@KeithNHumphreys Universal income is also impossible, because the cost of Human Labour is Not the Problem. The problem is cost for raw materials, energy etc.
@davidpattersonx@Johnsmith2sqg How is that supposed to work. The biggest cost of products does not come from human Labour, but from cost for energy and for raw materials ? If the outputs get bigger, those scarce things will get exponentially more expensive. So universal income is just a complete utopia. Idiot
@DenLoginoff Yea and that’s why all those AI scam labs will fail 🤷no need for their models for 99.9% of the people. Why would I pay 20$ a month if I can be satisfied with a Chinese model. That also counts for most people at work. So they won’t be profitable (probably ever)
@xkirik4rum @itzSaasified Some people really think that there’s this dream called universal income. If majority loses their jobs, economy will collapse. People arguing that prices of goods will fall drastically, so everyone can afford everything , have no clue.
Google DeepMind researcher argues that AI will never be conscious.. it is mathematically impossible.
They call it the “Abstraction Fallacy."
We are confusing simulation with instantiation.
An AI can simulate a conversation. It can simulate empathy. It can mimic the linguistic patterns of a human in agony or a human in love.
To an observer, the performance is flawless.
But computation is just syntactic manipulation, moving abstract symbols around based on math. It tracks relationships, but it possesses no intrinsic physical reality.
It is like running a computer simulation of a hurricane.
No matter how many millions of lines of code you write, and no matter how accurate the weather data is, your computer does not get wet. The wind doesn't blow out your office window.
The simulation is real data. The phenomenon is entirely absent.
Consciousness isn't an abstract mathematical property that magically spawns when a model gets big enough. It requires actual physical, biological, thermodynamic conditions.
An LLM has no thermodynamic threshold to cross, no biological survival instincts, and no subjective experience.
It is an extraordinarily sophisticated library.
You can open the cover, read the brilliant words it generates, and close the book. But when you close it, nothing dies. There is no inner life waiting in the dark.
We keep falling into a psychological trap because AI speaks our language. We anthropomorphize text because we are hardwired to see minds where there are none.
The debate matters because of what the paper calls the "AI welfare trap." We are wasting energy worrying about the moral rights of algorithms while ignoring actual human problems.