Bore off! Tell us your answer instead of trying to point-score.
I've rewritten it for you:
UK long-term borrowing costs have reached extremely high levels. Part of that is a global bond-market sell-off, with borrowing costs also rising sharply in the US, France, Germany and elsewhere, and part reflects UK-specific concerns about inflation, debt and the public finances.
The UK's 30-year gilt yield going above 6% is serious. But pretending it is simply the consequence of Andy Burnham, or that today's gilt move suddenly created a £300m-a-day debt-interest bill, isn't serious economics.
That debt-interest bill reflects decades of accumulated borrowing, inflation-linked debt and previous interest-rate decisions. Higher yields today become a bigger problem if they persist, because refinancing existing debt and issuing new debt becomes increasingly expensive.
That means the Government faces difficult choices about taxation, spending, and borrowing. It also makes economic growth and productivity even more important, because you can't sustainably improve the debt position simply by moving money from one column of the spreadsheet to another.
So what would you actually do?
Cut spending? Where and by how much?
Raise taxes? Which ones?
Borrow less? Which investment would you cancel?
Or what is your plan for increasing growth whilst bringing borrowing and debt-interest costs under control?
Pointing at the problem is easy. The interesting bit is the answer.
I grew up feeling like I was a European citizen. Then one day I was told I wasn't. It's like someone telling me I could only think of myself as English. Truly sickening. I still feel bereft to this day. I also think we could make something of Brexit, but I don't think the international system will allow us to.
In mid-August, I shared that ChatGPT was hiding "view sources" behind the overflow menu. Well, now I'm seeing a different treatment in the free version of ChatGPT. It's much better and sources are visible by default and named just "Sources". But in my paid account, I still see sources hidden behind the overflow menu. You need to click the three dots to see "view sources". Here is the new treatment in the free version:
Ah, so we’ve finally got the answer: if Falklanders won’t accept Argentine rule, you think they should be removed from the country their families have lived in for generations and “sent back” to Britain.
That’s not liberation. That’s forced population displacement.
The Falklands had no indigenous population for British settlers to replace. The people living there today are Falklanders. It’s their home. Their wishes matter.
You can call the islands Malvinas. You can claim the territory. But if your solution to the people saying “no” is “they can leave”, then the democratic problem with your position is pretty obvious. 🇫🇰
You’ve completely changed the argument. 😂
I was talking about Brits and Chileans and Argentinians moving to the Falklands, building lives there and choosing to become Falklanders. You’ve somehow turned that into “mass migration from the Islamic third world”.
And those maps don’t prove what you think they prove either. A map showing differences between countries in innovation, development or test scores is not a map of innate racial ability. Countries differ enormously in education, institutions, wealth, health, political stability, infrastructure and history. You can’t colour in a map and announce you’ve discovered genetics.
More importantly, I never argued that every culture or every immigration policy produces identical outcomes. Obviously they don’t. That’s precisely why immigration can be selective.
My argument is much simpler: somebody from Chile or Argentina who voluntarily moves to the Falklands, works, contributes, embraces its institutions, raises Falklander children and chooses British sovereignty can become part of that nation.
I think the Anglo-Western civilisation is strong enough to assimilate people who genuinely want to join it. You apparently think it is so fragile that it requires genetic purity to survive. I’m not sure I’m the one lacking confidence in Western civilisation there. 🇬🇧🇫🇰
That's an interesting response to someone who has just argued for building a larger, richer and more fiercely British Falklands. 😂
I don't think Britishness is a skin colour. Apparently you do.
Someone from Chile or Argentina who moves to the Falklands, builds a life there, embraces the country and becomes a Falklander isn't causing “civilisational suicide”. They're helping build the civilisation.
Nations aren't preserved by keeping everyone genetically identical. They're preserved by having a culture people actually want to join, defend and pass on.
I want more people choosing Britishness, not fewer. 🇬🇧🇫🇰
Geography isn't sovereignty.
But you've actually answered my question now. Your position is that the wishes of the Falkland Islanders don't matter because you regard them as an “implanted population”.
That's the fundamental difference between us. I think people have the right to determine which country governs them. You think Argentina's territorial claim overrides their wishes.
So what happens to the Falkland Islanders if they continue to refuse Argentine sovereignty?
There's just one rather important problem with that.
The people who actually live there don't want to be Argentine.
In the 2013 referendum, 99.8% voted to remain a British Overseas Territory.
You can call the Falklamds Malvinas all you want. You can call its people pirates. You can put 🇦🇷 after the name.
But you haven't explained why Argentina's territorial claim should matter more than the democratic wishes of the people who live there.
I get that. And I can see why people who love the Falklands as they are would be wary of turning them into something unrecognisable.
But “nice as it is” is also a luxury created by British defence, fisheries income and a very unusual geopolitical settlement.
My point isn’t to cover the islands in tower blocks. It’s that if we genuinely believe their future is British, we should be thinking about how to make that future economically, demographically and strategically secure for the next 100 years.
That probably means some growth. The real argument is over how much, where and on whose terms.
@AngloAmerican85@BasilTheGreat 😂 Touché.
British by birth. American by choice. Glock by constitutional right.
I'm beginning to think putting you in charge of the Falklands Defence Force might result in Argentina voluntarily moving another 300 miles further west!
🇫🇰🇬🇧🇺🇸
And I think you've just identified the fundamental problem with Argentina's position.
Argentina doesn't want the Falklanders.
It wants the Falklands.
People whose families have lived there for up to nine generations are simply expected to pack their bags and "go back" to Britain.
But Britain isn't their home.
The Falklands are.
Which is why my answer is the exact opposite.
Don't leave.
Stay. Build. Grow.
And let's make sure there are tens of thousands more Falklanders. In another nine generations, that could be hundreds of thousands or even millions!. 🇫🇰🇬🇧
I think the oil has definitely changed the calculation.
Sea Lion has actually already passed Final Investment Decision and is heading towards first oil in 2028.
And Milei's reaction tells us something important.
The Falklands are becoming considerably more valuable.
Which is exactly why Britain and the Falkland Islanders need to think much bigger now.
Don't just extract the oil.
Use the wealth it creates to transform the islands.
Housing. Infrastructure. Ports. Energy. Businesses. New settlements. Tens of thousands more people.
Turn the Falklands into a wealthy, increasingly self-sufficient South Atlantic country.
Oil shouldn't just make the Falklands richer.
It should help make them permanent. 🇫🇰🇬🇧
And this is the bit I can never get past.
“They don't have the right to choose.”
Forget Britain for a moment.
You're talking about people born on those islands, whose parents, grandparents and in some cases generations before them were born there.
And your position is that YOU get to decide their nationality and government, but THEY don't.
You don't want to persuade the Falklanders to become Argentine.
You want their opinion to be irrelevant.
That's not liberation.
That's annexation.