Unlike the other painful demolitions of the era, I think this change is ultimately for the better. You can still take side roads up to St. Peter's, but it's actually a disappointing way to approach the basilica, in my opinion. The Via della Conciliazione adds more dignity in the final approach for both pilgrims/visitors and the edifice itself. And, even with the open approach, you most assuredly still get a moment of "wow" and amazement as the magnitude and scale of the colonnade opens up before you at the end. Even a purely casual observer looking at the old arrangement would instantly and intuitively see how odd it was to have the central path occupied by buildings, and how beautiful it would be to have a clear boulevard connecting St. Peter's to the Tiber and Castel Sant'Angelo. I don't think this is like Piazza Venezia; I know history was bulldozed here, but this change feels quite a bit like common sense. In America, they bulldozed many buildings around Independence Hall to give Independence Hall more civic prestige, and of course they'll bulldoze around Sagrada Familia for the same reason. And, given the extraordinary number of pilgrims/tourists who visit the Vatican each day by foot, it also just seems eminently pragmatic from an urban planning perspective.