and that's exactly why we should support each other and help build a stronger long-form video community on X.
If people are willing to spend their time watching our work, then that work has value.
Viewers could also discover different kinds of content here.
And as people spend more time on X, they may naturally spend less time on YouTube.
In some ways, this is still an untapped market. That's why we should unite.
As for me, I create fairy-tale adaptations that aim to stay as faithful as possible to the original works of Giambattista Basile, Charles Perrault, and the Brothers Grimm.
My goal is to build a cinematic library of literary works.
I had only just been approved for YouTube monetization at the end of October, and then, on November 18, my monetization was removed.
If YouTube believed there was something wrong with my content from the beginning, why approve my channel for the YouTube Partner Program in the first place?
Later, I was told my content was repetitive.
But my Shorts are simply memorable scenes taken from my own original long-form films.
For example, the scene in Hansel and Gretel where the witch is pushed into the oven, or the magical transformation of Cinderella's pumpkin carriage.
These are exactly the kinds of attention-grabbing moments YouTube has always encouraged creators to use as hooks.
We're constantly told to put the most engaging moments at the beginning to capture viewers' attention.
Countless creators turn highlights from their long-form videos into Shorts.
And now we're being told that this is repetitive content?
YouTube is contradicting its own advice!
If you've experienced something similar, I encourage you to share your story too.
Let's start by bringing creators together here on X.
We shouldn't have to face this alone.
https://t.co/0KohZfyNjS
Let's follow and support one another, and help each other grow our long-form video channels on X!
Please also take a moment to read my post and the concerns I've raised. I hope we can work together, support each other, and stand up against YouTube's unfair treatment of creators.
Hello everyone.
I believe one of the main reasons many creators are moving to X is that YouTube has suddenly demonetized their channels without a clear explanation, leaving them with almost nowhere to turn when they try to appeal.
We shouldn't remain scattered, each of us complaining on our own. If we're willing to pay for X Premium and maintain our blue checkmarks, it means we still want to keep making videos and making our voices heard.
We're different from accounts that simply repost other people's content. Paying for X shows that we're serious creators who are willing to invest in our own work.
So I'd like to suggest a few things we can start doing together.
First, upload one of your older long-form videos every day. Our old videos are valuable assets. Reposting them also gives us an opportunity to share behind-the-scenes stories, explain our creative process, or add thoughts we didn't get to share before.
Second, tell people how YouTube treated you. Share your experiences, and include screenshots whenever possible. We can post about these experiences every day so more people understand that these aren't isolated incidents.
Third, follow and support one another. Watch each other's work. Building an audience and qualifying for long-form video monetization on X takes time, and supporting each other could help us establish another source of income here.
We need to organize if we want our voices to have real impact. If enough creators come together, perhaps we could even formally bring our concerns to Elon Musk's attention.
Right now, I believe X is probably the second-best platform for hosting long-form videos.
Facebook is another option, although without a paid membership barrier, content may be more vulnerable to unauthorized reposting. Still, it's worth trying.
There's also Kick, which currently focuses mainly on gaming and livestreaming. If its operators ever recognize this opportunity and welcome creators who produce narrative films, I believe it could gradually become another viable platform.
At the moment, I think X's biggest weakness is its relatively limited long-form video ecosystem.
Meanwhile, YouTube seems to be pushing away creators who genuinely invest their time and effort into producing long-form content.
This could be our opportunity to fill that gap and help expand long-form video content on X.
If we could eventually reach television audiences as well, we might finally stop being completely dependent on a single platform.
Many AI video creators have been demonetized for supposedly producing "repetitive content" or "template-based content."
But when the same person directs multiple films, of course there will be similarities in style!
You cannot expect emotionless AI systems to fairly judge works created with genuine human emotion.
Every creator has their own way of expressing feelings, and naturally, some patterns will appear across their work.
How can an AI system reliably determine whether those similarities make the content repetitive?
YouTube previously cut large numbers of employees, and now it seems to be relying on AI in ways that are causing chaos for smaller channels.
What makes this even worse is that demonetized channels can still upload videos, and their videos can still be watched with advertisements.
The creators receive nothing.
It feels like YouTube is deliberately encouraging people to work for free.
YouTube appears to want a subscription-driven business model similar to Netflix. On one hand, it encourages everyone to upload videos, opening the door to creative people beyond the traditional Hollywood industry.
On the other hand, its monetization decisions can leave those same creators providing content without compensation.
That's shameless.
To some extent, this reflects YouTube's dominance over long-form video. Platforms like TikTok, Xiaohongshu, and others simply don't have the same volume of long-form content.
Many demonetized creators have channels with tens of thousands or even hundreds of thousands of subscribers.
Yet it often feels as though YouTube only takes creators with more than a million subscribers seriously, while everyone else is treated as disposable.
YouTube knows it dominates long-form video, and that's exactly why we should support each other and help build a stronger long-form video community on X.
If people are willing to spend their time watching our work, then that work has value.
Viewers could also discover different kinds of content here.
And as people spend more time on X, they may naturally spend less time on YouTube.
In some ways, this is still an untapped market. That's why we should unite.
As for me, I create fairy-tale adaptations that aim to stay as faithful as possible to the original works of Giambattista Basile, Charles Perrault, and the Brothers Grimm.
My goal is to build a cinematic library of literary works.
I had only just been approved for YouTube monetization at the end of October, and then, on November 18, my monetization was removed.
If YouTube believed there was something wrong with my content from the beginning, why approve my channel for the YouTube Partner Program in the first place?
Later, I was told my content was repetitive.
But my Shorts are simply memorable scenes taken from my own original long-form films.
For example, the scene in Hansel and Gretel where the witch is pushed into the oven, or the magical transformation of Cinderella's pumpkin carriage.
These are exactly the kinds of attention-grabbing moments YouTube has always encouraged creators to use as hooks.
We're constantly told to put the most engaging moments at the beginning to capture viewers' attention.
Countless creators turn highlights from their long-form videos into Shorts.
And now we're being told that this is repetitive content?
YouTube is contradicting its own advice!
If you've experienced something similar, I encourage you to share your story too.
Let's start by bringing creators together here on X.
We shouldn't have to face this alone.
https://t.co/0KohZfzl9q
Let's follow and support one another, and help each other grow our long-form video channels on X!
Please also take a moment to read my post and the concerns I've raised. I hope we can work together, support each other, and stand up against YouTube's unfair treatment of creators.
Hello everyone.
I believe one of the main reasons many creators are moving to X is that YouTube has suddenly demonetized their channels without a clear explanation, leaving them with almost nowhere to turn when they try to appeal.
We shouldn't remain scattered, each of us complaining on our own. If we're willing to pay for X Premium and maintain our blue checkmarks, it means we still want to keep making videos and making our voices heard.
We're different from accounts that simply repost other people's content. Paying for X shows that we're serious creators who are willing to invest in our own work.
So I'd like to suggest a few things we can start doing together.
First, upload one of your older long-form videos every day. Our old videos are valuable assets. Reposting them also gives us an opportunity to share behind-the-scenes stories, explain our creative process, or add thoughts we didn't get to share before.
Second, tell people how YouTube treated you. Share your experiences, and include screenshots whenever possible. We can post about these experiences every day so more people understand that these aren't isolated incidents.
Third, follow and support one another. Watch each other's work. Building an audience and qualifying for long-form video monetization on X takes time, and supporting each other could help us establish another source of income here.
We need to organize if we want our voices to have real impact. If enough creators come together, perhaps we could even formally bring our concerns to Elon Musk's attention.
Right now, I believe X is probably the second-best platform for hosting long-form videos.
Facebook is another option, although without a paid membership barrier, content may be more vulnerable to unauthorized reposting. Still, it's worth trying.
There's also Kick, which currently focuses mainly on gaming and livestreaming. If its operators ever recognize this opportunity and welcome creators who produce narrative films, I believe it could gradually become another viable platform.
At the moment, I think X's biggest weakness is its relatively limited long-form video ecosystem.
Meanwhile, YouTube seems to be pushing away creators who genuinely invest their time and effort into producing long-form content.
This could be our opportunity to fill that gap and help expand long-form video content on X.
If we could eventually reach television audiences as well, we might finally stop being completely dependent on a single platform.
Many AI video creators have been demonetized for supposedly producing "repetitive content" or "template-based content."
But when the same person directs multiple films, of course there will be similarities in style!
You cannot expect emotionless AI systems to fairly judge works created with genuine human emotion.
Every creator has their own way of expressing feelings, and naturally, some patterns will appear across their work.
How can an AI system reliably determine whether those similarities make the content repetitive?
YouTube previously cut large numbers of employees, and now it seems to be relying on AI in ways that are causing chaos for smaller channels.
What makes this even worse is that demonetized channels can still upload videos, and their videos can still be watched with advertisements.
The creators receive nothing.
It feels like YouTube is deliberately encouraging people to work for free.
YouTube appears to want a subscription-driven business model similar to Netflix. On one hand, it encourages everyone to upload videos, opening the door to creative people beyond the traditional Hollywood industry.
On the other hand, its monetization decisions can leave those same creators providing content without compensation.
That's shameless.
To some extent, this reflects YouTube's dominance over long-form video. Platforms like TikTok, Xiaohongshu, and others simply don't have the same volume of long-form content.
Many demonetized creators have channels with tens of thousands or even hundreds of thousands of subscribers.
Yet it often feels as though YouTube only takes creators with more than a million subscribers seriously, while everyone else is treated as disposable.
YouTube knows it dominates long-form video, and that's exactly why we should support each other and help build a stronger long-form video community on X.
If people are willing to spend their time watching our work, then that work has value.
Viewers could also discover different kinds of content here.
And as people spend more time on X, they may naturally spend less time on YouTube.
In some ways, this is still an untapped market. That's why we should unite.
As for me, I create fairy-tale adaptations that aim to stay as faithful as possible to the original works of Giambattista Basile, Charles Perrault, and the Brothers Grimm.
My goal is to build a cinematic library of literary works.
I had only just been approved for YouTube monetization at the end of October, and then, on November 18, my monetization was removed.
If YouTube believed there was something wrong with my content from the beginning, why approve my channel for the YouTube Partner Program in the first place?
Later, I was told my content was repetitive.
But my Shorts are simply memorable scenes taken from my own original long-form films.
For example, the scene in Hansel and Gretel where the witch is pushed into the oven, or the magical transformation of Cinderella's pumpkin carriage.
These are exactly the kinds of attention-grabbing moments YouTube has always encouraged creators to use as hooks.
We're constantly told to put the most engaging moments at the beginning to capture viewers' attention.
Countless creators turn highlights from their long-form videos into Shorts.
And now we're being told that this is repetitive content?
YouTube is contradicting its own advice!
If you've experienced something similar, I encourage you to share your story too.
Let's start by bringing creators together here on X.
We shouldn't have to face this alone.
https://t.co/0KohZfzl9q
Let's follow and support one another, and help each other grow our long-form video channels on X!
Please also take a moment to read my post and the concerns I've raised. I hope we can work together, support each other, and stand up against YouTube's unfair treatment of creators.
Hello everyone.
I believe one of the main reasons many creators are moving to X is that YouTube has suddenly demonetized their channels without a clear explanation, leaving them with almost nowhere to turn when they try to appeal.
We shouldn't remain scattered, each of us complaining on our own. If we're willing to pay for X Premium and maintain our blue checkmarks, it means we still want to keep making videos and making our voices heard.
We're different from accounts that simply repost other people's content. Paying for X shows that we're serious creators who are willing to invest in our own work.
So I'd like to suggest a few things we can start doing together.
First, upload one of your older long-form videos every day. Our old videos are valuable assets. Reposting them also gives us an opportunity to share behind-the-scenes stories, explain our creative process, or add thoughts we didn't get to share before.
Second, tell people how YouTube treated you. Share your experiences, and include screenshots whenever possible. We can post about these experiences every day so more people understand that these aren't isolated incidents.
Third, follow and support one another. Watch each other's work. Building an audience and qualifying for long-form video monetization on X takes time, and supporting each other could help us establish another source of income here.
We need to organize if we want our voices to have real impact. If enough creators come together, perhaps we could even formally bring our concerns to Elon Musk's attention.
Right now, I believe X is probably the second-best platform for hosting long-form videos.
Facebook is another option, although without a paid membership barrier, content may be more vulnerable to unauthorized reposting. Still, it's worth trying.
There's also Kick, which currently focuses mainly on gaming and livestreaming. If its operators ever recognize this opportunity and welcome creators who produce narrative films, I believe it could gradually become another viable platform.
At the moment, I think X's biggest weakness is its relatively limited long-form video ecosystem.
Meanwhile, YouTube seems to be pushing away creators who genuinely invest their time and effort into producing long-form content.
This could be our opportunity to fill that gap and help expand long-form video content on X.
If we could eventually reach television audiences as well, we might finally stop being completely dependent on a single platform.
Many AI video creators have been demonetized for supposedly producing "repetitive content" or "template-based content."
But when the same person directs multiple films, of course there will be similarities in style!
You cannot expect emotionless AI systems to fairly judge works created with genuine human emotion.
Every creator has their own way of expressing feelings, and naturally, some patterns will appear across their work.
How can an AI system reliably determine whether those similarities make the content repetitive?
YouTube previously cut large numbers of employees, and now it seems to be relying on AI in ways that are causing chaos for smaller channels.
What makes this even worse is that demonetized channels can still upload videos, and their videos can still be watched with advertisements.
The creators receive nothing.
It feels like YouTube is deliberately encouraging people to work for free.
YouTube appears to want a subscription-driven business model similar to Netflix. On one hand, it encourages everyone to upload videos, opening the door to creative people beyond the traditional Hollywood industry.
On the other hand, its monetization decisions can leave those same creators providing content without compensation.
That's shameless.
To some extent, this reflects YouTube's dominance over long-form video. Platforms like TikTok, Xiaohongshu, and others simply don't have the same volume of long-form content.
Many demonetized creators have channels with tens of thousands or even hundreds of thousands of subscribers.
Yet it often feels as though YouTube only takes creators with more than a million subscribers seriously, while everyone else is treated as disposable.
YouTube knows it dominates long-form video, and that's exactly why we should support each other and help build a stronger long-form video community on X.
If people are willing to spend their time watching our work, then that work has value.
Viewers could also discover different kinds of content here.
And as people spend more time on X, they may naturally spend less time on YouTube.
In some ways, this is still an untapped market. That's why we should unite.
As for me, I create fairy-tale adaptations that aim to stay as faithful as possible to the original works of Giambattista Basile, Charles Perrault, and the Brothers Grimm.
My goal is to build a cinematic library of literary works.
I had only just been approved for YouTube monetization at the end of October, and then, on November 18, my monetization was removed.
If YouTube believed there was something wrong with my content from the beginning, why approve my channel for the YouTube Partner Program in the first place?
Later, I was told my content was repetitive.
But my Shorts are simply memorable scenes taken from my own original long-form films.
For example, the scene in Hansel and Gretel where the witch is pushed into the oven, or the magical transformation of Cinderella's pumpkin carriage.
These are exactly the kinds of attention-grabbing moments YouTube has always encouraged creators to use as hooks.
We're constantly told to put the most engaging moments at the beginning to capture viewers' attention.
Countless creators turn highlights from their long-form videos into Shorts.
And now we're being told that this is repetitive content?
YouTube is contradicting its own advice!
If you've experienced something similar, I encourage you to share your story too.
Let's start by bringing creators together here on X.
We shouldn't have to face this alone.
https://t.co/0KohZfzl9q
Let's follow and support one another, and help each other grow our long-form video channels on X!
Please also take a moment to read my post and the concerns I've raised. I hope we can work together, support each other, and stand up against YouTube's unfair treatment of creators.
Hello everyone.
I believe one of the main reasons many creators are moving to X is that YouTube has suddenly demonetized their channels without a clear explanation, leaving them with almost nowhere to turn when they try to appeal.
We shouldn't remain scattered, each of us complaining on our own. If we're willing to pay for X Premium and maintain our blue checkmarks, it means we still want to keep making videos and making our voices heard.
We're different from accounts that simply repost other people's content. Paying for X shows that we're serious creators who are willing to invest in our own work.
So I'd like to suggest a few things we can start doing together.
First, upload one of your older long-form videos every day. Our old videos are valuable assets. Reposting them also gives us an opportunity to share behind-the-scenes stories, explain our creative process, or add thoughts we didn't get to share before.
Second, tell people how YouTube treated you. Share your experiences, and include screenshots whenever possible. We can post about these experiences every day so more people understand that these aren't isolated incidents.
Third, follow and support one another. Watch each other's work. Building an audience and qualifying for long-form video monetization on X takes time, and supporting each other could help us establish another source of income here.
We need to organize if we want our voices to have real impact. If enough creators come together, perhaps we could even formally bring our concerns to Elon Musk's attention.
Right now, I believe X is probably the second-best platform for hosting long-form videos.
Facebook is another option, although without a paid membership barrier, content may be more vulnerable to unauthorized reposting. Still, it's worth trying.
There's also Kick, which currently focuses mainly on gaming and livestreaming. If its operators ever recognize this opportunity and welcome creators who produce narrative films, I believe it could gradually become another viable platform.
At the moment, I think X's biggest weakness is its relatively limited long-form video ecosystem.
Meanwhile, YouTube seems to be pushing away creators who genuinely invest their time and effort into producing long-form content.
This could be our opportunity to fill that gap and help expand long-form video content on X.
If we could eventually reach television audiences as well, we might finally stop being completely dependent on a single platform.
Many AI video creators have been demonetized for supposedly producing "repetitive content" or "template-based content."
But when the same person directs multiple films, of course there will be similarities in style!
You cannot expect emotionless AI systems to fairly judge works created with genuine human emotion.
Every creator has their own way of expressing feelings, and naturally, some patterns will appear across their work.
How can an AI system reliably determine whether those similarities make the content repetitive?
YouTube previously cut large numbers of employees, and now it seems to be relying on AI in ways that are causing chaos for smaller channels.
What makes this even worse is that demonetized channels can still upload videos, and their videos can still be watched with advertisements.
The creators receive nothing.
It feels like YouTube is deliberately encouraging people to work for free.
YouTube appears to want a subscription-driven business model similar to Netflix. On one hand, it encourages everyone to upload videos, opening the door to creative people beyond the traditional Hollywood industry.
On the other hand, its monetization decisions can leave those same creators providing content without compensation.
That's shameless.
To some extent, this reflects YouTube's dominance over long-form video. Platforms like TikTok, Xiaohongshu, and others simply don't have the same volume of long-form content.
Many demonetized creators have channels with tens of thousands or even hundreds of thousands of subscribers.
Yet it often feels as though YouTube only takes creators with more than a million subscribers seriously, while everyone else is treated as disposable.
YouTube knows it dominates long-form video, and that's exactly why we should support each other and help build a stronger long-form video community on X.
If people are willing to spend their time watching our work, then that work has value.
Viewers could also discover different kinds of content here.
And as people spend more time on X, they may naturally spend less time on YouTube.
In some ways, this is still an untapped market. That's why we should unite.
As for me, I create fairy-tale adaptations that aim to stay as faithful as possible to the original works of Giambattista Basile, Charles Perrault, and the Brothers Grimm.
My goal is to build a cinematic library of literary works.
I had only just been approved for YouTube monetization at the end of October, and then, on November 18, my monetization was removed.
If YouTube believed there was something wrong with my content from the beginning, why approve my channel for the YouTube Partner Program in the first place?
Later, I was told my content was repetitive.
But my Shorts are simply memorable scenes taken from my own original long-form films.
For example, the scene in Hansel and Gretel where the witch is pushed into the oven, or the magical transformation of Cinderella's pumpkin carriage.
These are exactly the kinds of attention-grabbing moments YouTube has always encouraged creators to use as hooks.
We're constantly told to put the most engaging moments at the beginning to capture viewers' attention.
Countless creators turn highlights from their long-form videos into Shorts.
And now we're being told that this is repetitive content?
YouTube is contradicting its own advice!
If you've experienced something similar, I encourage you to share your story too.
Let's start by bringing creators together here on X.
We shouldn't have to face this alone.
https://t.co/0KohZfzl9q
Let's follow and support one another, and help each other grow our long-form video channels on X!
Please also take a moment to read my post and the concerns I've raised. I hope we can work together, support each other, and stand up against YouTube's unfair treatment of creators.
Hello everyone.
I believe one of the main reasons many creators are moving to X is that YouTube has suddenly demonetized their channels without a clear explanation, leaving them with almost nowhere to turn when they try to appeal.
We shouldn't remain scattered, each of us complaining on our own. If we're willing to pay for X Premium and maintain our blue checkmarks, it means we still want to keep making videos and making our voices heard.
We're different from accounts that simply repost other people's content. Paying for X shows that we're serious creators who are willing to invest in our own work.
So I'd like to suggest a few things we can start doing together.
First, upload one of your older long-form videos every day. Our old videos are valuable assets. Reposting them also gives us an opportunity to share behind-the-scenes stories, explain our creative process, or add thoughts we didn't get to share before.
Second, tell people how YouTube treated you. Share your experiences, and include screenshots whenever possible. We can post about these experiences every day so more people understand that these aren't isolated incidents.
Third, follow and support one another. Watch each other's work. Building an audience and qualifying for long-form video monetization on X takes time, and supporting each other could help us establish another source of income here.
We need to organize if we want our voices to have real impact. If enough creators come together, perhaps we could even formally bring our concerns to Elon Musk's attention.
Right now, I believe X is probably the second-best platform for hosting long-form videos.
Facebook is another option, although without a paid membership barrier, content may be more vulnerable to unauthorized reposting. Still, it's worth trying.
There's also Kick, which currently focuses mainly on gaming and livestreaming. If its operators ever recognize this opportunity and welcome creators who produce narrative films, I believe it could gradually become another viable platform.
At the moment, I think X's biggest weakness is its relatively limited long-form video ecosystem.
Meanwhile, YouTube seems to be pushing away creators who genuinely invest their time and effort into producing long-form content.
This could be our opportunity to fill that gap and help expand long-form video content on X.
If we could eventually reach television audiences as well, we might finally stop being completely dependent on a single platform.
Many AI video creators have been demonetized for supposedly producing "repetitive content" or "template-based content."
But when the same person directs multiple films, of course there will be similarities in style!
You cannot expect emotionless AI systems to fairly judge works created with genuine human emotion.
Every creator has their own way of expressing feelings, and naturally, some patterns will appear across their work.
How can an AI system reliably determine whether those similarities make the content repetitive?
YouTube previously cut large numbers of employees, and now it seems to be relying on AI in ways that are causing chaos for smaller channels.
What makes this even worse is that demonetized channels can still upload videos, and their videos can still be watched with advertisements.
The creators receive nothing.
It feels like YouTube is deliberately encouraging people to work for free.
YouTube appears to want a subscription-driven business model similar to Netflix. On one hand, it encourages everyone to upload videos, opening the door to creative people beyond the traditional Hollywood industry.
On the other hand, its monetization decisions can leave those same creators providing content without compensation.
That's shameless.
To some extent, this reflects YouTube's dominance over long-form video. Platforms like TikTok, Xiaohongshu, and others simply don't have the same volume of long-form content.
Many demonetized creators have channels with tens of thousands or even hundreds of thousands of subscribers.
Yet it often feels as though YouTube only takes creators with more than a million subscribers seriously, while everyone else is treated as disposable.
YouTube knows it dominates long-form video, and that's exactly why we should support each other and help build a stronger long-form video community on X.
If people are willing to spend their time watching our work, then that work has value.
Viewers could also discover different kinds of content here.
And as people spend more time on X, they may naturally spend less time on YouTube.
In some ways, this is still an untapped market. That's why we should unite.
As for me, I create fairy-tale adaptations that aim to stay as faithful as possible to the original works of Giambattista Basile, Charles Perrault, and the Brothers Grimm.
My goal is to build a cinematic library of literary works.
I had only just been approved for YouTube monetization at the end of October, and then, on November 18, my monetization was removed.
If YouTube believed there was something wrong with my content from the beginning, why approve my channel for the YouTube Partner Program in the first place?
Later, I was told my content was repetitive.
But my Shorts are simply memorable scenes taken from my own original long-form films.
For example, the scene in Hansel and Gretel where the witch is pushed into the oven, or the magical transformation of Cinderella's pumpkin carriage.
These are exactly the kinds of attention-grabbing moments YouTube has always encouraged creators to use as hooks.
We're constantly told to put the most engaging moments at the beginning to capture viewers' attention.
Countless creators turn highlights from their long-form videos into Shorts.
And now we're being told that this is repetitive content?
YouTube is contradicting its own advice!
If you've experienced something similar, I encourage you to share your story too.
Let's start by bringing creators together here on X.
We shouldn't have to face this alone.
https://t.co/0KohZfzl9q
Let's follow and support one another, and help each other grow our long-form video channels on X!
Please also take a moment to read my post and the concerns I've raised. I hope we can work together, support each other, and stand up against YouTube's unfair treatment of creators.
Hello everyone.
I believe one of the main reasons many creators are moving to X is that YouTube has suddenly demonetized their channels without a clear explanation, leaving them with almost nowhere to turn when they try to appeal.
We shouldn't remain scattered, each of us complaining on our own. If we're willing to pay for X Premium and maintain our blue checkmarks, it means we still want to keep making videos and making our voices heard.
We're different from accounts that simply repost other people's content. Paying for X shows that we're serious creators who are willing to invest in our own work.
So I'd like to suggest a few things we can start doing together.
First, upload one of your older long-form videos every day. Our old videos are valuable assets. Reposting them also gives us an opportunity to share behind-the-scenes stories, explain our creative process, or add thoughts we didn't get to share before.
Second, tell people how YouTube treated you. Share your experiences, and include screenshots whenever possible. We can post about these experiences every day so more people understand that these aren't isolated incidents.
Third, follow and support one another. Watch each other's work. Building an audience and qualifying for long-form video monetization on X takes time, and supporting each other could help us establish another source of income here.
We need to organize if we want our voices to have real impact. If enough creators come together, perhaps we could even formally bring our concerns to Elon Musk's attention.
Right now, I believe X is probably the second-best platform for hosting long-form videos.
Facebook is another option, although without a paid membership barrier, content may be more vulnerable to unauthorized reposting. Still, it's worth trying.
There's also Kick, which currently focuses mainly on gaming and livestreaming. If its operators ever recognize this opportunity and welcome creators who produce narrative films, I believe it could gradually become another viable platform.
At the moment, I think X's biggest weakness is its relatively limited long-form video ecosystem.
Meanwhile, YouTube seems to be pushing away creators who genuinely invest their time and effort into producing long-form content.
This could be our opportunity to fill that gap and help expand long-form video content on X.
If we could eventually reach television audiences as well, we might finally stop being completely dependent on a single platform.
Many AI video creators have been demonetized for supposedly producing "repetitive content" or "template-based content."
But when the same person directs multiple films, of course there will be similarities in style!
You cannot expect emotionless AI systems to fairly judge works created with genuine human emotion.
Every creator has their own way of expressing feelings, and naturally, some patterns will appear across their work.
How can an AI system reliably determine whether those similarities make the content repetitive?
YouTube previously cut large numbers of employees, and now it seems to be relying on AI in ways that are causing chaos for smaller channels.
What makes this even worse is that demonetized channels can still upload videos, and their videos can still be watched with advertisements.
The creators receive nothing.
It feels like YouTube is deliberately encouraging people to work for free.
YouTube appears to want a subscription-driven business model similar to Netflix. On one hand, it encourages everyone to upload videos, opening the door to creative people beyond the traditional Hollywood industry.
On the other hand, its monetization decisions can leave those same creators providing content without compensation.
That's shameless.
To some extent, this reflects YouTube's dominance over long-form video. Platforms like TikTok, Xiaohongshu, and others simply don't have the same volume of long-form content.
Many demonetized creators have channels with tens of thousands or even hundreds of thousands of subscribers.
Yet it often feels as though YouTube only takes creators with more than a million subscribers seriously, while everyone else is treated as disposable.
YouTube knows it dominates long-form video, and that's exactly why we should support each other and help build a stronger long-form video community on X.
If people are willing to spend their time watching our work, then that work has value.
Viewers could also discover different kinds of content here.
And as people spend more time on X, they may naturally spend less time on YouTube.
In some ways, this is still an untapped market. That's why we should unite.
As for me, I create fairy-tale adaptations that aim to stay as faithful as possible to the original works of Giambattista Basile, Charles Perrault, and the Brothers Grimm.
My goal is to build a cinematic library of literary works.
I had only just been approved for YouTube monetization at the end of October, and then, on November 18, my monetization was removed.
If YouTube believed there was something wrong with my content from the beginning, why approve my channel for the YouTube Partner Program in the first place?
Later, I was told my content was repetitive.
But my Shorts are simply memorable scenes taken from my own original long-form films.
For example, the scene in Hansel and Gretel where the witch is pushed into the oven, or the magical transformation of Cinderella's pumpkin carriage.
These are exactly the kinds of attention-grabbing moments YouTube has always encouraged creators to use as hooks.
We're constantly told to put the most engaging moments at the beginning to capture viewers' attention.
Countless creators turn highlights from their long-form videos into Shorts.
And now we're being told that this is repetitive content?
YouTube is contradicting its own advice!
If you've experienced something similar, I encourage you to share your story too.
Let's start by bringing creators together here on X.
We shouldn't have to face this alone.
https://t.co/0KohZfzl9q
Let's follow and support one another, and help each other grow our long-form video channels on X!
Please also take a moment to read my post and the concerns I've raised. I hope we can work together, support each other, and stand up against YouTube's unfair treatment of creators.
Hello everyone.
I believe one of the main reasons many creators are moving to X is that YouTube has suddenly demonetized their channels without a clear explanation, leaving them with almost nowhere to turn when they try to appeal.
We shouldn't remain scattered, each of us complaining on our own. If we're willing to pay for X Premium and maintain our blue checkmarks, it means we still want to keep making videos and making our voices heard.
We're different from accounts that simply repost other people's content. Paying for X shows that we're serious creators who are willing to invest in our own work.
So I'd like to suggest a few things we can start doing together.
First, upload one of your older long-form videos every day. Our old videos are valuable assets. Reposting them also gives us an opportunity to share behind-the-scenes stories, explain our creative process, or add thoughts we didn't get to share before.
Second, tell people how YouTube treated you. Share your experiences, and include screenshots whenever possible. We can post about these experiences every day so more people understand that these aren't isolated incidents.
Third, follow and support one another. Watch each other's work. Building an audience and qualifying for long-form video monetization on X takes time, and supporting each other could help us establish another source of income here.
We need to organize if we want our voices to have real impact. If enough creators come together, perhaps we could even formally bring our concerns to Elon Musk's attention.
Right now, I believe X is probably the second-best platform for hosting long-form videos.
Facebook is another option, although without a paid membership barrier, content may be more vulnerable to unauthorized reposting. Still, it's worth trying.
There's also Kick, which currently focuses mainly on gaming and livestreaming. If its operators ever recognize this opportunity and welcome creators who produce narrative films, I believe it could gradually become another viable platform.
At the moment, I think X's biggest weakness is its relatively limited long-form video ecosystem.
Meanwhile, YouTube seems to be pushing away creators who genuinely invest their time and effort into producing long-form content.
This could be our opportunity to fill that gap and help expand long-form video content on X.
If we could eventually reach television audiences as well, we might finally stop being completely dependent on a single platform.
Many AI video creators have been demonetized for supposedly producing "repetitive content" or "template-based content."
But when the same person directs multiple films, of course there will be similarities in style!
You cannot expect emotionless AI systems to fairly judge works created with genuine human emotion.
Every creator has their own way of expressing feelings, and naturally, some patterns will appear across their work.
How can an AI system reliably determine whether those similarities make the content repetitive?
YouTube previously cut large numbers of employees, and now it seems to be relying on AI in ways that are causing chaos for smaller channels.
What makes this even worse is that demonetized channels can still upload videos, and their videos can still be watched with advertisements.
The creators receive nothing.
It feels like YouTube is deliberately encouraging people to work for free.
YouTube appears to want a subscription-driven business model similar to Netflix. On one hand, it encourages everyone to upload videos, opening the door to creative people beyond the traditional Hollywood industry.
On the other hand, its monetization decisions can leave those same creators providing content without compensation.
That's shameless.
To some extent, this reflects YouTube's dominance over long-form video. Platforms like TikTok, Xiaohongshu, and others simply don't have the same volume of long-form content.
Many demonetized creators have channels with tens of thousands or even hundreds of thousands of subscribers.
Yet it often feels as though YouTube only takes creators with more than a million subscribers seriously, while everyone else is treated as disposable.
YouTube knows it dominates long-form video, and that's exactly why we should support each other and help build a stronger long-form video community on X.
If people are willing to spend their time watching our work, then that work has value.
Viewers could also discover different kinds of content here.
And as people spend more time on X, they may naturally spend less time on YouTube.
In some ways, this is still an untapped market. That's why we should unite.
As for me, I create fairy-tale adaptations that aim to stay as faithful as possible to the original works of Giambattista Basile, Charles Perrault, and the Brothers Grimm.
My goal is to build a cinematic library of literary works.
I had only just been approved for YouTube monetization at the end of October, and then, on November 18, my monetization was removed.
If YouTube believed there was something wrong with my content from the beginning, why approve my channel for the YouTube Partner Program in the first place?
Later, I was told my content was repetitive.
But my Shorts are simply memorable scenes taken from my own original long-form films.
For example, the scene in Hansel and Gretel where the witch is pushed into the oven, or the magical transformation of Cinderella's pumpkin carriage.
These are exactly the kinds of attention-grabbing moments YouTube has always encouraged creators to use as hooks.
We're constantly told to put the most engaging moments at the beginning to capture viewers' attention.
Countless creators turn highlights from their long-form videos into Shorts.
And now we're being told that this is repetitive content?
YouTube is contradicting its own advice!
If you've experienced something similar, I encourage you to share your story too.
Let's start by bringing creators together here on X.
We shouldn't have to face this alone.