@LegalManFC Interesting - I would assume that “they erred in fact” would fail on its face; the panel was the fact finder. But I’m assuming a standard of review (any evidence, clear error) that we don’t know. I’m so glad I don’t have to think about this without a premier league title.
@LegalManFC One thing I think we do know is that city’s appeal seems to rest largely on questions of fact. Typically appellate proceedings leave fact finding to the lower “court” - do we know if that’s the case with the premier league appeals process?
@LegalManFC Ok this is as I would have expected. No de novo review, which means this decision does matter, at least at some point in my children’s lives
@LegalManFC And then in my mind that appeal would be basically only considering whether the panel/league applied the rules as agreed during proceedings, not a place for new defenses or findings of fact.
@LegalManFC Procedurally, where does this stand? My (admittedly very basic) understanding is that this was an independent panel, which would imply this is all just under PL dispute resolution procedure. An appeal would then go…to a court? CAS? Or am I just completely wrong? (Likely)
@LegalManFC I’m actually desperate for a deep dive on precedence amongst these rules, distinction from or comparison with the Ronaldo decision, just the legal technicalities. We all know what happened, but whether there’s a colourable argument that they can do this? That’s the good stuff
@Flannyballs Oh man now I’m thinking of posting in a Facebook group about Eboue and it’s really hitting me how long it has been. Miss you in this corner of the internet
@YankeeGunner Deference to the decision made with less information has always been the worst part of replay. NFL seems to have learned this (though not officially stated), but VAR really needs to
@notthefakeSVP Kurkjian Baltimore accents, Dump, the Duke, naked grandma, literally anything from a mailbag - that’s just five seconds off the top of the head. Those who got it, loved it.
@LegalManFC Apologies if this is completely irrelevant, but how (if at all) does the Webster case (CAS 2007/A/1300) play into this, or indeed anything at all these days? I remember thinking it would be as groundbreaking as Bosman, but I had to go look it up to even remember the name
@YankeeGunner The commentary/VAR finding ways to explain why inconsistent calls are both correct just reminds me of a 1L contracts class where a kid hasn’t done the reading, can’t argue one side, then is asked to argue the opposing side, and just melts in a puddle
@daniel_knauf@Starlink Same problems in the English countryside until Starlink - now more consistent than anything I ever had in the U.S. or London. You won’t look back
@SethWEmerson Missed having the real-time thoughts here during this game. Any reason you’ve been MIA for a few days or is this a longer term change to adjust to?
@LouGillis91@BLegend247@LH_440@ESPNFantasy@ESPN_ff@ESPNFANSUPPORT@FieldYates@YahooFantasy It’s not a ST play until the ball is kicked. If they lose yards or gain them or score a TD they are the offense. Once the ball is kicked, they become special teams. That’s why a QB can punt - the action of kicking makes it a special teams play, not the name on the jersey
@SayItOutLoudSp1 @EricBartel@YahooFantasy@espn@ESPNFantasy If the offense fumbles a snap it’s not on the D/ST, and until the ball is kicked that is still the offense. That’s why a fake FG for a TD isnt credited to the D/ST, but if the QB tried to punt and got it blocked for a TD it would count for the D/ST