I'll weigh in here.
Football announcers in both college and the NFL in today's world are far more knowledgeable about rules than they have ever been in my lifetime. They are also more supportive of officiating than they have ever been.
The three announcing crews I regularly work with are incredibly strong on their knowledge of the rules, which (fortunately?) minimizes the times I need to speak.
Sometimes the rules get very complex and announcers do get it wrong, but sometimes the officials, including Replay, get it wrong and announcers are obliged to point it out especially when rules are involved rather than real-time judgments.
Judgments are always open for debate, but as I said, today's announcers are very deferential to judgments by officials and almost always extremeley fair.
If Commissioner Sankey and the SEC believe announcers are treating SEC officiating unfairly, I would suggest reaching out and working with their broadcast partners on rules/officiating would be far more effective than a broadside attack such as this.
@finebaum@GregSankey announcers and rules analysts on the broadcast don’t have to answer to you. They call it how they see it. If you don’t want the public to listen to them, give inside access to the review process. Try pointing a thumb at yourself instead of pointing fingers at others
The official’s signal as we see here makes this an even more interesting play.
College football has a silly rule that an inadvertent signal causes the ball to become dead.
If the ball is then recovered in the immediate continuing action, Replay can award the recovering team the ball at the spot of recovery.
If it is not, because it was ruled a fumble, the offense can either take the ball at the spot of the fumble or repeat the down at the previous spot.
It’s highly subjective but I don’t see this as a clear recovery as players must react immediately and they must be in the vicinity of the loose ball.
Obviously Musselman didn’t grab the guys phone, but players and staff reflect their head coach. Watched this game and Arkansas players crying and stomping after every foul call. Totally lost their composure and blew a huge lead. Biggest clown in CBB
Watching Big 10 basketball game: dude gets hacked while shooting, no foul
Watching SEC basketball game: phantom whistles on every possession. Come on @SECOfficiating
2,000 retweets and @GaryPinkel & myself will go half and bring Bengals back to Mizzou campus! 🙃🐯
First 100 get to ride on GP boat with me at the lake for Memorial weekend! 😎