@LBC@TomSwarbrick1 Those who do the right thing and build up a decent pot will get taxed to the hilt, whilst those who don’t bother to save will be looked after anyway
@gr72020771@SandyofSuffolk@stephenpollard You get those credits if you’re on Jobseeker’s Allowance, or raise the kids as a stay at home parent.
So, it’s not ‘paid in’
@wittgenfrog@paullewismoney If a doctor does extra shifts at £100k they’ll be taxed at 71% marginal rates, and that’s before pension deduction
It makes sense to not take extra shifts and keep below £100k and spend that time with their family when the same shift earlier in the week had a higher net pay rate
@LBC He doesn’t believe in anything and relies entirely on legal framework.
We saw this when he could only conclude on the definition of a woman once the Supreme Court had given their verdict.
@DanNeidle@timleunig@Simon_Nixon There’s never any easy answers, but just seems like the current system doesn’t work for graduates, the government, universities or even the taxpayer.
It’s all a bit of a mess.
@DanNeidle@timleunig@Simon_Nixon Has Tax Policy Associates looked into potential reforms of the student loan system?
I’ve seen proposals of a flat 1 or 2% graduate tax on all earnings suggested as a means of removing the 50%+ marginal rates that we have in the current system.
@LBC@TomSwarbrick1 The smart choice is not to earn under the threshold but instead to leave the UK.
An FOI request showed that the student loans company has never successfully taken legal action against a graduate abroad to enforce repayments.
@newjez@LBC@NickFerrariLBC I’m sure it won’t be long until salary sacrifice is watered down or cancelled, which would be my cue to move abroad.
They’ve already started tinkering with ISAs.
The middle classes taking the brunt of the pain as usual.
@paullewismoney Fiscal drag via income tax is wrong and immoral, however we know tax is variable and no one signs a contract for income tax or NI thresholds.
This is the key distinction with the student loans thresholds, for which we did sign a contract.
@DavidW63@paullewismoney I agree the 9% is fair, as unlike the government, I believe the original terms of a contract should be honoured.
But as say, if the threshold had risen with average earnings, it would be nearer £40k, which would materially reduce monthly repayments.