So those who do wish to sleep with teenagers as an older adult are nonces? Because all I did is ask the question, I didn't call anyone anything.
It worked better when society had a moral grounding and everyone got married but that's sadly not the case anymore.
The details are what they are. If you disagree then explain why.
It's not the business of a middle aged man which you specified. The legislation helps to protect them from those men. Don't ignore the nuanced points I'm making and keep trying to drag it back into a binary that doesn't exist.
It is staggered so that they have autonomy which is reasonable, but otherwise I agree that adults should not be targeting teenagers for sex.
We're circling back to the reason that there is a staggering which you are wilfully ignoring.
@LaughalotL86018@JackHadders It's not his business and yes they should. I'm a bit confused as to what you're disagreeing with here...
Legislating to protect those 16 and 17 year olds means further deterrence and convictions if they are taken advantage of.
But the staggered approach is evidently reasonable, otherwise how do you fix the scenario I gave?
I think sexual relationships as an adult rather than a teenager is a good thing and I'd agree with that as a binary in its own right, but in reality as a policy the nuance does matter for older teenagers. The proposal accommodates for that whilst achieving the main goal which is to protect the vulnerable against older adults with bad intentions.
@basebaritone@Silkysanch0@Tom_Rowsell They still can for people up to 3 years older than them. That's why it's called a staggered proposal. The focus is on older adults.
Read into the staggered approach and I think you might change your mind somewhat.
Please elaborate...
Anyone that disagrees with this proposal cannot describe why they want older adults to continue to be able to do this. If you disagree even after understanding the detail then that's what you're arguing for. It's quite simple.
Perhaps Barry being gay has something to do with it, who knows.
@LaughalotL86018@JackHadders If it wasn't staggered then teenagers would be unjustly imprisoned just for having relationships at a young age. For example an 18 year old sleeping with a 17 year old. That's just unworkable.
It would be stupid without staggering...
That's allowed technically as well as a relationship but sexual consent cannot be granted. I don't see a problem with them having to wait, it encourages a genuine connection which improves safety and the relationship itself.
That's not the idea being pushed, it's just a protective mechanism because we all know that the exceptions do not disprove the rule, that in most cases the younger person is the one being influenced, not the other way around.
Yes but that literally never happens anymore because the concept of marriage and the strength of our Christian belief system has been immensely damaged, so the framing of protection is different today. Committing to someone for life through marriage also creates inherent safety and security which differs from a more casual relationship. Just because we used to marry younger due to the cultural differences mentioned above, doesn't mean we have to be sexually liberal at those ages now which present different dangers.
We already legislate in this regard to protect children and girls. This is actually a minor but very sensible change to what is fundamentally a moral question.
It's purely about sexual consent, not legislating for "relationships" more broadly.
What's so hard about leaving 16 and 17 year olds alone sexually as an older adult? What about that is so difficult to accept?
You literally started this thread by calling me a name and now you're drawing a ridiculous equivalence with whether we should legalise homosexuality or not.
If we were to accept your rationale that would mean stating that paedophilia is bad but we shouldn't legislate to criminalise it...
Woeful.
Discrepancies aside and if it was illegal to do so then yes don't do it.
Why can't a 21 year old focus on adults who are 18+? Is that so hard? Rather than targeting girls still in their first year of sixth form...
Otherwise they can wait for a while, something we used to do for years before marriage which conditioned societal control and morality. It encourages relationships that are not based solely on lust and sex, that of which has destroyed much of how stable our societies used to be.
Throwing fringe hypotheticals out there and not thinking about the more meaningful consequences of it is in fact retarded.
Clearly nothing would happen if consent existed. Without knowing the exact detail of that legal scenario I would assume that discrepancy applies and that when they say 3 years they do not mean a hard cut off rendering relationships illegal for a few months...
And no it doesn't, men and women can be exploited at any age but adults have a responsibility to protect children and teenagers. Supporting the proposals doesn't mean arguing for legal consent to be extended into adulthood... I'm not arguing for that.
And no, if someone is being exploited then legal protection exists for that at any age, just not as a default which is what this proposal is doing. I don't see how that scenario is relevant to what these proposals are trying to do?
Supporting one piece of legislation doesn't mean I support a nanny state. That's just a silly slopulist way of addressing the issue if you disagree with it.
We're talking about something which is societally extremely important and which actually helps to suppress the liberal chaotic culture we live in - sex has been liberalised to toxic ends that is damaging young people and society as a whole so something that protects the sanctity of it and makes it less important during formative years is a good thing. I want vastly less regulation and state intervention but not all policy is bad and something as fundamental as this stands on its own feet outside of the nonsense such as the Millburn review which is completely moronic, impractical and damaging.